Randy's Tank and Learn Thread

I don’t have a theory, just a curiosity about what might stand out.

I had an outbreak about a year into my last tank. Very frustrating. It was smaller so I tackled it manually. Scrubbing rocks, mostly outside the tank, big water change(s). I also started to lightly carbon dose as nutrients were plentiful.

It’s just an anecdote like any other, a solution or a total coincidence or somewhere n between. I could theorise why it seemed to turn the tide but I’d just be guessing. Based on that experience I’d probably do the same today.

It was a messy long day of work. Low point in that tank for me. But that tank eventuated into my best one ever.

A tank breakdown and scrubbing is certainly an option, although one I fear.
 
What about one rock at a time and a peroxide scrub? Maybe you can test a rock or two and see how long the treatment lasts. The idea being that if you move slow enough between sections you may not upset to much?
 
Can the Mantis be rehomed while the Hares finish off the algae? Any room in the sump for him?

We caught one and a second one died. Have not spent the time needed to catch this last one.
 
What about one rock at a time and a peroxide scrub? Maybe you can test a rock or two and see how long the treatment lasts. The idea being that if you move slow enough between sections you may not upset to much?

Maybe. It might end up being a merry go round of one clean rock and a series of progressively worse ones. lol
 
I’m gutted to even post such a disaster picture, and was hoping I might never have to if the sea hares did their job, but here is the sickening mess:

IMG_6601.jpeg


This is what it looked like just 5 months ago:


IMG_5984.jpeg
 
Someone needs to invent a marine lawnmower for cutting down hair algae.

Is it clear what happened with the hares? One died. One is missing? Presumed dead? It sounds like they didn't have a chance to get to work?
 
I am not current on what you have tried but removing one rock at a time as an option suggested by BA may be worth while. A bucket, some gloves, calm music, peroxide...I don't know.

I think I read a mantis - was going to suggest some scarlets as those at some of my algae that looked like that. Of course this is the internet and I probably didn't have that type of algae - but anyway...

Forget what size tank you have but maybe see if Dr. Reef can send you a Gold Line Rabbitfish from Biota. They get extremely large but grow slow. Great algae eaters. Maybe they would work. Could always rehome it to a LFS if you are within driving.

Of course if time isn't really an option then neither is rehoming as that takes your time. So back to scrubbing rocks.

Of course this isn't your first rodeo so I'm guessing just finding something that fits your current time allocation to putter around. Good luck with whatever you choose.
 
I’ve been following your thread and I did suspect it might be Chlorodesmis, now that some of your corals are being affected too, I’m wondering if that could be what you’re dealing with. This algae can cause coral bleaching through direct contact and also produces toxins that put many herbivores off eating it.
 
I’m gutted to even post such a disaster picture, and was hoping I might never have to if the sea hares did their job, but here is the sickening mess:

IMG_6601.jpeg


This is what it looked like just 5 months ago:
It’s been years, but I’ve been there.. manual removal by the handfuls was my primary weapon. I’m not sure that the snails and urchin helped but they appeared to strip areas that were shortened by manual removal. I can’t image what would have worked without mostly plucking the stuff by hand.
 
I would be interested to know what the N/P concentrations are, a week(then 2) after pulling all the algea....
 
I propose a simple experiment...
Measure N/P a few weeks with the tank as it is.
Then pull all the algea.
Test and continue to track N/P as it grows back (assuming it will, all else the same).

If nothing else, we will have a idea of how much N/P that (weighed) amount of algea consumed and how long it took to grow back.
Would be doing this, regardless, until this is resolved.
 
Its not that bad. I have seen worse. Pull as much out by hand and scrub the rest. A big round brush works great to twist it onto and get out big pieces at one time. Long handle tapped to a tooth brush works good too. Then try and get a seahare again. Maybe even a little more radom flow. It will go away. Your tank is too young to be pretty yet .......
 
Thanks folks. It’s hard to get motivated with the tank so bad.
 
It's really not that bad.
My tank did this, to include 4" carpet over back glass.
I pulled it all for a year, then started only pulling what was on the rocks. The rocks seemed to stay cleaner for longer as the back glass continued to grow. Then vodka took car off the that.
 
I found it easier to use a 3/8 tubing and siphon it off. You can use the end of the tubing and kinda scrape the rock as you go and it will pull off most so that the CUC can get in and eat it easier. Glass scraping with a razor and siphon or the tubing so the CUC can get at it.. Was doing this 2 or 3 times a week. Eventually the spots with the GHA would get covered in biofilm and coralline and no more GHA. I was tossing in dozens of snails into a 20gal tank.. all sorts, turbo were most effective at clearing patches but they would die off. Also had an army of small red leg hermits.
 
I actually agree with a few folks above that it's not that bad for us outsiders looking in, though I understand your own frustration. And there is a wild beauty to the swaying hair algae.
 
I would be interested to know what the N/P concentrations are, a week(then 2) after pulling all the algea....

I propose a simple experiment...
Measure N/P a few weeks with the tank as it is.
Then pull all the algea.
Test and continue to track N/P as it grows back (assuming it will, all else the same).

If nothing else, we will have a idea of how much N/P that (weighed) amount of algea consumed and how long it took to grow back.
Would be doing this, regardless, until this is resolved.

I’ve never found a correlation in my system. I don’t test now, but when I was battling it back in the day,I tested like a madman, filling an entire notebook with tests and LaCl doses, etc. It’s part of the reason I don’t bother now.
 
I’m gutted to even post such a disaster picture, and was hoping I might never have to if the sea hares did their job, but here is the sickening mess:

IMG_6601.jpeg


This is what it looked like just 5 months ago:


IMG_5984.jpeg
Oh ya been there before! Honestly not bad. A solid hour of pulling clumps and then scrubbing with brushes. Followed up a few times a week. Probably for a few weeks! Gotta get it mowed down for the cuc to take over. Run the marineland magnum filter while cleaning to suck up debris during the process. I’d probably dump a liter or two of pods in also if this was mine. Best cuc by far is a thriving pod population though the mandarins might make that hard in the DT.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 13 35.1%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 37.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 10 27.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new