Most Hard To Keep Zoa/Paly List

[stacy_vennes]

Dark Phoenix PE & PZ Datenights as well

I have the dark phoenix and they are doing awesome in my tank had them about 2 years. I have mine on the sand bed

 

[Newwaterville]

It's a hit or miss I guess. Thanks for the heads up, I plan on having them again.

 

[mainereefer]

I have never been able to keep any micro zoa long term. I dont agree with all pe being hard to keep, ive only had trouble with the purple pe,red pe and rdpe grow like weeds

 

[Ice]

Lately it's been very expensive but jf blood shots keep dyeing

 

[cutterx23]

Ouch that's not a good one to keep losing. Full spectrums, and all maul morphs for that matter are a pain in the rear to keep and grow. Strats suck at growing. Flaming Mohicans are super slow. And there are so many that will all die the second they are fragged.

 

[terrypercula]

Deep waters seem to be tougher.

 

[timmylucas]

the PE's I seem to have will grow rapidly at one point. Like weeds. Then they seem to start to die off and then it happens again and again. So Id say PE's for sure and purple hornets

 

[that Reef Guy]

I've never had any trouble with any PE zoos. They grow slowly but I have never had any meltdowns with them. I totally 100% agree on any Caribbean zoos. They are extremely tempermental. The nice gorgeous blue ones most of all.

How do you know which ones are from the Caribbean?

 

[that Reef Guy]

I've read that some zoanthids and palythoas actually like "dirty" water with higher nitrates and detritus. I know that azooxanthellae uses nitrates in it's metabolic processes and that could be one reason that a zoa/paly could die if the water was too clean. Just something to ponder about.

I read a lot that Carbon Kills Zoanthids which worries me as I use Carbon but do not have any problems.

But at the same time I worry every day that my Zoanthid Tank could Crash at any Time because I use Carbon.

What do you guys think?

Is there any Proven Facts to this Theory or is it Made Up?

 

[that Reef Guy]

This is a Cool Thread.

Does anybody know if there is a "Fastest Growing Zoanthid Thread"?

And if so can I get a Link to it?

 

[that Reef Guy]

I like this Thread so much that I decided to Post Three Similar (Yet Different) Threads with Top 5 and 10 Lists.

Please Click on the Three Links Below and Post Your Lists there.

https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/zo...18-easiest-keep-zoanthids-top-5-10-lists.html

https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/zo...fastest-growing-zoanthids-top-5-10-lists.html

https://www.reef2reef.com/forums/zo...slowest-growing-zoanthids-top-5-10-lists.html

I feel that this information will be greatly beneficial to all the Club Zoa Members so please Participate.

It will greatly help us decide our Future Zoanthid Purchases.

 

[Acro]

For me it's utter chaos, every frag I've ever had has melted. Only one that does it for me!

 

[golfnut1232]

z's and p's that I've tried multiple times:

clementines - 4 times. I am now on my 4th time and an 11 polyp frag has melted to one polyp + a tiny one. Hoping they make it.

blue agaves - 3 times. The last go around was a colony of 40+ and still no luck.

fruit loops - 2 times

lakers = 2 times

emeralds on fire - 2 times, working on a 3rd, lol

Also, all three of the traditional hornets don't thrive. I still have blue, purple and red, but they just don't seem happy.

All these stuggles and yet I have 75+ other varieties that do very well. Frustrating.

 

[jeremy]

I for some reason can't keep jf bloodshots.

 

[bichirfreak]

I had some issue with lakers not pop out . I lowerd my salt level to 1.024- .023
Now there are everywhere growing and eat fine hope it helps u

 

[melonheadorion]

pink zippers seems to be the hardest one for me. ive had 2 frags with them, and the first one detached from its frag, and disappeared. it was barely hanging on to begin with, and the second, which i still have, only partially opens, and has shrunk considerably

 

[ChrisfromBrick]

for me i’m having issues with rasta’s

 

[Gumbies R Us]

We've had issues with our bam bam's, but I chalk that up to GHA issues (which are solved now)

 

[ChrisfromBrick]

my bam bams grow like weeds. I cannot believe how fast my playboy bunnies are spreading. If anyone needs playboy bunnies, let me know. I think i will frag a few polyps soon.