Paul B
10K Club member
View Badges
Excellence Award
Reef Tank 365
Reef Of The Month
Article Contributor
Rock Pool Reef Keepers
My Aquarium Showcase
- Joined
- Nov 3, 2010
- Messages
- 21,985
- Reaction score
- 74,722
- Location
- Long Island NY
- What state or country do you live in
- New York
Carbon is great for adsorbing many things including toxins but I don't use carbon. I used it for many years but I feel it removes to many things that I actually want. It also contributes (a lot) to HLLE, but I think there are other factors involved in that too.
It is just another un-natural addition to tanks that many of us use that I feel is in some cases detrimental to water conditions for the reasons I said. There are thousands of chemicals in seawater, most we don't even know what purpose, if any they serve but carbon removes most of them in different amounts and I assume many of those things are a benefit to a tank.
I am not sure why my tank runs so good with no problems, no diseases etc. But
those unknown chemicals may be one reason.
Metals are one element we have in our tanks and I am sure with my NSW I have a lot of metals in there. Metals are needed in the exact proportions that are in NSW and our fish evolved with them. Metals are one thing carbon is very good at removing.
Of course I am guessing
It is just another un-natural addition to tanks that many of us use that I feel is in some cases detrimental to water conditions for the reasons I said. There are thousands of chemicals in seawater, most we don't even know what purpose, if any they serve but carbon removes most of them in different amounts and I assume many of those things are a benefit to a tank.
I am not sure why my tank runs so good with no problems, no diseases etc. But
those unknown chemicals may be one reason.
Metals are one element we have in our tanks and I am sure with my NSW I have a lot of metals in there. Metals are needed in the exact proportions that are in NSW and our fish evolved with them. Metals are one thing carbon is very good at removing.
Of course I am guessing
