Pick my skimmer! 500g

revhtree · Jan 12, 2017

I used to think the bigger the better but now I know that isn't the case. I'm so torn!

revhtree · Jan 12, 2017

Ok more suggestions! HA!

Daniel@R2R · Jan 12, 2017

revhtree said:
Ok more suggestions! HA!

NYOS...Tunze...you're welcome...

dragon99 · Jan 12, 2017

@twilliard should convince you to get the Orphek Helix

revhtree · Jan 12, 2017

mdbannister said:
NYOS...Tunze...you're welcome...

That is all you would suggest? Looking for a skimmer that doesn't have the pump built into the skimmer. Been there done that and I don't like taking the hole thing apart to clean the pump.

dragon99 · Jan 12, 2017

revhtree said:
That is all you would suggest? Looking for a skimmer that doesn't have the pump built into the skimmer. Been there done that and I don't like taking the hole thing apart to clean the pump.

if that's your concern, definitely get a Lifereef. You can attach any pump you want.

DLHDesign · Jan 12, 2017

revhtree said:
I used to think the bigger the better but now I know that isn't the case. I'm so torn!

This one should work right?

revhtree · Jan 12, 2017

DLHDesign said:
This one should work right?

That might be too much....

Daniel@R2R · Jan 12, 2017

revhtree said:
That is all you would suggest?

Hey I thought you were trying to narrow it down! After my research, I really like the NYOS and the Tunze...those would be my top two. So, I guess (although there are lots of other great skimmers out there), that's the 2 I'd recommend.

Looking for a skimmer that doesn't have the pump built into the skimmer. Been there done that and I don't like taking the hole thing apart to clean the pump.

Tunze it is then! :D Check out the 9430 or 9460 (I'd personally go with the 9460, but I like to oversize my skimmers a lot). I am running a 9410 on my 50g and I LOVE it! Super easy to adjust with the control (no twisting of anything on the skimmer) and the pump is outside the skimmer body so should be easy maintenance for you. It's also super consistent IME. I'm dumping mine every couple of days (my philosophy is feed heavy and skim heavy).

MaddyP · Jan 12, 2017

Are you on a budget? If not, you can't go wrong with a Vertex Alpha. The 300 gets you into the tank size you want without being overboard. I think you could safely go with a 250 as well with a skim locker to account for the larger volume of skimate...

RamsReef · Jan 12, 2017

http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=3578+4392+20710&pcatid=20710&s=lh

Daniel@R2R · Jan 12, 2017

dragon99 said:
if that's your concern, definitely get a Lifereef. You can attach any pump you want.

Lifereef is definitely highly recommended by most reviewers. I don't think I've ever seen a negative review.

Daniel@R2R · Jan 12, 2017

If you're wanting to feel "exclusive" you could go with a Bubble King (their pumps are also outside the skimmer body). http://www.aquariumspecialty.com/pr...rs/bubble-king-supermarin-300-protein-skimmer

They're too expensive for my salary, but if you a baller, then maybe that's more your thing. :D

jeffrey holloway · Jan 12, 2017

My vote goes for Lifereef! love mine

buckroe07 · Jan 12, 2017

I really love my ATB!

hybridazn · Jan 12, 2017

Nyos, tunze, a custom made Geo's Reef skimmer :)

JEREMY82 · Jan 12, 2017

I may have over looked this but a few questions may help point in your decision,how much space do you have for the skimmer?are you wanting to go external or internal ?are you thinking bout have a pretty heavy stocked system?and are you on a price capp?