Three Noisy Drain Issues; I Would Love to Solve One!

QuitterJr

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
37
Reaction score
34
Location
Washington, D.C.
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I am slowly but surely getting my Waterbox INFINIA Reef 190.5 set up after my RedSea seem broke over the summer.

I finally have everything solved, but the Waterbox overflow and ReefMat are giving me trouble.

The ReefMat makes a loud washing machine noise. I can see the bubbles in the unit, but others seem to have them without noise. I tried redoing the connection to the drain line and reseating the rods at the base after looking at other posts, but no luck.

The drain line is separately somewhat loud. I suspect it is the corrugated tube provided for the ReefMat, but again I did not see other fixes to this problem.

It looks like the Waterbox overflow is known to be loud. I think I could fix the waterfall sound by letting water trickle into the emergency drain, but I do not love the idea of regularly flowing into the emergency drain, and I would need to lower the sump side to stop splashing. I originally set the sump side of the emergency drain high with the idea that I would want to hear splashing. In case it helps, there is large variation in the waterfall noise, and the overflow level does not seem to stay at a stable level.

Videos below.

Thank you so much for any ideas!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2720.mov
    13 MB
  • IMG_2721.mov
    10.7 MB
  • IMG_2722.mov
    11.8 MB
I forgot to note that I am using a Varios 8 on the lowest setting for the return. One setting higher creates a very loud waterfall in the sump over an baffle and seemed very fast.

I think the return chamber would empty without much room to add more water to the sump if I went to a third setting higher.
 
For anyone else who may have the same problem, I think raising my ReefMat to 1” below the water line and reducing my Varios 8 to the lowest setting with minimum sump volume above the return may fix 2/3 of the issues.

I may need to resign myself to a fair amount falling down the emergency drain with surface waves from powerheads. I would love to avoid the result, but I have not been able to find any feedback directly on point. I suspect the Waterbox weirs just cannot handle much surface turbulence. I also received multiple Waterbox plumping replacements of varying heights for the same pieces, so the emergency overflow may simply be cut too low.

I will try raising my ReefMat much higher than the hang-on default and lowering the enegebcy drain to permit more flow without as much noise tomorrow. I am not happy with either result, so I would still love to hear alternatives. I feel like Waterbox just adding weird to the sides of the overflows would fix all of the waterfalling issues.
 
For anyone else who may have the same problem, I think raising my ReefMat to 1” below the water line and reducing my Varios 8 to the lowest setting with minimum sump volume above the return may fix 2/3 of the issues.

I may need to resign myself to a fair amount falling down the emergency drain with surface waves from powerheads. I would love to avoid the result, but I have not been able to find any feedback directly on point. I suspect the Waterbox weirs just cannot handle much surface turbulence. I also received multiple Waterbox plumping replacements of varying heights for the same pieces, so the emergency overflow may simply be cut too low.

I will try raising my ReefMat much higher than the hang-on default and lowering the enegebcy drain to permit more flow without as much noise tomorrow. I am not happy with either result, so I would still love to hear alternatives. I feel like Waterbox just adding weird to the sides of the overflows would fix all of the waterfalling issues.
I not knowing much about your overflow would try what you seem to be doing playing with the height of your primary . Are you using a double elbow in the overflow? If not I would try that with a small hole drilled in the top . It was suggested to me to put the pipe deeper into the sump as well . You did not say what drain design you have , but if you can change to a bean animal so it is three pipe . Then no need to be using your emergency drain . Possible easy experiments ?
 
Thank you! I am using a Herbie drain with the stock overflow side plumbing for the Waterbox INFINIA Reef 190.5.

I made a lot of progress narrowing down the issues by raising the ReefMat and straightening the flexible plumbing that comes with it and is attached to the main drain.

I now only face one issue, which is still extremely frustrating and difficult for me to solve. Every 20-30 seconds, there is surging into the overflow. That prevents me from tuning the gate valve on the drain because it is either quiet with large surges down the emergency drain or very loud and fluctuating with the overflow waterfall. It is not the powerheads because I tested with them off.

I also used a manifold pumping back into the sump to further reduce return pump speed because I suspected the drain could not keep up with the flow even at the lowest setting of my return. However, that did not work.

At this point, I think the corrugated ReefMat return connection is just building pressure and releasing for some reason. I hear a large bubble in the line or ReefMat every minute or two. I already shortened it and made it as downward sloping without dips as possible.

I ordered parts to hard plumb the ReefMat on Saturday, but I would love any other suggestions to fix the surging. I am not sure that I can do the pinhole/durso suggestion with my Herbie layout. I am also not certain that hard plumbing the drain to the ReefMat is going to fix the problem.
 
The only remaining step that I can think of for air or syphon issues is to hard plumb the drain line to the ReefMat. However, I am holding off on that last step because, after taking all other steps I could think of, I am certain that the last remaining surge is actually due to powerheads. The other steps made a huge difference, but I still get a slight surge every 20-30 seconds. I now turn off powerheads, and it is silent.

I have tried moving my two MP40s down to the halfway point near the front glass on opposite ends, but the surge still slightly occurs even on constant speed. The max speed is only 40% on one for a 5 foot tank.

I am a loss as to why turbulence is causing so many issues in the overflow. I may try installing a bubble trap below the overflow to just accept the surge and minimize the noise.

Please let me know if this is too many OP posts. I am hopeful others can get information from my experience as I have received tons of help reading through similar threads.

Thanks!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.5%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.4%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 10 10.9%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.4%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.2%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 10.9%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 24 26.1%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.6%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new