New Reef Tank - Not sure what to do.

TheNewClownFish

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 3, 2021
Messages
115
Reaction score
36
Location
canada
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi guys,

I have a 18.5G Reef Tank. It’s three weeks old (cycled) with two small clowns and some snails/large GSP coral.

I noticed some weird algea growing after my diatoms died. Now I’m questioning what this could be and I’m scared it might be bryopsis.

It started off looking like this (shown in image) but it’s growing quick over the rock, glass and sand.

If I could get help on what to do, especially with my clowns in there, I’d appreciate it.

Thanks.



IMG_5664.png

IMG_5671.jpeg

IMG_5672.jpeg

IMG_5675.png
 
This won't bother your Clowns at all, it will just bother you 🙃

#reefsquad what do you guys see?

In the very first picture, I thought that's the start of dinoflagellates. The rest of the pics look like they could be early Bryopsis. I think the there may be two pest algae growing here.
 
This won't bother your Clowns at all, it will just bother you 🙃

#reefsquad what do you guys see?

In the very first picture, I thought that's the start of dinoflagellates. The rest of the pics look like they could be early Bryopsis. I think the there may be two pest algae growing here.
Man this sucks. I used to do have a Reef tank from 2021-2024 and never dealt with this. I took a one year break, came back, and I feel like I got slammed.

Should I start Reef Flux? I’m not sure what to do aha. I heard manual removal is hard.
 
Definitely looks to be a filamentous algae, but it is hard to tell. I'm not convinced it is Bryopsis, though. Looks less feathery and more like Cladophora/ Pithophora.

Maybe just early GHA?

OP, can you pluck some and get a close up pic for us in a dish, please?

Also, smush some in-between your fingers. Does it smell like garden soil?

@ISpeakForTheSeas
 
Definitely looks to be a filamentous algae, but it is hard to tell. I'm not convinced it is Bryopsis, though. Looks less feathery and more like Cladophora/ Pithophora.
Yes, I thought the same, that it doesn't have the fronds of Bryopsis, but I was Googling some pics, and it seems like when Bryopsis first starts it can look like this. I'm no expert, and I hope I'm wrong 🙂
 
Man this sucks. I used to do have a Reef tank from 2021-2024 and never dealt with this. I took a one year break, came back, and I feel like I got slammed.

Should I start Reef Flux? I’m not sure what to do aha. I heard manual removal is hard.
Don't do anything until you get a firmer ID than my advice 🤪
 
Definitely looks to be a filamentous algae, but it is hard to tell. I'm not convinced it is Bryopsis, though. Looks less feathery and more like Cladophora/ Pithophora.

Maybe just early GHA?

OP, can you pluck some and get a close up pic for us in a dish, please?

Also, smush some in-between your fingers. Does it smell like garden soil?

@ISpeakForTheSeas
Hey! I added a video. It didn’t smell the best to be honest. And some of it break down in hands like it was dust which was weird. Hopefully my video isn’t too bad. Thank you so much
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5685.mov
    20.2 MB
Definitely looks to be a filamentous algae, but it is hard to tell. I'm not convinced it is Bryopsis, though. Looks less feathery and more like Cladophora/ Pithophora.

Maybe just early GHA?

OP, can you pluck some and get a close up pic for us in a dish, please?

Also, smush some in-between your fingers. Does it smell like garden soil?

@ISpeakForTheSeas
I also added a photo as well!



IMG_5694.png
 
Hi guys,

I have a 18.5G Reef Tank. It’s three weeks old (cycled) with two small clowns and some snails/large GSP coral.

I noticed some weird algea growing after my diatoms died. Now I’m questioning what this could be and I’m scared it might be bryopsis.

It started off looking like this (shown in image) but it’s growing quick over the rock, glass and sand.

If I could get help on what to do, especially with my clowns in there, I’d appreciate it.

Thanks.



IMG_5664.png

IMG_5671.jpeg

IMG_5672.jpeg

IMG_5675.png
This is derbesia, similar to bryopsis and is one of the more challenging of algae due to need of its complete removal. Derbesia algae is a fast-growing, invasive algae species notorious for its resistance to conventional algae management methods. Once established, derbesia can quickly overtake rockwork and corals, creating a challenging problem. Removal is best accomplished by taking the rock out of tank and placing in a container of tank water. Then you will want to pull as much as you can by hand and discard. With a dental pick or small crochet needle, pull the roots off the rock. YOU MUST GET EVERY ROOT OR IT WILL SIMPLY RETURN !!
After you are done return rock to tank and reduce white light intensity and even hours of white light and add the following cleaners which will help with control. These guys will consume derbesia but not as fast as it can grow - They will never keep up.
Pin cushion urchin, Chiton snails, pitho crabs, and larger astrea snails
Excessive nutrients like nitrates and phosphates are major contributors to this growth. Algae thrives when there is an abundance of these compounds.
 
