Maybe a stupid question about raising baby clownfish. . .

  • Thread starter Thread starter MoshJosh
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

MoshJosh

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Messages
4,542
Reaction score
4,803
Location
Grand Junction
What state or country do you live in
Colorado
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Has anyone ever tried raising clownfish larvae INSIDE a rottifer culture???

Now I have read different things about the parameters to keep a culture, but as I understand it, using tank water (same parameters as a reef tank) is acceptable. . . So if you had a culture at tank parameters just full of rottifer, wouldn't dumping the clown larvae in MAXIMIZE their availability and proximity to food?

My first thought as to why you would not do this is the nutrient levels in the culture. . . ???

0.5. can a healthy rottifer culture be maintained at "reef tank parameters"?

1. Has anyone placed clownfish larvae directly into a rottifer culture?

2. What are the nutrient levels inside of a rottifer culture?
 
Has anyone ever tried raising clownfish larvae INSIDE a rottifer culture???

Now I have read different things about the parameters to keep a culture, but as I understand it, using tank water (same parameters as a reef tank) is acceptable. . . So if you had a culture at tank parameters just full of rottifer, wouldn't dumping the clown larvae in MAXIMIZE their availability and proximity to food?

My first thought as to why you would not do this is the nutrient levels in the culture. . . ???

0.5. can a healthy rottifer culture be maintained at "reef tank parameters"?

1. Has anyone placed clownfish larvae directly into a rottifer culture?

2. What are the nutrient levels inside of a rottifer culture?
People have tried this before - it's called co-culturing. It has been a while since I looked into it, but, IIRC, nutrients don't seem to be an issue; the issue I've commonly seen with it is that the larvae may essentially eat the feeders faster than the feeders can reproduce (either just by eating too many/being placed in too small of a culture vessel, or by growing and beginning to eat the adults, causing the population to not be able to reproduce since the reproductive members of the population become the targeted food source).

So, the fish basically end up eating themselves into extinction unless the aquarist is ready to provide other feeds once the larvae start eating the adults.

That said, this method can work - and well, when done correctly - but you need to be prepared for the feeder population's collapse:
https://www.was.org/Meeting/Program/PaperDetail/156303
 
People have tried this before - it's called co-culturing. It has been a while since I looked into it, but, IIRC, nutrients don't seem to be an issue; the issue I've commonly seen with it is that the larvae may essentially eat the feeders faster than the feeders can reproduce (either just by eating too many/being placed in too small of a culture vessel, or by growing and beginning to eat the adults, causing the population to not be able to reproduce since the reproductive members of the population become the targeted food source).

So, the fish basically end up eating themselves into extinction unless the aquarist is ready to provide other feeds once the larvae start eating the adults.

That said, this method can work - and well, when done correctly - but you need to be prepared for the feeder population's collapse:
https://www.was.org/Meeting/Program/PaperDetail/156303
Thanks for the reply and very interesting! I wonder if supplementing prepared foods at some point during the larval stage would help offset the culture depletion. As I understated, there have been some successes feeding larvae powdered foods. . . But I'll need to do more research. . .
 
Thanks for the reply and very interesting! I wonder if supplementing prepared foods at some point during the larval stage would help offset the culture depletion. As I understated, there have been some successes feeding larvae powdered foods. . . But I'll need to do more research. . .
It might, but I could see a few ways that could backfire as well - that's part of the risk with experimenting though.

Anyway, yeah, some larvae are willing to accept powdered foods, but definitely not all larvae will. Clownfish I know will eat powdered foods very early (as early as Day 2 Post Hatching), but a lot of other fish would literally starve since the powdered foods don't move in the right way to entice them to strike.
 
It might, but I could see a few ways that could backfire as well - that's part of the risk with experimenting though.

Anyway, yeah, some larvae are willing to accept powdered foods, but definitely not all larvae will. Clownfish I know will eat powdered foods very early (as early as Day 2 Post Hatching), but a lot of other fish would literally starve since the powdered foods don't move in the right way to entice them to strike.
Wonder if powder mixed with pods at a high density would "trick" them into striking. . . Also, I wonder what kind of mortality you would see during a transfer of larvae to a second (more dense) culture after a few days. . .

All sort of a moot point since I don't have any clowns spawning. . . YET!!!
 
Wonder if powder mixed with pods at a high density would "trick" them into striking. . . Also, I wonder what kind of mortality you would see during a transfer of larvae to a second (more dense) culture after a few days. . .

All sort of a moot point since I don't have any clowns spawning. . . YET!!!
Possibly - unintentional ingestion of the powder is also possible - but unlikely with most species. Mortality rates when transferring larvae are usually pretty high - it's generally a lot safer to transfer eggs than larvae.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new