We got our new clear view Lid Monday, I am really pleased with it. It fit our tank perfectly we ordered cutouts for the lights, two power cords and a feed door. We went with the Tsunami model to keep price down, there are more elaborate versions you can order that may feature cleaner looks or other benefits. We are completely satisfied with ours. I feel their build quality far exceeds anything I could have put together. Waterbox offers a cover but you have to buy parts and successfully assemble it. Also theirs may not have things like a feed door. I feel this perfectly suits our needs. It will need regular cleaning every salt water spill shows up on it. However that is really to be expected. I think it will accumulate moisture etc from the bottom side so will need vinegar cleaned on a regular basis. However we have fish that might jump so I think the compromises worth it.