So many pests! Help with Cloves?

What amount of water change would you consider it safe to return snails and softies back to the display tank?
I would do a few water changes - first one around 20% then a few more at 10% and add 1 or 2 snails to see how they do. If ok, then add more. If not, remove and do a few more water changes. It might take a little time as the effects can linger in a tank for a bit.
 
Help!
I have a 65g mature community reef with a mix of LPS and soft corals and a lot of Zoas.
I am watching an explosion of Clove polyps all over the sand and lower rocks. I also have some pesky xenia and GSP. Recently I have a high number of the tiny snails to eating algae off the glass at night. I have recently treated for bryopsis (pretty successfully) . My N03 and PO4 are near 0, because I imagine so much stuff growing is consuming all of it (it's always been 0 or near 0).
My problem now is the cloves are growing and FAST! Is there ANYTHING I can do? I note that the FenBendazole will likely kill about half my tank. I have LARGE toadstools and torches and hammers. Photos to follow.
So here is an update on my clove and fenbendazole situation. A week ago, I separated the soft corals the snails and the starfish into a 10 gallon quarantine tank. So far that tank is doing fine in the main tank, which is 65 gallons was prepared by removing carbon, removing the skimmer cup, but leaving the aeration and then dosing at 2 mg per gallon of fenbendazole. It’s been three days since I dosed the medication. All the remaining corals look stressed as expected, but the clove polyps have turned into white dots, which is also expected. now I have to remove the medication. My plan is to do a 25% water change today and add a double dose of activated carbon. I plan on repeating this three more times over the next two weeks 25% water change and replace the carbon every three or four days until the equivalent of 100% of water change and four double doses of activated carbon in my mind this sounds like it would remove the very vast majority of medication. Does anybody want to comment come confirm or refute this? I understand that a small amount of the 120 mg would be persistent in the sand bed or in the rocks. but I’m assuming that would be a very small amount and overtime. It would reach back into the water column and be absorbed by carbon. Do you think after those four large water changes and carbon doses I’d be safe to put back my soft corals? I only have one large snail and serpent star.
 
Hey guys, so here is the update:
I separated out my tank into Main tank (65g) and Quarantine (10g side tank). I moved all the soft corals, snails and serpent star to the 10g. I then took out the skimmer cup and carbon from the main tank. I then dosed 2g/Gal of Fenbendazole.
After 3 days, the remaining corals look stressed but alive, and the cloves look like white dots or closed up. I assume they will die off over time.
It's time to take the medication out. My plan is this.
25% water change tonight with addition of double dose of carbon.
Repeat this every 4 days for 4 times (total of 100% water change and 4 x replacement of carbon.

Thoughts on how much of the medication will be gone / left?
I know some trace amounts will remain in the sand rocks. But over time that will dissipate into the carbon...
After a few weeks, I will start reintroducing the soft corals back.
Thoughts?
 
Carbon and water changes are definitely the answer, but I do not know about time. I would also vacuum the substrate.

And I think out of caution, since there's no real way to test how much is left, I'd move a couple items over for a week or two and see how they do before moving everything back.

These stories are definitely what keeps me away from cloves... Gorgeous, but what a pain.
Good luck!
 
Update: So I finished the 1st dose at 2mg / gallon about 3 weeks ago. I have since done 3 25% water changes and a 15% water change. I have double dosed carbon and replaced weekly during that time. I have to say it LOOKED like the Cloves died at first, but some are coming back. I also note that at this time the many species of Zoanthids are still VERY annoyed and not fully open. Some LPS are doing "ok" but not super happy. Soft corals are still in separate tank doing "ok" along with big snap and serpent star. I was thinking of putting the tanks back together, but NOW I think I have to do a second dose on the main tank. Thoughts on this? repeat treatment, then wait 3 days and repeat the above water changes and carbon, and try again to reintegrate in a month?
 
Update: So I finished the 1st dose at 2mg / gallon about 3 weeks ago. I have since done 3 25% water changes and a 15% water change. I have double dosed carbon and replaced weekly during that time. I have to say it LOOKED like the Cloves died at first, but some are coming back. I also note that at this time the many species of Zoanthids are still VERY annoyed and not fully open. Some LPS are doing "ok" but not super happy. Soft corals are still in separate tank doing "ok" along with big snap and serpent star. I was thinking of putting the tanks back together, but NOW I think I have to do a second dose on the main tank. Thoughts on this? repeat treatment, then wait 3 days and repeat the above water changes and carbon, and try again to reintegrate in a month?
Do you have any updates on your progress? I am having the same issue with blue clove polyps, and am weighing up whether to give fenbendazole a try.
 
Update: So. bad news. Well.. perspective. The cloves are dead. But. So are the rest of my corals. 100% tank crash. Fish ok.
After 2 months of water changes and carbon, i decided re re-merge the soft corals back to the main tank. Mistake. They started dying quickly. Within 2 more weeks the tank fully crashed. Now I basically have a bunch of rocks with GHA and Diatoms all over it.
Sad.
was such a cool reef.
Fenbendazole must still be present.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new