Randy’s Thoughts on Nutrient Target Ranges

I've come across more than one reefer who states the opposite of what you claim just today in this one subforum. It's apparently not rare to see visible benefits to N and P above zero on hobby test kits.

This was posted just 2 hours ago:

This is purely my own opinion on acro care but I would get that no3 above 5 as a starting point. Keep it there for a couple of weeks to see if your acros like that and start coloring up. I would bet they not only start coloring up but start to grow a bit quicker. I never let my nitrate get below 5. The SPS clearly show a negative reaction when it has.
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/no3-staying-very-low-in-mature-tank.1098552/post-13337618
What fun would it be if we all agreed on everything? lol

:)
 
@Randy Holmes-Farley

I think I’ve asked you this in the past, but I’d like to ask again:

For acropora growth, do you think there’s a target range of nitrate and phosphate you’d recommend for the best chance of growth?

Growth is very important to me. What do the studies seem to suggest?

I feed my corals with phytoplankton. Feeding isn’t an issue for me. It will be helpful to have a range to follow. I personally do best with clear-cut guidelines.

Today my phosphate is 0.05ppm and nitrate is 1.5ppm.
 
Last edited:
@Randy Holmes-Farley

I think I’ve asked you this in the past, but I’d like to ask again:

For acropora growth, do you think there’s a target range of nitrate and phosphate you’d recommend for the best chance of growth?

Growth is very important to me. What do the studies seem to suggest?

I feed my corals with phytoplankton. Feeding isn’t an issue for me. It will be helpful to have a range to follow. I personally do best with clear-cut guidelines.
I didn’t know acros ate phyto. I’d think feeding is important but I always thought zoo plankton (or like particles) were food for SPS.

It’s an interesting question, look forward to the response. I certainly don’t know the answer but my sense is it’s more complex than a target level of nutrients. For example, I’d think higher P and N and alkalinity and maybe other stuff could work in concert for more growth. Seems like you’d need to push many parameters so they are not limiting. Also, I used to think too much phosphate negatively impacts calcification. Not sure if that’s actually true.

Lastly, I’d think ammonia would be far superior to nitrate.

Obviously just spit balling.
 
I didn’t know acros ate phyto. I’d think feeding is important but I always thought zoo plankton (or like particles) were food for SPS.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0044848619310282
Continuous feeding of Isochrysis galbana promotes improved growth and nutritional composition in captive Acropora corals.


I certainly don’t know the answer but my sense is it’s more complex than a target level of nutrients.

I agree, of course. It just seems like nutrients, specifically phosphate, is a double edged sword. Corals need phosphate, but calcification is inhibited by it. What’s the balance? If other forms of P are fed, would lower PO4 lead to better growth?
Lastly, I’d think ammonia would be far superior to nitrate.
I think we can all agree on that. Studies don’t seem to find a correlation between nitrate and stunted growth. While I really like ammonia, having some nitrate is an assurance and can theoretically leave more ammonia for the organisms that depend on it.
 
I agree, of course. It just seems like nutrients, specifically phosphate, is a double edged sword. Corals need phosphate, but calcification is inhibited by it. What’s the balance? If other forms of P are fed, would lower PO4 lead to better growth?
Thanks for the info on phyto! I was just telling my wife last night that I want a small fridge with a mag stir to continuously feed phyto, but that’s just because I like all the flora and fauna that pop up. She didn’t seem to think it was a good an idea as I did :)

I think that’s the right idea on phosphate. It seems logical that more particulates with phosphorus would mean less phosphate is useful. The balance? I think that’s the million $ question. It’s hard to go heavy on phosphorus containing particulate food without getting a bunch of phosphate in the water.
 
I agree, of course. It just seems like nutrients, specifically phosphate, is a double edged sword. Corals need phosphate, but calcification is inhibited by it. What’s the balance? If other forms of P are fed, would lower PO4 lead to better growth?

