Surge protection and GFCI - Electricians help!

  • Thread starter Thread starter kitti-fish
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

kitti-fish

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 13, 2024
Messages
582
Reaction score
713
Location
USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
After doing some wiring and having to redo it all, I happened to find articles about GFCI. I definitely want protection so great! I considered replacing the outlet but then read your pump shouldn’t be directly plugged into GFCI and so I’m leaning towards a plug with a weatherproof cover over the outlets so one can be just the pump and one can house the GFCI extender that two extensions plugs will go into. Awesome. Now I’m stumped; I’ve read up at surge protected extension can trip GFCI and it’s counterintuitive. I have two that have my lights, heater, wave maker and skimmer plugs. Am I overdoing it with the GFCI? I want this to be my final build and want to do it right but have so much information I don’t know where to start. Any help please!
 
I use GFCI and plug them into these. Works well.
Get 20amp GFCI'S.
20260106_103745.jpg
 
Just leave the normal house receptacle there. Get this awesome invention Kasa Strip now you have surge protection and app control of your tank.
I wouldn't put one of those near my tank or call it any type of protection and to that end, "surge" protection and "shock" protection are entirely different things.

And that is ignoring having to signup for a China controlled app to run the thing.


After doing some wiring and having to redo it all, I happened to find articles about GFCI. I definitely want protection so great! I considered replacing the outlet but then read your pump shouldn’t be directly plugged into GFCI and so I’m leaning towards a plug with a weatherproof cover over the outlets so one can be just the pump and one can house the GFCI extender that two extensions plugs will go into. Awesome. Now I’m stumped; I’ve read up at surge protected extension can trip GFCI and it’s counterintuitive. I have two that have my lights, heater, wave maker and skimmer plugs. Am I overdoing it with the GFCI? I want this to be my final build and want to do it right but have so much information I don’t know where to start. Any help please!
I would NOT run the aquarium without full GFCI protection. Personal safety is far more important than uptime. That said, properly setup, modern GFCIs are unlikely to nuisance trip due to a pump motor or ballast being plugged into them.

A single GFCI is a singe point of failure, be it clearing a fault, or from a nuisance trip. If either is your concern then you will want to split the load between 2 or more GFCI receptacles. Without going into detail, using multiple GFCIs to run equipment instead of stacking it all on a single GFCI will also GREATLY reduce the chance of nuisance tripping.

How you do this depends on your experience and understanding, but assuming your level of understanding contextually from your question, you should consult an qualified electrician.

GFCI receptacles can be wired in parallel and share a single branch circuit, just like any other receptacle. They should never be wired in series with the load side of one GFCI feeding the line side of the next. Again, consult an electrician.
 
Last edited:
After doing some wiring and having to redo it all, I happened to find articles about GFCI. I definitely want protection so great! I considered replacing the outlet but then read your pump shouldn’t be directly plugged into GFCI and so I’m leaning towards a plug with a weatherproof cover over the outlets so one can be just the pump and one can house the GFCI extender that two extensions plugs will go into. Awesome. Now I’m stumped; I’ve read up at surge protected extension can trip GFCI and it’s counterintuitive. I have two that have my lights, heater, wave maker and skimmer plugs. Am I overdoing it with the GFCI? I want this to be my final build and want to do it right but have so much information I don’t know where to start. Any help please!
Maybe Install GFCI breaker on your breaker box feeding the line you want.
 
After doing some wiring and having to redo it all, I happened to find articles about GFCI. I definitely want protection so great! I considered replacing the outlet but then read your pump shouldn’t be directly plugged into GFCI and so I’m leaning towards a plug with a weatherproof cover over the outlets so one can be just the pump and one can house the GFCI extender that two extensions plugs will go into. Awesome. Now I’m stumped; I’ve read up at surge protected extension can trip GFCI and it’s counterintuitive. I have two that have my lights, heater, wave maker and skimmer plugs. Am I overdoing it with the GFCI? I want this to be my final build and want to do it right but have so much information I don’t know where to start. Any help please!
I would not seek electrical advice on a reefing forum. Already too many threads with much conflicting advice. As stated talk to an electrician who actually knows his trade
 
I would not seek electrical advice on a reefing forum. Already too many threads with much conflicting advice. As stated talk to an electrician who actually knows his trade
Yes well said! I had an electrician install all mine. Don't mess with electricity hire a licensed electrician.
 
