Microbe lift phos out

[Garf]

Purple bacteria !? What kind is that then?

PNSB and Natural Aquarium Filtration | Product Info | AlgaeBarn https://share.google/cV6XNtfdCzwsIR6eQ

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

Also
Agent green and rx which are lanthium don’t give a tang warning

Correct. But I believe tangs are at risk from lanthanum, and I’m not aware of any other product that is a singular risk for them relative to other fish.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

Maybe it’s ricin or anthrax

This is ridiculous. You seem bent on proving it is good, so use it. I’m not going to add further to such a discussion.

 

[scotty333]

This is ridiculous. You seem bent on proving it is good, so use it. I’m not going to add further to such a discussion.

Take a chill boss just having a little fun now or is it strictly no funny stuff on your page?

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

Let us know what happens if you try it.

 

[scotty333]

Let us know what happens if you try it.

Sure
I’m going half dose and observe so may not get any results in for a few days but I’ll keep anyone that’s interested in the loop
Why I am so bent on trying it is because it’s only 9 euro and delivered next day on amazon and I’m on a phosphate leach period so rising .05 a day and need to get on top of it

Usually I’d take a ride out to my lfs but 2 reasons I can’t , no car and not alot of spare cash
I know it’s not ideal to be trying it out when it looks like nobody out there has is risky
But in for a penny in for a pound ( an English saying )

 

[Fishy888]

Take a chill boss just having a little fun now or is it strictly no funny stuff on your page?

Scotty it’s in your best interest to not be so quick to trust a company that doesn’t list the ingredients in a product they claim is “reef safe and effective” just because they say so. That’s all we’re trying to tell you.

Randy and others are trying to look out for your good and the good of your animals. It sounds like you’re making light of that. I can see their frustration.

Cheaper isn’t always better!

 

[scotty333]

Scotty it’s in your best interest to not be so quick to trust a company that doesn’t list the ingredients in a product they claim is “reef safe and effective” just because they say so. That’s all we’re trying to tell you.

Randy and others are trying to look out for your good and the good of your animals. It sounds like you’re making light of that. I can see their frustration.

No I get it , read my last post I think they were the same time so look up

 

[Fishy888]

Let us know what happens if you try it.

Sure
I’m going half dose and observe so may not get any results in for a few days but I’ll keep anyone that’s interested in the loop
Why I am so bent on trying it is because it’s only 9 euro and delivered next day on amazon and I’m on a phosphate leach period so rising .05 a day and need to get on top of it

Usually I’d take a ride out to my lfs but 2 reasons I can’t , no car and not alot of spare cash
I know it’s not ideal to be trying it out when it looks like nobody out there has is risky
But in for a penny in for a pound ( an English saying )

That’s when you get on Amazon, eBay or online stores and buy something decent. I also don’t have a vehicle right now but I research the p00p out of the products I buy and I order the ones that gives my reef the best bang for the buck.

If this product nukes your tank the fact that it was “only “ 9 euros won’t be of much comfort I wouldn’t think.

 

[scotty333]

That’s when you get on Amazon, eBay or online stores and buy something decent. I also don’t have a vehicle right now but I research the p00p out of the products I buy and I order the one that gives my reef the best bang for the buck.

If this product nukes your tank the fact that it was “only “ 9 euros won’t be of much comfort I wouldn’t think.

Ah jeez now I’m really put off ,
You are right though, there’s not a mention of it on the net like other forums , Reddit etc n that does make me nervous

 

[scotty333]

Right
I’m going to contact them tomorrow and try to figure out what’s in their product , I doubt they’ll tell me but I’ll convince them they’ll get a good review if they tell me and it works haha

 

[Fishy888]

Right
I’m going to contact them tomorrow and try to figure out what’s in their product , I doubt they’ll tell me but I’ll convince them they’ll get a good review if they tell me and it works haha

IF (and that’s a BIG if!) they tell you what’s in it please let us know. Otherwise I’d honestly just go with LaCl and some 1 or even 5 micron socks. I just bought some from Amazon. Yes it’s more expensive but I can about guarantee you it’ll be far less expensive than a tank crash.

 

[scotty333]

IF (and that’s a BIG if!) they tell you what’s in it please let us know. Otherwise I’d honestly just go with LaCl and some 1 or even 5 micron socks. I just bought some from Amazon. Yes it’s more expensive but I can about guarantee you it’ll be far less expensive than a tank crash.

If I had 40 euro spare that would be my go to also but I just haven’t
I won’t use it until I get some sort of response

 

[scotty333]

It’s here and blue
Very lax on instructions , only guide is add 2ml per 100ltr with no listed removal at that amount

I did call this morning and I was told “ I don’t know off the top of my head , and he would have to dig out the data sheets on it” useless as expected

 

[Garf]

It’s here and blue
Very lax on instructions , only guide is add 2ml per 100ltr with no listed removal at that amount

I did call this morning and I was told “ I don’t know off the top of my head , and he would have to dig out the data sheets on it” useless as expected

That sais "ARKA" on the label. Somewhere on the web I noticed an "ARKA" product with the same name as the microbe lift brand. "Arka phos out 4". Perhaps you could research that to give an idea what it truly is.

 

[scotty333]

That sais "ARKA" on the label. Somewhere on the web I noticed an "ARKA" product with the same name as the microbe lift brand. "Arka phos out 4". Perhaps you could research that to give an idea what it truly is.

All I can find is the ph is 3.5-5 which is different from what I found under the microbelift search

 

[Garf]

All I can find is the ph is 3.5-5 which is different from what I found under the microbelift search

Pretty sure the pH of lanthanum in RODI is 5 ish fyi.

 

[scotty333]

Pretty sure the pH of lanthanum in RODI is 5 ish fyi.

They do say no lanthium of metals but just polymers are listed

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

They do say no lanthium of metals but just polymers are listed

Where is that stated?

 

[scotty333]

Where is that stated?

I should retract the lanthium statement , must have dreamt that sorry