Let's Talk Fish! We are going LIVE with Jay Hemdal! Submit your questions here!

revhtree

Owner Administrator
View Badges
Joined
May 8, 2006
Messages
55,211
Reaction score
123,854
Seller Rating
5 ★
Rating Count
1
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
We are going LIVE with Jay Hemdal!
Date and time TBA.

@Jay Hemdal will be talking about all things fish, fish disease, public aquariums and more based on your suggestions here in this thread, as well as some of the LIVE questions that come up.

Jay Hemdal has kept aquarium fish since he was four. He set up his first marine aquarium in 1968 when he was nine years old. He later worked part time for many years at various local retail pet stores and fish wholesale companies while he was living at home and then during college. After graduating from college with a degree in aquatic biology, he managed the aquarium department of a large retail pet store for five years until 1985, when he was hired as an aquarist/diver (and later department manager) for a large public aquarium. In 1989, he accepted the position of curator of fishes and invertebrates for another public aquarium, where he remains today. Jay has written over 200 articles and papers as well as seven books since 1981.

1782749792876.png


Tell us what you want to talk about!
 
It's so awesome that R2R is doing more of these live streams! I hope we can find a way to expand the audience/advertising to new reefers. a couple questions from me:

  • What is one fish that you always regret adding to you tank, and one fish that you never regret adding?
  • What are the easiest ways to tell if your fish are happy and healthy?
 
We are going LIVE with Jay Hemdal!
Date and time TBA.

Jay Hemdal has kept aquarium fish since he was four.
Tell us what you want to talk about!
Why did you wait until you were 4 to start? 😂

Let me think about this, I trust he will be asked to discuss QT set ups, options, and tools for QT that help make it work. Maybe some of the thoughts and theories why QT in the first place?

This is gonna be a good event!
 
YAY, another one of these is great to hear!

Few questions

What made you even get into the hobby?

The most commonly misidentified fish disease?

What is something you find that every reefer should have stocked in their tanks at all times?
 
Jay, you're one of the most valuable people on R2R when it comes to fish diseases. I can't thank you enough for helping me diagnose and treat several of my fish.

My question is about how hyposalinity and copper affect parasites, and when treatment periods need to be extended if therapeutic levels aren't maintained. I often hear conflicting info on this.

For hypo, if salinity rises above the therapeutic limit, like 1.009 -> 1.010 for ich or 1.012 -> 1.013 for flukes, how long is that considered safe before we need to extend treatment? 1 hour? 4 hours? 12 hours?

Same for copper: if it drops below 2 ppm, when would you say the 30-day clock needs to restart or be extended?

Thanks in advance! :)
 
So we're going to switch it up a bit by taking some questions from this thread and some via the live chat in this thread and on youtube.
 
My question is: when your fish are acting abnormally, what's your process for diagnosing the problem?
 
Jay, what are some of the most often seen beginner mistakes when it comes to meds and quarantine procedures?

I used to not quarantine. But I really wanted some ich sensitive fish, such as a powder blue and brown. I went fallow, QT’d everything wet, and have never seen any indication of ich being present in my system due to anal management of what goes in and out of the tank. All my sensitive fish are just fine now, and I believes with your help I have a truly ich free system.

Even macro algae, snails, and corals receive strict QT treatment!
 
Love the idea

- Acclimation techniques for fish with 4-6 hours shipping time vs 12-24 hours.
- quarantining fish schools like 20-30 anthias. Same or multiple tanks. Intro to display tricks abd issues when the separated groups of a school of fish have been quarantined separately. If quarantined in same tabk what tank size and filtration is recommended and do you do daily water changes and top off meds ?
-how to deal with fish that arrive with ammonia toxicity. Hyperventilating and jumping out of water in the bag or right after bag is opened.
 
@Jay Hemdal I'm a big believer in QT'ing, and I personally follow your protocol for QT'ing new fish. I also QT all other critters separately, as best as I can, and I follow just about all of your posts here on R2R 🙂

Thank you for doing this live stream!!

