New fish always disappear after one night

ScRmptisSnkhds723

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 5, 2024
Messages
37
Reaction score
33
Location
Malaysia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a 60 Gallon Reef tank that has been set up for around 1.5 years, currently I have 4 fish in the aquarium which are an Azure damsel, a Tomato Clownfish, a Pajama Cardinal and an algea blenny. The damsel and pajama Cardinal and damsel were the first fish that i added to the aquarium a month after cycling. The two others came a few months later. I have never been in a rush to stock this tank but It's very frustrating because new fish always disappear after one night. Cardinals, Gobies and more. longest i got was a wrasse which lasted 2 months. When i add these new fish i ensure theyre acclimated and i rarely see them get bullied upon entry, more like politely ushered to the back of the tank. Im not sure what to think. Predators, shock or night time aggression. what should i do. I have other livestock such as cleaner shrimp and a red legged hermit crab, if this helps give an insite. Aggression is at the top of my suspect list as the tomato will attack my hand if it gets the chance, even then I haven't ruled out everything and am still undecided
 
Please provide a full tank shot with white light.

I am interested in seeing rock scape and hiding places for new fish.
 
Please provide a full tank shot with white light.

I am interested in seeing rock scape and hiding places for new fish.
38d0bdbd-505b-4c43-8e9b-1905e7db0940.jpg
 
Tank looks great. More rock and hiding places might help.

New fish are always at a disadvantage with aggression from established fish in tank. Consider adding more than one fish at a time. I suspect your tomato clown may be the problem. You might consider removing him.
 
If they're completely disappearing, I wouldn't rule out a large polyclad flatworm or other such predator. I had one in my tank for a long time, and it would somehow not eat my established fish but dined on the new ones that I guess just didn't have a hiding spot yet. Do some observation at night with the lights out to see if you can find anything.
 
Tank looks great. More rock and hiding places might help.

New fish are always at a disadvantage with aggression from established fish in tank. Consider adding more than one fish at a time. I suspect your tomato clown may be the problem. You might consider removing him.
im thinking of trading in the clown and isolating the damsel for a while as he doesn't seem like that much of a culprit, however I'll still be cautious.
 
If they're completely disappearing, I wouldn't rule out a large polyclad flatworm or other such predator. I had one in my tank for a long time, and it would somehow not eat my established fish but dined on the new ones that I guess just didn't have a hiding spot yet. Do some observation at night with the lights out to see if you can find anything.
All my new fish are sent to the back corner of the aquarium by my older ones , the new fish often hang out around there and disappear the next morning
 
Damsels and clowns are very aggressive and territorial, I've never had luck introducing a fish that had a damsel in it. I'm guessing its an aggression thing
 
You said that your fishes is acclimated - but how? I have a heavy stocked 80 G (30-40 fish) and I use an acclimation box for the first 5 days. Since I started with that - my losses with fish introduction is nearly 0. Among others - I have 9 damsels, two clowns and one small tang - all known to be aggressive. (there are some blennies and 2 huge pyjamas cardinals to - also sometimes aggressive) The five days in the acc box give my newcomers a chance to start to eat and get use of water quality. They also more or less get the same "smell" as the others and the other learn the smell of the newcomers. The only fish in this bouillabaisse that sometimes show up "pursuit" aggressivity against newcomers is my pyjamas cardinals and only against newcomers from the same species.

With help of my acclimation box - I have also introduce a mate to - at that time - lonely clown.





Sincerely Lasse
 
You said that your fishes is acclimated - but how? I have a heavy stocked 80 G (30-40 fish) and I use an acclimation box for the first 5 days. Since I started with that - my losses with fish introduction is nearly 0. Among others - I have 9 damsels, two clowns and one small tang - all known to be aggressive. (there are some blennies and 2 huge pyjamas cardinals to - also sometimes aggressive) The five days in the acc box give my newcomers a chance to start to eat and get use of water quality. They also more or less get the same "smell" as the others and the other learn the smell of the newcomers. The only fish in this bouillabaisse that sometimes show up "pursuit" aggressivity against newcomers is my pyjamas cardinals and only against newcomers from the same species.

With help of my acclimation box - I have also introduce a mate to - at that time - lonely clown.





Sincerely Lasse
Hi Lasse, thanks for the advice. I do plan on keeping getting an acclimation box and trying this out before removing any fish
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new