Tank pest/Bacterial or other issue?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AB's reef
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
Were the mariculture plugs kept? My advice on plugs in general is to scrap them...and Mari plugs can come with a host of issues themselves. Its certainly possible that the plugs themselves have Introduced a bacteria that doesnt agree with the balance of the tank. It's also plausible that its taken this long to proliferate to an unhealthy balance. There are vendors that have used chemiclean to stop rtn in acros. Not sure the availability in UK. Cipro has also been used to combat bacterial. I wouldn't use them in tandem fwiw bc I don't know the benefit or detriment of that. Obviously, research the dosing and disposal well before application of the cipro. Be prepared for a possible dino outbreak afterward as well. Some have experienced them and some have not post treatment. As far as the newer aefw..has he/she been dipping and inspecting for any signs of them or eggs? The eggs are mighty small...I usually use an led microscope to inspect any incoming frags or existing coral in tank if there are any problems. Here's the newer type as seen through a stereoscope.

20231102_075746.jpg
20231101_113503.jpg

Anyhoo...hope it narrows it down a bit and or at least provides info for someone in the future once its sorted.
 
Sometimes local municipalities boost their chlorine levels (especially in the summer) or change from chlorine to chloramine or vise versa which can quickly deplete a standard carbon block. I have heard of this causing seemingly unexplainable acute problems as you describe.
 
Were the mariculture plugs kept? My advice on plugs in general is to scrap them...and Mari plugs can come with a host of issues themselves. Its certainly possible that the plugs themselves have Introduced a bacteria that doesnt agree with the balance of the tank. It's also plausible that its taken this long to proliferate to an unhealthy balance. There are vendors that have used chemiclean to stop rtn in acros. Not sure the availability in UK. Cipro has also been used to combat bacterial. I wouldn't use them in tandem fwiw bc I don't know the benefit or detriment of that. Obviously, research the dosing and disposal well before application of the cipro. Be prepared for a possible dino outbreak afterward as well. Some have experienced them and some have not post treatment. As far as the newer aefw..has he/she been dipping and inspecting for any signs of them or eggs? The eggs are mighty small...I usually use an led microscope to inspect any incoming frags or existing coral in tank if there are any problems. Here's the newer type as seen through a stereoscope.
Looks like the "new" AEFW (NAEFW) are also limited to Acropora spp., so if OP has issues with other corals it's less likely to be the issue. (Wang et al. 2019)
However it's obviously a good idea to check for parasites up close, but OP needs to be aware that once corals start losing tissue a lot of obligatory organisms will appear including those that are visible with the naked eye like amphipods, copepods, isopods, bristleworms, and also otherwise harmless flatworms, etc., so not every organism on the coral will actually cause problems.

From what I have seen in the linked article and its featured images those NAEFW stay on the raw skeleton for a moment so OP should be able to see them, probably even without microscope. I'm not sure if they are capable of overrunning so many corals over night while others stay completely unaffected for the moment though.

I didn't hear about the NAEFW until now, so thank you very much for the hint 😁
 
Looks like the "new" AEFW (NAEFW) are also limited to Acropora spp., so if OP has issues with other corals it's less likely to be the issue. (Wang et al. 2019)
However it's obviously a good idea to check for parasites up close, but OP needs to be aware that once corals start losing tissue a lot of obligatory organisms will appear including those that are visible with the naked eye like amphipods, copepods, isopods, bristleworms, and also otherwise harmless flatworms, etc., so not every organism on the coral will actually cause problems.

From what I have seen in the linked article and its featured images those NAEFW stay on the raw skeleton for a moment so OP should be able to see them, probably even without microscope. I'm not sure if they are capable of overrunning so many corals over night while others stay completely unaffected for the moment though.

I didn't hear about the NAEFW until now, so thank you very much for the hint 😁
Not sure what acropora spp is limited to. They didn't like milles where as to the regular aefw loved milles. The only reason I found them was due to thinking I had rtn on multiple acros and I dipped and inspected. For sure not saying its the cause here...just something to be wary of.
 
Were the mariculture plugs kept? My advice on plugs in general is to scrap them...and Mari plugs can come with a host of issues themselves. Its certainly possible that the plugs themselves have Introduced a bacteria that doesnt agree with the balance of the tank. It's also plausible that its taken this long to proliferate to an unhealthy balance. There are vendors that have used chemiclean to stop rtn in acros. Not sure the availability in UK. Cipro has also been used to combat bacterial. I wouldn't use them in tandem fwiw bc I don't know the benefit or detriment of that. Obviously, research the dosing and disposal well before application of the cipro. Be prepared for a possible dino outbreak afterward as well. Some have experienced them and some have not post treatment. As far as the newer aefw..has he/she been dipping and inspecting for any signs of them or eggs? The eggs are mighty small...I usually use an led microscope to inspect any incoming frags or existing coral in tank if there are any problems. Here's the newer type as seen through a stereoscope.