The one that Randy did recently was very good, so, you know, no pressure 🤣 🙃 🤪

The push-back to QT'ing your own livestock that I know you hear daily is, "I don't have room", or, "I don't have the extra equipment".

How would you address this? Could you elaborate on what you'd need as a minimum QT tank, and as simple/inexpensive as it can be?

For those that still don't want to QT at home, could you please address what to look for from a fish vendor? Many, say that they QT, but that's little more than a week or two of "observation". There are online vendors that specialize in selling pre-QT'd fish, what would you expect from such vendors? What questions would you ask before purchasing fish from a vendor that says that they QT fish?

Thanks again @Jay Hemdal for doing the live stream 🙂
 
YAY, another one of these is great to hear!

Few questions

What made you even get into the hobby?

The most commonly misidentified fish disease?

What is something you find that every reefer should have stocked in their tanks at all times?

Hi,

I'm working through the posted questions and wondered if you could help me by clarifying this question you posed?

What is something you find that every reefer should have stocked in their tanks at all times?

Do you mean some animal that reefers need to stock in their tanks, or some product that they should have on hand to handle isues?

Thanks,

Jay
 
What fish do not belong in home aquaria and fish species are most prone to be imported/ultimately sold with high parasite loads.
 
Do fish ever get stunted growth in smaller tanks instead of outgrowing them?

Good question, one with a fairly complicated answer - stay tuned!
 
My questions are very basic, and I apologize if this has been discussed many times.
1. How can I tell which dry food is good and which is bad? Can I tell from the brand or ingredients?
2. Which additional food additives are truly beneficial, and which should be avoided: garlic, vitamins, amino acids, fatty acids, astaxanthin, etc.?
3. Which frozen seafood is most beneficial, and which should I avoid?
4. How long the fish should be observed to determine if their diet is adequate? Say, a month, a year, five years?
5. What are the early signs of an improper diet?
6. Should I have a "fasting day" for my fish, and is it beneficial for everyone?
 
I have seen this being discussed very... passionately... on R2R before, so it's probably a controversial question, but I would love to hear your full thoughts on this:

Do you think that live food actually impacts the gut bacteria of fish in a positive way (compared to frozen food for example), and if so, do you believe that it sufficiently stimulates the immune system of fish to make quarantine procedures obsolete?
 
Hi,

I'm working through the posted questions and wondered if you could help me by clarifying this question you posed?

What is something you find that every reefer should have stocked in their tanks at all times?

Do you mean some animal that reefers need to stock in their tanks, or some product that they should have on hand to handle isues?

Thanks,

Jay
Product! Sorry should’ve have clarified that question
 
I have seen this being discussed very... passionately... on R2R before, so it's probably a controversial question, but I would love to hear your full thoughts on this:

Do you think that live food actually impacts the gut bacteria of fish in a positive way (compared to frozen food for example), and if so, do you believe that it sufficiently stimulates the immune system of fish to make quarantine procedures obsolete?
Marketing idea: pellets with ich and garlic!
 
Marketing idea: pellets with ich and garlic!

Spicy ich?

There are a number of garlic infused foods:
  • Omega One Garlic Marine Pellets: Made with fresh seafood and whole salmon skin, rich in Omega-3 fatty acids, and blended with garlic and spirulina.
  • Ocean Nutrition Formula Two Marine Pellet: A soft, highly digestible pellet for herbivorous and omnivorous marine fish containing garlic, kelp, and spirulina.
  • Dr. Bassleer Biofish Food Garlic: Premium European micro-granules/pellets targeted at boosting the immune systems and recovery of freshwater and saltwater fish.
  • New Life Spectrum Thera+A: Features regular pellet formulas boosted with a high concentration of garlic to help combat internal parasites.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 6 7.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 28 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.6%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 20 26.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new