Nitrate Checker vs Dip Strips

  • Thread starter Thread starter tbrown
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

tbrown

Cronies #3?? Heathens' Coffee Snob???
View Badges
Joined
Nov 22, 2019
Messages
84,365
Reaction score
234,100
Location
Peoria, AZ
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Now I know everyone says you can't rely on the dip strips for accurate readings, and I'm to here to agree! I recently received a Hanna NO3 HR Checker (thanks @RiptideAquaculture !!!) and ran my nitrates. I had been using some Amazon dip strips to give me a basic ball park and they were just showing a hint of pink so we're good there. Hanna? She says I'm at 39.4! That should have been bright pink on the strips. I'm definitely going to verify the Hanna number - going to take a sample to my local pool company and Petco for comparisons. I know neither of them use good equipment but at least I'll have something. The crazy thing about the dip strips is that I have used probably 40 out of the bottle and NONE of them have ever even registered at 10!

Make sure you have trustworthy tests and always double check your reads.
 
This may sound obvious but make sure you follow the procedures for the Hanna checker perfectly. Also, for the Hanna checkers it’s important to make sure the cuvette stays clean. I wipe mine off with a micro fiber towel every time I put it in the checker. Then when I’m done I rinse and fill mine up with rodi water to prevent any kind of residue from forming on the inside.

Lets us know what you find out.
 
This may sound obvious but make sure you follow the procedures for the Hanna checker perfectly. Also, for the Hanna checkers it’s important to make sure the cuvette stays clean. I wipe mine off with a micro fiber towel every time I put it in the checker. Then when I’m done I rinse and fill mine up with rodi water to prevent any kind of residue from forming on the inside.

Lets us know what you find out.
I use Hanna Checkers at work along with Hach so I am aware but thanks for the reminder!

When the two minutes of mixing was complete, it was definitely red so I trust the Hanna read way more than the test strips.
 
Also: if you're heading to Reef A Palooza Orlando, check out booth 609!!!!
 
I use Hanna Checkers at work along with Hach so I am aware but thanks for the reminder!

When the two minutes of mixing was complete, it was definitely red so I trust the Hanna read way more than the test strips.
Yeah sorry I forgot that you said you’ve used them before. If you can’t get a definite answer from a local store then I personally like Saliferts nitrate test as a backup.
I agree though that I would trust the Hanna over a strip also.
 
Yeah sorry I forgot that you said you’ve used them before. If you can’t get a definite answer from a local store then I personally like Saliferts nitrate test as a backup.
I agree though that I would trust the Hanna over a strip also.
Even if I have used them before it's always a good reminder! I've got guys working for me that have been in the industry for 30+ years that I just found out don't know that there is a different procedure for total and free chlorine... They thought all samples are: add water, zero, add regent, swirl, read.
 
Even if I have used them before it's always a good reminder! I've got guys working for me that have been in the industry for 30+ years that I just found out don't know that there is a different procedure for total and free chlorine... They thought all samples are: add water, zero, add regent, swirl, read.
I’m almost embarrassed to admit when I first started using my Hanna checker for phosphate I didn’t realize you have to hold the button to start a timer on the phosphate checker.
For a long time I just zeroes the checker added the reagent and agitated it for 2 minutes, then put it in the checker and pressed the button to immediately get the reading.
It wasn’t until I accidentally watched a YouTube video of someone using it that I found out I was using it wrong.

I also, not long ago, was getting very inconsistent reading because I would get a cup of water from my tank for the samples, but it was the same cup I would thaw frozen food in. You’d be amazed how much phosphates can increase in the sample from a small amount of old food in the bottom of the cup.

Hitting Myself Mtv GIF by Teen Mom
 
I’m almost embarrassed to admit when I first started using my Hanna checker for phosphate I didn’t realize you have to hold the button to start a timer on the phosphate checker.
For a long time I just zeroes the checker added the reagent and agitated it for 2 minutes, then put it in the checker and pressed the button to immediately get the reading.
It wasn’t until I accidentally watched a YouTube video of someone using it that I found out I was using it wrong.

I also, not long ago, was getting very inconsistent reading because I would get a cup of water from my tank for the samples, but it was the same cup I would thaw frozen food in. You’d be amazed how much phosphates can increase in the sample from a small amount of old food in the bottom of the cup.

Hitting Myself Mtv GIF by Teen Mom
Yep. Especially since food is a large part of our phosphates!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.7%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 9.9%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.4%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.0%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 26.4%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.7%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new