For acropora growth, do you think there’s a target range of nitrate and phosphate you’d recommend for the best chance of growth?
Growth is very important to me. What do the studies seem to suggest?
I don't have a good answer for that for a few reasons:
1. I think it will vary tank to tank for the reasons in the article involving different corals and different other N and P sources.
2. I think that it will also vary tank to tank due to what else might be growth limiting (more on this below).
3. I expect that there may be a very wide range of good coral growth between just barely enough nitrate and phosphate, and so much that one or both is retarding growth in a detectable fashion.
Expanding on #2, there's a general principle called Liebig's law of the minimum
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebig's_law_of_the_minimum
Basically, it states that only one nutrient or other factor can be growth limiting at a time. It may be a matter of debate whether it always holds, but let's go with it.
The limiting nutrient is the one that if you added more of, organisms will grow more. It could be light, trace elements of all sorts, including nutrients, flow, or other aspects of coral husbandry. For that one nutrient, if you add more, corals will grow more. If you add some other nutrient, the coral cannot grow faster because the first one becomes in short supply and the coral cannot grow. In some cases, the theory may be a bit black and white for something that may have grew areas, and folks need to recognize that certain things may partly substitute for one another (such as added organics in place of light) but others clearly cannot (iron in excess while manganese is limiting).
The reason i bring this up is that for either N or P to be growth limiting, nothing else can be growth limiting. Not alkalinity, not pH, not light, and not any other trace elements.
So what is growth limiting to acropora in many tanks? It appears that carbonate may often be limiting, based on the experiments showing an effect by increasing alk or pH. In that scenario, at least at the lower alk and ph range used, N and P must not be growth limiting. OTOH, after the alk and pH is raised, perhaps they are limiting in that experiment and the growth would have been even higher.
If we start from natural seawater levels of everything, what is limiting? It may be N and P in many reef tanks lacking as much particulate foods as the ocean has. But as we begin to raise N and P to the levels seen in reef tanks, what then becomes growth limiting? Carbonate in at least some.
But as we continue to ratchet each of these to higher levels, what is limiting may move around between light, flow, trace elements, nutrients, etc. Consequently, I think there is the potential for 100 different SPS tanks to have a variety of different factors that are growth limiting in each, and in those cases, reefers may find different levels of nitrate and phosphate may be optimal for growth in each.
That's the main reason, IMO, that one result from a coral farm or reefer who says X and Y are best for nitrate and phosphate for acropora growth may not extrapolate to other settings.