Urgent advise needed for QT tank

PinkysAquarium

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 3, 2026
Messages
6
Reaction score
2
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone!!
I really need some urgent help with my fish. I suspect ich or Brooklynella may have entered my 80-gallon reef tank through a tang and an Oreni tilefish that my fish guy quarantined before adding them. Both later died, but I don’t have a confirmed diagnosis.


My mandarin had been very unwell and barely moving, and one of my clowns has gotten worse with white, patchy-looking skin. Tonight, I set up a 15-gallon Innovative Marine AIO and moved my yellow watchman goby, sand goby, mandarin, two clowns, neon goby and redhead goby into it for treatment.


My mandarin initially looked worse after the transfer and released slime, but has since improved. His breathing, movement and skin all look better now, although I’m still concerned.


Only the front section is filled with saltwater, and the back chambers are empty. There’s a heater and an air stone in the front, but no filter running. I added Copper Power. The QT is currently reading 31 ppt and 25.5°C.


Is this setup okay temporarily for all these fish? Should the back chambers be filled and the return pump running? How do I check whether there’s enough water and whether the copper dose is correct? What treatment would be appropriate if this is brook rather than ich? I also need advice on managing ammonia and water changes without a cycled filter.


This has never happened to me before. I’ve looked after some of these fish for over two years, and I’m terrified of losing them. Any experienced advice on what I should do immediately would mean a lot. I can share photos and videos.
 
Welcome to Reef2Reef!

#WelcometoR2R

Yes, please post some clear pics or a short video of the fish in distress, use your whitest lights, turning off your blues for clarity. If posting a video it's best if you can first upload it to YouTube, then link that back here. Sometimes, some members have a problem viewing videos uploaded directly to R2R.

Here's the Reef2Reef QT protocol with details of how to setup a QT tank:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/current-quarantine-protocol.825055/

I'd personally fil and use the back filter section of your AIO. If you have some cycled sponge media from your main tank that can be added to the QT, that would be a good idea. Otherwise, you would need to mitigate ammonia with water changes, and it sounds like you have a lot of fish in a small tank, so I'd watch the ammonia closely. Don't use product like Seachem Prime, these products do not bind or reduce ammonia as stated on the bottle.

If you can post some pics or a video, then we can ask the R2R Fish Medic team for a diagnosis and what medication would be best.

#fishmedic

Good luck!
 
Hi everyone!!
I really need some urgent help with my fish. I suspect ich or Brooklynella may have entered my 80-gallon reef tank through a tang and an Oreni tilefish that my fish guy quarantined before adding them. Both later died, but I don’t have a confirmed diagnosis.


My mandarin had been very unwell and barely moving, and one of my clowns has gotten worse with white, patchy-looking skin. Tonight, I set up a 15-gallon Innovative Marine AIO and moved my yellow watchman goby, sand goby, mandarin, two clowns, neon goby and redhead goby into it for treatment.


My mandarin initially looked worse after the transfer and released slime, but has since improved. His breathing, movement and skin all look better now, although I’m still concerned.


Only the front section is filled with saltwater, and the back chambers are empty. There’s a heater and an air stone in the front, but no filter running. I added Copper Power. The QT is currently reading 31 ppt and 25.5°C.


Is this setup okay temporarily for all these fish? Should the back chambers be filled and the return pump running? How do I check whether there’s enough water and whether the copper dose is correct? What treatment would be appropriate if this is brook rather than ich? I also need advice on managing ammonia and water changes without a cycled filter.


This has never happened to me before. I’ve looked after some of these fish for over two years, and I’m terrified of losing them. Any experienced advice on what I should do immediately would mean a lot. I can share photos and videos.

Welcome to Reef2Reef!

I’m not sure of your tank set up, but with an AIO tank, the back chamber needs to be running, but without any carbon.

Do you have any established biomedia that you can move over from your display to the QT?

An accurate diagnosis is really important there because Brooklynella has a different treatment than does ich or velvet.

The #f#fishmedicay also have some advice.

Jay
 
I have ran a AIO tank, and I would advise against using it as a compete system. Well depends. I like my water clean so I used a more intense method of filter. I got a sock filter system that had a 200micron prefilter, then added a filter floss cut out to get extra filtration. This in turn would cause too much water fluctuation. Steady water level helps keep copper at the amount you dose.