I think we can all agree on that. Studies don’t seem to find a correlation between nitrate and stunted growth. While I really like ammonia, having some nitrate is an assurance and can theoretically leave more ammonia for the organisms that depend on it.
Here an article with details. Oldest publication usually weren't conducted under controlled conditions and sometimes are of little value. Nevertheless, results seem still to be present and even dominant in "reefer's knowledge". Specifically "phosphate inhibits calcification" seems to be based on a theory only and has not been verified under controlled conditions.
 
I have a very counter view on looking at ocean parameters and trying to correlate that to our hobby. I think it's a fools errand. Why? Because I contend that seeing near zero's on things like phos and nitrates in an ocean sample indicate an exhaustion of supply, not the supply itself. In other words if there were more available then a new organism would pop up and utilize it, hence resulting in values going back to near zero. I think a healthy wild reef is a voracious consumer of any and all available "nutrients" of every form so seeing little in the water column is misleading. Obviously there is a huge input of resources or the reef would not be flourishing. Until someone can actually determine what a specific coral is utilizing we just are left with supplying "enough" but not too much that we encourage runaway algae growth.
 
For acropora growth, do you think there’s a target range of nitrate and phosphate you’d recommend for the best chance of growth?

Growth is very important to me. What do the studies seem to suggest?


I don't have a good answer for that for a few reasons:

1. I think it will vary tank to tank for the reasons in the article involving different corals and different other N and P sources.

2. I think that it will also vary tank to tank due to what else might be growth limiting (more on this below).

3. I expect that there may be a very wide range of good coral growth between just barely enough nitrate and phosphate, and so much that one or both is retarding growth in a detectable fashion.

Expanding on #2, there's a general principle called Liebig's law of the minimum

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebig's_law_of_the_minimum
Basically, it states that only one nutrient or other factor can be growth limiting at a time. It may be a matter of debate whether it always holds, but let's go with it.

The limiting nutrient is the one that if you added more of, organisms will grow more. It could be light, trace elements of all sorts, including nutrients, flow, or other aspects of coral husbandry. For that one nutrient, if you add more, corals will grow more. If you add some other nutrient, the coral cannot grow faster because the first one becomes in short supply and the coral cannot grow. In some cases, the theory may be a bit black and white for something that may have grew areas, and folks need to recognize that certain things may partly substitute for one another (such as added organics in place of light) but others clearly cannot (iron in excess while manganese is limiting).

The reason i bring this up is that for either N or P to be growth limiting, nothing else can be growth limiting. Not alkalinity, not pH, not light, and not any other trace elements.

So what is growth limiting to acropora in many tanks? It appears that carbonate may often be limiting, based on the experiments showing an effect by increasing alk or pH. In that scenario, at least at the lower alk and ph range used, N and P must not be growth limiting. OTOH, after the alk and pH is raised, perhaps they are limiting in that experiment and the growth would have been even higher.

If we start from natural seawater levels of everything, what is limiting? It may be N and P in many reef tanks lacking as much particulate foods as the ocean has. But as we begin to raise N and P to the levels seen in reef tanks, what then becomes growth limiting? Carbonate in at least some.

But as we continue to ratchet each of these to higher levels, what is limiting may move around between light, flow, trace elements, nutrients, etc. Consequently, I think there is the potential for 100 different SPS tanks to have a variety of different factors that are growth limiting in each, and in those cases, reefers may find different levels of nitrate and phosphate may be optimal for growth in each.

That's the main reason, IMO, that one result from a coral farm or reefer who says X and Y are best for nitrate and phosphate for acropora growth may not extrapolate to other settings.
 
Obviously there is a huge input of resources or the reef would not be flourishing. Until someone can actually determine what a specific coral is utilizing we just are left with supplying "enough" but not too much that we encourage runaway algae growth.

I don't tend to agree with the final conclusion. Corals only know what is in the water contacting them, and flourish (or not) based on what is contacting them. They cannot respond or know about or care about how many other corals or other organisms nearby are also consuming nutrients.
 