This is derbesia, similar to bryopsis and is one of the more challenging of algae due to need of its complete removal. Derbesia algae is a fast-growing, invasive algae species notorious for its resistance to conventional algae management methods. Once established, derbesia can quickly overtake rockwork and corals, creating a challenging problem. Removal is best accomplished by taking the rock out of tank and placing in a container of tank water. Then you will want to pull as much as you can by hand and discard. With a dental pick or small crochet needle, pull the roots off the rock. YOU MUST GET EVERY ROOT OR IT WILL SIMPLY RETURN !!
After you are done return rock to tank and reduce white light intensity and even hours of white light and add the following cleaners which will help with control. These guys will consume derbesia but not as fast as it can grow - They will never keep up.
Pin cushion urchin, Chiton snails, pitho crabs, and larger astrea snails
Excessive nutrients like nitrates and phosphates are major contributors to this growth. Algae thrives when there is an abundance of these compounds.
Thanks Vette. Are you sure it’s not Bryopsis? I pulled some strands out of the tank. It has ferns which is weird.



IMG_5694.png
 
Definitely wouldn’t jump into chemicals to help get rid of it. That will just add more problems down the line. I would start with manual removal. Get a new toothbrush and scrub the rocks. Hold a siphon hose close to the toothbrush to remove as much from the water column. You could also siphon in to a filter sock so you aren’t replacing all the water you are removing. @vetteguy53081 also gave a great recommendation of pulling the rock and scraping it off. You can pull the rock, make a 50/50 peroxide solution and use that to scrub the rock. Peroxide kills algae quick.

Also, three weeks is a very new tank. You will go through the ugly phase.
Looks like you used all dry rock. The algae probably came in on the GSP frag.
 
I agree that manual removal would be the best idea for your tank. A chemical solution (especially with a new tank) can make the issue worse and introduce different issues with your tank
 
Hey! I added a video. It didn’t smell the best to be honest. And some of it break down in hands like it was dust which was weird. Hopefully my video isn’t too bad. Thank you so much
No worries. It's GHA. Lots of good advice has already been posted, so I won't inundate you with more, but feel free to reach out if need be.
 
Thanks Vette. Are you sure it’s not Bryopsis? I pulled some strands out of the tank. It has ferns which is weird.



IMG_5694.png
DErbesia is very similar and both have same characteristics
 
Hi guys,

I have a 18.5G Reef Tank. It’s three weeks old (cycled) with two small clowns and some snails/large GSP coral.

I noticed some weird algea growing after my diatoms died. Now I’m questioning what this could be and I’m scared it might be bryopsis.

It started off looking like this (shown in image) but it’s growing quick over the rock, glass and sand.

If I could get help on what to do, especially with my clowns in there, I’d appreciate it.

Thanks.



IMG_5664.png

IMG_5671.jpeg

IMG_5672.jpeg

IMG_5675.png
I wouldn’t panic just yet. At only three weeks old, the tank is still going through the ugly stage and it’s pretty normal to see different types of algae show up after the diatoms disappear.


Bryopsis can look similar to some other algae, so I’d try to get a closer picture before treating the tank with anything. I’d also keep an eye on your nutrients and avoid overfeeding. Manual removal during water changes can help in the meantime.


With the clowns, I wouldn’t do anything drastic until you know exactly what you’re dealing with. Give the tank some time to mature and see how it develops.
 
Hi everyone, just wanted to provide an update - firstly thank you all. I read all of your replies.

Today I did a 25% water change so I was able to move my one big rock (it’s one structure) and scrubbed 95% of it. I also siphoned the sand bed.

I’d say I got 85% out and it surprisingly was pretty easy to get off. There’s still tiny pieces but I just spent an hr doing this so I think I’ll call it a day and hopefully my CUC eats the rest.

I was also able to rehome a fish that was given to me and it was too large. It went to my friends aquarium which is amazing.

I’ll keep you posted on how things go. I’ll continue with manual removal + CUC and only resort to medication as a last attempt
 
I’d say I got 85% out and it surprisingly was pretty easy to get off.
I'm glad to see that you're making some positive progress 🙂

However, Bryopsis and some of the other nasty algae are not typically easy to pull off of a rock. When I saw your reply quoted here, I again thought that maybe you have dinoflagellate algae, possibly (likely) in combination with something else.

Dino's are super common in tanks, I think much more so than Bryopsis and others, and typically hit soon after the diatoms come and go. Dino's can be their own kind of bear to deal with and I'm making a point of this because I don't want you to be so focused on other algae that you miss Dinos if/when you see them.

I hope this helps!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 5 16.1%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 3 9.7%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 8 25.8%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 4 12.9%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 3.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 3.2%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new