Now above can be disregarded if you don’t use a more refining type of filter. You might not get the water level fluctuations. Keep an eye on the filter regardless.

I have used a few aio but without the back change most of the time. It was the last coral QT tank I ended up moving corals and adding fish for QT. And found the water level for my system as I stated above to be too much for my liking.

Other wise as stated above post pics and 30 second video if you can to YouTube (allows for higher quality videos) link them here. All under bright white lights.
 
Hi guys, thank you so much!! Have added photos here

I lost my mandarin early this morning unfortunately :(

I’m really struggling on the next steps, this is all so overwhelming and happened so quickly



IMG_5572.png

IMG_5568.jpeg

IMG_5573.png

IMG_5566.jpeg

IMG_5545.jpeg

BC67675A-0B31-4E08-BAD4-E37B6FBF38B9.png
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5543.mov
    17.6 MB
Brook meds….

Ruby Rally Pro

1.5 ml per gallon of SW

For 90min bath 3ml per gallon. Helps relieve the fish faster.

Instructions for Ruby Rally Pro


STEP 1:
Turn off protein skimmer and UV sterilizer. Remove carbon filtration or any absorbent media. (phosphate absorbents are okay)

STEP 2:
Determine the total water volume including filtration system.

STEP 3:
SALTWATER:
Add 1 ounce (30 ml) of Rally™ PRO per 20 gallons (76 liters) of total water volume.

Apply Rally PRO once per day for at least 3 days. Longer treatment periods may be required for heavy or persistent infections.


The treatment does comes out to 1.5ml per gallon to be dosed. 😉
 
Brook meds….

Ruby Rally Pro

1.5 ml per gallon of SW

For 90min bath 3ml per gallon. Helps relieve the fish faster.

Instructions for Ruby Rally Pro


STEP 1:
Turn off protein skimmer and UV sterilizer. Remove carbon filtration or any absorbent media. (phosphate absorbents are okay)

STEP 2:
Determine the total water volume including filtration system.

STEP 3:
SALTWATER:
Add 1 ounce (30 ml) of Rally™ PRO per 20 gallons (76 liters) of total water volume.

Apply Rally PRO once per day for at least 3 days. Longer treatment periods may be required for heavy or persistent infections.


The treatment does comes out to 1.5ml per gallon to be dosed. 😉
You are amazing!! Thank you so much 🙏🏻

Is this ok to add even if I originally added copper power last night?
 
You are amazing!! Thank you so much 🙏🏻

Is this ok to add even if I originally added copper power last night?


It can. I have not seen any research that shows otherwise.

Some will say keep the copper QT, and do Ruby Rally baths for 90 min per day.
 
It can. I have not seen any research that shows otherwise.

Some will say keep the copper QT, and do Ruby Rally baths for 90 min per day.
I like your advise to treat the specific disease. As you implied, many qt protocols advise copper without seeing symptoms.

The fish I saw looked very stressed. Treat the immediate threat and save fish.

OP,
Consider putting some cover for fish to hide. Anything to help reduce stress.
 
I like your advise to treat the specific disease. As you implied, many qt protocols advise copper without seeing symptoms.

The fish I saw looked very stressed. Treat the immediate threat and save fish.

OP,
Consider putting some cover for fish to hide. Anything to help reduce stress.

This right here. PVC is a good item to use. Especially the diamond goby. They will jump.
 
Thank you so much! I really appreciate all your help and advice.


Unfortunately, I lost both my mandarin and clownfish. I’m still unsure whether the cause is velvet or Brooklynella, so I’ve paused any further copper dosing until my Hanna checker arrives and I can confirm the copper level.


I also have Ruby Reef Rally Pro arriving on Tuesday. Would you recommend using that as the next step, given the uncertainty about what I’m dealing with?


I’ve attached a photo of my clownfish taken after he passed today, in case it helps identify what may have caused his death. Any guidance on the best approach for the remaining fish would be greatly appreciated.



IMG_5617.jpeg

IMG_5614.jpeg
 
Thank you so much! I really appreciate all your help and advice.


Unfortunately, I lost both my mandarin and clownfish. I’m still unsure whether the cause is velvet or Brooklynella, so I’ve paused any further copper dosing until my Hanna checker arrives and I can confirm the copper level.


