This topic had been done on Reef2Reef numerous times. The result is pretty much always the same:
1. The old timers and broke reefers swear by IO/RC and insist the brown dookie-like sludge on your mixing container is reef fertilizer
2. The deeper pocket reefers and tech nerds insist Nyos Pure and Tropic Marin are the best since they mix clean and quickly
3. The newbs and below average intelligence reefers use RedSea even though there are much better options at the same price or cheoser
4. The hippies and stoners use NSW
5. The masochists use ESV
6. The randos use the other smaller brands like AF, FM, Fritz, etc. because they want to be cool and different
Pick your poison!