After doing some wiring and having to redo it all, I happened to find articles about GFCI. I definitely want protection so great! I considered replacing the outlet but then read your pump shouldn’t be directly plugged into GFCI and so I’m leaning towards a plug with a weatherproof cover over the outlets so one can be just the pump and one can house the GFCI extender that two extensions plugs will go into. Awesome. Now I’m stumped; I’ve read up at surge protected extension can trip GFCI and it’s counterintuitive. I have two that have my lights, heater, wave maker and skimmer plugs. Am I overdoing it with the GFCI? I want this to be my final build and want to do it right but have so much information I don’t know where to start. Any help please!
I used a couple of these connected to a power strip that goes to the wall. From these I separated out my devices so that the return pump is separate from the flow pumps. The thought being that if one trips that there would still be flow in the tank of some sort.

https://www.lowes.com/pd/Southwire-Black-Single-Outlet-GFCI-Adapter/5001992601
May be OK? I am not an electrician. lol
 
There are GFCI and AFCI breakers and they are different the AFCI breakers used to nuisance trip all the time with motors plugged in but they have greatly improved. A lot of AFCI problems were actually from an incorrectly connected neutral wire. Outlets are another story, with most people buying a 15 amp GFCI outlet not understanding the reason it is cheaper. If you buy a 20 amp GFCI outlet you ar unlikey to overload it unless you have a very large tank and lots of equipment. Also outlets behind a tank (or sump usually) can get corroded inside over time and trip easier and possibly cause a fire from overheating due to the poor electrical connection the corrosion causes. This is why some people say not to install them behind the tank even though this is the most convenient and "clean" place for the cords. They do make outdoor rated "weather resistant" outlets which would be much better if behind a tank. They also make dual rated GFCI/AFCI outlets and breakers. Afci will protect against arcing which can happen if there is a damaged cord or corrosion in any of the connections. The arcing also happens when something is unplugged while running (think housewife with vacuum) which is one of the more common nuisance tripping of AFCI.
 
I would not seek electrical advice on a reefing forum. Already too many threads with much conflicting advice. As stated talk to an electrician who actually knows his trade
I find that advice to be shocking!

But it’s also true. We do have some electricity gurus who post here but they are hard to discern amongst the rest of us well meaning people who lack the fundamental skills needed to ensure a safe environment.

A properly wired circuit is essential for insurance coverage when the Chinese made GFCI’s fail and the tank and the dwelling unit are destroyed by fire.
 
If you buy a 20 amp GFCI outlet you ar unlikey to overload it
The receptacle rating is irrelevant here. The breaker is what determines the circuit capacity. A 15A and 20A GFCI receptacle both trip at the same ground-fault current threshold. In general you can NOT put a 20A receptacle on a 15A circuit because it allows single loads to be connected that exceed the breakers maximum capacity.

The arcing also happens when something is unplugged while running (think housewife with vacuum) which is one of the more common nuisance tripping of AFCI.
The issue is not arcing caused by unplugging a running appliance, but the electrical noise generated by brushed motors (such as many vacuums). That electrical noise can resemble an arcing signature to the AFCI and result in nuisance trips.
 
Last edited:
I would not seek electrical advice on a reefing forum. Already too many threads with much conflicting advice. As stated talk to an electrician who actually knows his trade
I think you can trust Bean. It appears to me he has been in the trade for some time. Even though I was in the trade for 50+ years I have been out now for over 6 years so my experience with this equipment is that “outdated ?” Very little changes in method and practice in this trade but the equipment does. It does keep getting better. As evidenced by in my day gfci breakers were not as good as the outlets and so my advice always was use an outlet. Closer to the use and less costly, and easy to test, but that may have changed by now.
 
It appears to me he has been in the trade for some time.
I want to be clear so that there is no misunderstanding.

While I have a lifetime of hands-on experience in residential and commercial electrical work, with some mining and industrial exposure, am well versed in code, theory, and practice, and have worked alongside or under licensed electricians, I am not a licensed electrician in any jurisdiction or trade. The same applies to plumbing. I can design the system, cite applicable code, perform the work, and pass inspection, but I do not hold a plumbers card.
 
