https://reeftopia.com/collections/gorgonians-and-sponges/products/red-tree-spongeI got one of these red tree sponges 17 months ago and all I can say about it is, it isn't dead. At best, it seems able to fend off algae at least mostly. It's in a high flow area and I dose live phyto as well as add Spirulina to my food. Has anyone gotten this sponge to grow?