I didn’t know acros ate phyto. I’d think feeding is important but I always thought zoo plankton (or like particles) were food for SPS.

I'd also add that dosing phyto almost certainly boosts the zooplankton concentration, even if folks don't see it.
 
Basically, it states that only one nutrient or other factor can be growth limiting at a time. It may be a matter of debate whether it always holds, but let's go with it.
I think this has to be taken with a grain of salt. So-called co-limitation occurs. For example green algae may be co-limited by iron and nitrogen.
 
Thanks Randy and everyone! This was very enlightening. I really enjoy this topic.
 
I don't tend to agree with the final conclusion. Corals only know what is in the water contacting them, and flourish (or not) based on what is contacting them. They cannot respond or know about or care about how many other corals or other organisms nearby are also consuming nutrients.
I think we actually agree here. My point isn't that they are all intertwined, rather that they are all drawing from the same pool at the same time and that each will pull as much as it can get eventually draining the pool. However if you add additional input they all "rev up" to get their share, still leaving the pool empty.
 
Addition: Particulate nutrients also seem to have a special quality for corals since after feeding they show no net uptake of dissolved reactive phosphate from the water for some time.
This is extremely interesting. Could you elaborate more? Seems simple but maybe not….
 
I have a very counter view on looking at ocean parameters and trying to correlate that to our hobby. I think it's a fools errand. Why? Because I contend that seeing near zero's on things like phos and nitrates in an ocean sample indicate an exhaustion of supply, not the supply itself. In other words if there were more available then a new organism would pop up and utilize it, hence resulting in values going back to near zero. I think a healthy wild reef is a voracious consumer of any and all available "nutrients" of every form so seeing little in the water column is misleading. Obviously there is a huge input of resources or the reef would not be flourishing. Until someone can actually determine what a specific coral is utilizing we just are left with supplying "enough" but not too much that we encourage runaway algae growth.
There is a similar theory (but a quite well proven one by himself) by Sorokin in his book on Coral Reef Ecology from the 90s. He describes a coral reef as a giant phosphate filter. The difference to your theory is only that the filter is based on the organic carbon photosynthetically produced mainly by corals and excreted with coral mucus. This starts a food chain from which corals benefit in multiple ways finally filtering a good portion of the "fixed" phosphate out of the water. The "fixed" phosphate is (coral mucus with) bacteria, small crustaceans, fish feces and so on and also dissolved phosphate dissolved from the rocks. The ecosystem is more than its parts.
 
I think this has to be taken with a grain of salt. So-called co-limitation occurs. For example green algae may be co-limited by iron and nitrogen.

I don’t dispute the possibility, but as a rationale for why different reefers make different assertions about growth at different nitrate and phosphate, I think it’s a decent explanation among several.
 
I wonder if it also plays a role what conditions our corals have been conditioned to. Many of the corals we keep have been propagated in captivity for generations, while others are wild-caught and come from very different marine environments—whose exact conditions we often do not really know.

I have tried to follow the approaches of experts and experienced reef keepers whom I highly respect—with varying degrees of success. I am always in search of the optimum.

One example is nitrogen: It has been widely suggested that corals prefer ammonium. I have dosed ammonium specifically, but my corals do not respond well when nitrate is undetectable. They do not show good polyp extension and tend to close up in the evening.

Regarding phosphate (PO₄), I have observed that my corals grow best when the value is above 0.07 mg/l. However, these are my observations in my tank—under the specific conditions that prevail there.

In the ocean, it is different: Either a coral is adapted to the conditions that exist there, or it disappears—and no one asks about it. Corals do not care what we consider optimal; they decide for themselves what works for them.

Which brings us back to Hans-Werner’s point: Do not chase after "optimal" numbers; instead, observe your tank and your corals—they will tell you what is trul
y optimal.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 6 37.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 5 31.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new