The receptacle rating is irrelevant here. The breaker is what determines the circuit capacity. A 15A and 20A GFCI receptacle both trip at the same ground-fault current threshold.
This is true, i went back and reread the thread and realized it wasnt the OP that said they ran a new 20 amp breaker and circuit. Once again i am guilty of not giving complete information. I wasnt referring to the tripping from ground fault but the current load that happens much easier on a 15 amp versus 20 amp gfci receptacle (outlet). I am not suggesting you overload anything but know your load. The heat caused by current load (Watts) will also cause it to trip without a groung fault being present similar to a breaker(standard or gfci). Installing a 20 amp receptacle on a circuit protected by a 15 amp breaker wont gain you any extra load to plug into since the breaker will still trip when overloaded, but a 15 amp gfci receptacle on a 20 amp circuit is asking for early failure IMO. ( as an example, many hair dryers are all a 15 amp gfci receptacle can handle!) The other thing that happens is if tripped regularly they get weaker and trip more easily over time. ___AND PLEASE PEOPLE DO NOT SWITCH A 15 AMP BREAKER TO A 20 AMP BREAKER IN YOUR PANEL!___ NEVER,EVER,EVER PLEASE!!!___If its a 15 amp breaker on a 14 gauge wire it cant handle the load of a 20 amp. Thats 1 way electrical fires get started. A 20 amp breaker needs to have 12 gauge wire to carry that much load.
We all should know how much load we are plugging into the circuit we are using to avoid this. Leave a 15% margin for continuous loads as well!
Example: a 15 amp circuit should only have a total of appx. 1500 watts of load, AND THAT INCLUSES EVERYTHING PLUGGED INTO EVERY RECEPTACLE ON THAT CIRCUIT, not just the 1 receptacle by our tanks. For safety on a reef tank circuit i would consider everything plugged in a continuous load even though it technically isnt. On a medium to large tank 1500 watts isnt really very much at all. All our pumps, lights, heaters, and misc. that gets plugged in have their watt rating listed somewhere (unless the label is missing). Ideally a reef system would have more than 1 circuit so its harder to overload and if it trips not everything loses power.
 
This post got me thinking of ideas to easily incorporate a GFCI. What is everyone's opinion's on one of these?
1767801343314.png
 
This is true, i went back and reread the thread and realized it wasnt the OP that said they ran a new 20 amp breaker and circuit. Once again i am guilty of not giving complete information. I wasnt referring to the tripping from ground fault but the current load that happens much easier on a 15 amp versus 20 amp gfci receptacle (outlet).
To be clear:

The only functional difference between 15 A and 20 A receptacles is the plug blade configuration that they accept. A 20 A receptacle allows a 20 A plug and a 15 A receptacle does not.

A 20 A branch circuit may use 15 A receptacles, and those receptacles are not limited to supplying only 15 A. They are protected by the 20 A breaker.

A 15 A branch circuit is limited to 15 A receptacles.

Circuit ampacity is set by the breaker, not the receptacle.

, but a 15 amp gfci receptacle on a 20 amp circuit is asking for early failure IMO.

No, that is not the case. A 15 A GFCI receptacle on a 20 A circuit does not in any way promote early failure. Again, the receptacle rating only limits the plug type that can be connected. Circuit ampacity is determined by the breaker and conductors. Full Stop.


Leave a 15% margin for continuous loads as well!
The correct number is 20%. The NEC uses an 80% guideline of breaker rating for continuous loads. This is to avoid nuisance tripping, not because operation above that level presents an inherent safety risk. Standard thermal-magnetic breakers trip faster as they operate closer to their threshold. Motor inrush current can briefly exceed the breaker rating, causing nuisance trips. See TCC charts for a better understanding of why 80% is the standard.



My intention is not to single you out, but this subject is extremely sensitive. Electrical advice needs to be precise. We recently lost a forum member to electrocution while working on his aquarium, and unclear or partially incorrect guidance must be avoided.
 
Last edited:
This post got me thinking of ideas to easily incorporate a GFCI. What is everyone's opinion's on one of these?
1767801343314.png
They are fine with a few caveats.

1) many do not auto reset after power failure. Check the labeling and test before trusting!

2) some brands are more prone to nuisance tripping than name brand receptacles and breakers. So keep an eye on them until you are sure that they are stable in your setup.
 
They are fine with a few caveats.

1) many do not auto reset after power failure. Check the labeling and test before trusting!

2) some brands are more prone to nuisance tripping than name brand receptacles and breakers. So keep an eye on them until you are sure that they are stable in your setup.
Appreciate your advice, you seem very educated in the subject.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 17.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.3%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.5%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.3%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 15 15.8%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 12 12.6%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 25.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.4%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new