I also have Ruby Reef Rally Pro arriving on Tuesday. Would you recommend using that as the next step, given the uncertainty about what I’m dealing with?


I’ve attached a photo of my clownfish taken after he passed today, in case it helps identify what may have caused his death. Any guidance on the best approach for the remaining fish would be greatly appreciated.



IMG_5617.jpeg

IMG_5614.jpeg

Where you able to get a Ruby rally bath going? If not this was Brook. I just do not see how this was velvet. Is the other clown still alive? Or any other fish you listed as living in the original post?
 
I’m leaning pretty strongly toward Brooklynella based on the photos, the heavy/patchy mucus on the clown, the mandarin shedding slime and how quickly this progressed. I agree with the comments above that this doesn’t look like a typical ich presentation and to me it looks more like brook than velvet.

At this point I would focus on the immediate threat rather than continuing to add medications blindly. Since you already have Copper Power in the QT, I would absolutely get an accurate copper reading with the Hanna checker before adding any more. You don’t want to accidentally push copper too high especially with already stressed fish.

Once the Rally Pro arrives, I would use it specifically for the suspected brook. If the remaining fish are deteriorating before Tuesday especially heavy mucus, skin sloughing, rapid breathing, or lying down then I would not wait casually, because brook can move extremely fast.

Also, make sure that 15 gallon QT has very STRONG aeration, the AIO circulation running and some PVC or other inert hiding places. With that many fish in 15 gallons and little/no established biological filtration, ammonia and oxygen can become a second problem very quickly (been there done that). I would monitor ammonia closely and be prepared for frequent water changes, matching the copper concentration in replacement water if you decide to continue copper.

Personally, based on what has been shown so far, I would treat this as brook unless something new points strongly toward velvet. The clownfish presentation especially is what pushes me in that direction.

Sorry you lost the mandarin and clown. This moved incredibly fast and I totally understand how attached we get to our little guys. :(
 
I’m leaning pretty strongly toward Brooklynella based on the photos, the heavy/patchy mucus on the clown, the mandarin shedding slime and how quickly this progressed. I agree with the comments above that this doesn’t look like a typical ich presentation and to me it looks more like brook than velvet.

At this point I would focus on the immediate threat rather than continuing to add medications blindly. Since you already have Copper Power in the QT, I would absolutely get an accurate copper reading with the Hanna checker before adding any more. You don’t want to accidentally push copper too high especially with already stressed fish.

Once the Rally Pro arrives, I would use it specifically for the suspected brook. If the remaining fish are deteriorating before Tuesday especially heavy mucus, skin sloughing, rapid breathing, or lying down then I would not wait casually, because brook can move extremely fast.

Also, make sure that 15 gallon QT has very STRONG aeration, the AIO circulation running and some PVC or other inert hiding places. With that many fish in 15 gallons and little/no established biological filtration, ammonia and oxygen can become a second problem very quickly (been there done that). I would monitor ammonia closely and be prepared for frequent water changes, matching the copper concentration in replacement water if you decide to continue copper.

Personally, based on what has been shown so far, I would treat this as brook unless something new points strongly toward velvet. The clownfish presentation especially is what pushes me in that direction.

Sorry you lost the mandarin and clown. This moved incredibly fast and I totally understand how attached we get to our little guys. :(
Thank you so so much 🙏🏻
The Ruby Rally Pro arrives tomorrow and thankful the remaining 3 fish seem ok!!

Is it ok to add the Ruby Pro tomorrow? I haven’t dosed copper since Friday and have already done one water change and will do another tomorrow before adding the pro.

How much would you dose in a 15 gallon? 45 ml?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT KIND OF REEFING DEAL ARE YOU HOPING TO PICK UP THIS BLACK FRIDAY?

  • A whole new aquarium or complete system

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • Lighting, pumps, or other major equipment

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • Controllers, testing, dosing, or automation gear

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • Dry goods and restocks, like salt, media, or food

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • Corals! Must...Have...CORALS!!!

    Votes: 5 27.8%
  • Fish or other livestock

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Rock, sand, or other aquascaping supplies

    Votes: 1 5.6%
  • I’m browsing, but don’t have a specific target

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • I’m not shopping for reef deals this year

    Votes: 1 5.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 1 5.6%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new