Tank decision

[rjp64]

Im getting back into the hobby and can't decide on either an AIO or conventional tank with hob and skimmer. Looking at 30-40 gals. Im in an apartment so id like to go sumpless. Any suggestions? My target is softies an some acans

 

[Sam7]

Lots of options.....whats the budget?

 

[NanoSteam]

If the choice is between AIO or HOB gear I'm choosing AIO every day of the week because I really can't stand the look of gear in the display plus you get a little extra room to do things in the rear chambers like a small fuge or a rubble rock section for pods and such.

EDIT: to add one more option, I'm ok with canister filters and you could also go with something like a standard tank with an Oase canister that has the heater in it.

 

[Kodski]

Just curious, why does living in an apartment deter you from having a sump?

Equipment specifically for use in AIO and Hang on back systems is extremely limited in both options and size. In the end I believe it tends to be a hardship fought by the reefer of never quite having the right tool for the right job. Just by having a sump you open up a ton of options for equipment with lots of reviews and experience from fellow reefers. Not only that, I've had AIO's before and they are better than HOB in my opinion, but I pretty much always tear the system apart and go with a sump in the end.

If you ask me, 60 breeder with a 20 gallon long sump is the perfect setup for cheap. If that's too large, go down to a 40 breeder. Both options bring a ton of equipment options to the table but also livestock options. A 60 breeder has enough space to be a forever home for a small bristletooth tang (in my opinion with the correct rockwork) which will help a ton with algae control. You'll also have enough room for many other options like small angelfish, a few wrasses, and a few other fish. While a 40 breeder is likely enough for a juvenile bristletooth, its likely too small to be a forever home to one. (I would recommend an algae blenny aka a lawnmower blenny in its place) You still have a good many of options of fish though, while going any smaller would really limit those options.

 

[rjp64]

Kodski my apt is tiny so just researching different setups. Alot has changed since last tank

 

[Gumbies R Us]

I like AIO's. I started with one and don't regret it. They are good tanks for both beginners and those who want to get back into the hobby. Both Waterbox and IM sell AIO tanks that are 30g, and both of those I would recommend if you want to go the AIO route.