How often do you do water changes and how big? With my particular refractometer and salt mix, the salinity would measure 1.026 or 35 15 minutes after I made the batch, but then would measure a fair bit lower several hours later. I was doing 25% WC every week and always having to correct up salinity until I started making my salt water the day before WC day.
Another possibility (that also flummoxed me). How stable is the water level in your DT? My overflow is difficult to dial in. Sometimes it leans pretty heavy on the emergency overflow and the water level in the DT is pretty high. Other times, it seems to find a balance just above the main return pipe. Point being, your ATO can fill the sump to the "correct" level, but if your DT is running too high, you're increasing your total water volume (and decreasing salinity).