20231102_075746.jpg
20231101_113503.jpg

Anyhoo...hope it narrows it down a bit and or at least provides info for someone in the future once its sorted.
Thank you! much appreciated!
I'll get him to inspect everything that comes out of the tank.
I'm 95% leaning more towards the Bacteria at this point but I certainly don't think it will hurt for him to check and me/anyone who reads this thread when adding corals to our systems.

He's on setting up a 300ltr QT system, once he's got the Bacteria issue under control I think he's planning on treating the corals with Milbex (milbemycin oxime & praziquantel) as well as any new additions.
I've told him to take plenty of photos, dosage and record the outcome of treatments which I'll either post in here or create a separate thread once we've got some results.
 
Sometimes local municipalities boost their chlorine levels (especially in the summer) or change from chlorine to chloramine or vise versa which can quickly deplete a standard carbon block. I have heard of this causing seemingly unexplainable acute problems as you describe.
I did think of this earlier on in the diagnosis as my tap water had a strong scent of Chlorine and he's only about 30 miles down the road; he's pretty sharp on changing his RODI filters and resins.. It's possible that maybe the old filters let a little bit through if they were depleted and then the water was treated that week but I think any issue would have subsided fairly quickly as he's running a constant auto water change,
Also his fish stock, pods etc would certainly have suffered also?
He's been doing fairly regular ammonia tests since the issue started and I'm guessing anything that took out a large population of zooplankton would certainly show something in regards to ammonia or at least a spike in N/P?

You've got me thinking on testing my own RODI water every week with some test strips though!

Thank you! Certainly food for thought, considering how much my water smelt a couple weeks ago.
 
Looks like the "new" AEFW (NAEFW) are also limited to Acropora spp., so if OP has issues with other corals it's less likely to be the issue. (Wang et al. 2019)
However it's obviously a good idea to check for parasites up close, but OP needs to be aware that once corals start losing tissue a lot of obligatory organisms will appear including those that are visible with the naked eye like amphipods, copepods, isopods, bristleworms, and also otherwise harmless flatworms, etc., so not every organism on the coral will actually cause problems.

From what I have seen in the linked article and its featured images those NAEFW stay on the raw skeleton for a moment so OP should be able to see them, probably even without microscope. I'm not sure if they are capable of overrunning so many corals over night while others stay completely unaffected for the moment though.

I didn't hear about the NAEFW until now, so thank you very much for the hint 😁
Thanks again for posting, I've told him to set up a QT tank in his old 300ltr display and treat it as a Bacterial issue while continuing to check for any pests + maintain the main display tank at 100% until things start to show signs of recovering or no further issues can be observed.

Once he's got some results back I'll post them on here, if there's plenty of success I'll make a separate thread and hopefully it might save someone else the big losses he's had over the last 5-6 weeks.

Can't thank you enough for getting involved, much appreciated!

Andrew.
 
Would a couple of big water changes help flush the bacteria out the tank ?
I would assume that the potential pathogens are mostly found localized within the affected corals and then spread from there, so neither water changes nor UV sterilization will provide sufficient protection as their reproduce where water changes can't get them.

Water changes would however normalize water parameters which would certainly be beneficial. I would suggest smaller changes though to make sure parameters are changing slowly to not stress the corals even more.
 
Just a quick update, the effected tank kept getting worse over the past week and he has set up a smaller tank in a rush to act as quarantine; done a iodine treatment as it was the only anti bacterial available on short notice.
Losses slowed down but while the effected corals were handy he magnified in to check for any other possible pests and found a decent of white bugs.
He's treated the tank with Milbemycin and the coral losses have almost stopped + PE is returning to some corals.

Are white bugs capable for causing such losses, so quickly and in a manner where it basically moves around the tank 1 by 1 overnight or could this have just been a possible stress factor for the bacteria to enter the coral tissue?
For the tank to be totally healthy 1 minute to losing 100+ healthy colonies/frags has me wondering if they were there all along and reproducing to a number capable of wiping out the entire tank in less than a month or if there is an underlying issue?

Thanks again,
Andrew.
 
Are white bugs capable for causing such losses, so quickly and in a manner where it basically moves around the tank 1 by 1 overnight or could this have just been a possible stress factor for the bacteria to enter the coral tissue?
For the tank to be totally healthy 1 minute to losing 100+ healthy colonies/frags has me wondering if they were there all along and reproducing to a number capable of wiping out the entire tank in less than a month or if there is an underlying issue?
I could imagine the white bugs spread throughout the tank and weakened the corals to the point where they were unable to fight off potential infections. Once the first coral got hit by some pathogens, the other already weakened corals stood no chance against the flood of harmful bacteria and protozoans.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 21 25.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 7 8.6%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 30 37.0%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.5%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 21 25.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new