Throwing coral away....say it isn't so!

Have you ever had to throw away coral clippings? Read the thread for more.

  • Yes

    Votes: 339 67.8%
  • No

    Votes: 161 32.2%

  • Total voters
    500
I'm not a fan of selling stuff cheap or giving it away for free and then watch that person you gave it to turn around and resell it for a profit. I believe it is insulting. I see my husband go through this stuff with car parts. He gives stuff away on his off-roading forum or on craigslist because the hobby can be expensive and if he doesn't need it, he figures some other rock crawler should have it. Then he sees it immediately for sale online. He feels disappointed. However, if it is the choice between having a person resell it or you throw it away, I'd prefer the resell it method -- as shameful as it is. Because eventually, someone would use it vs. it rotting in the garbage.
 
These throw out stories really make me sad. Last month again I brought a box of pom pom xenia and kenya trees to a fish store (7hrs from home btw) they were very happy to give me $270 credit for them. I invested a couple of bucks in plugs and dollar store glue and I guess a couple dozen bags. Got a bunch of supplies, a yellow tang for a friend which these days cost a lot more but since it was basically free didn't care, and a rabbit fish for my frag tank.

When I got rid of all these frags I took my eggcrate out to clean and probably made another 15 or 20 frags from whatever had just grown off plugs onto the racks.

Wow 7 hours. The chances of me making that kind of trip in the next several years is slim to nil. I can’t even manage the 2 hour trip to the nearest lfs. Truthfully when I throw away coral, it’s not stuff I’m “bored with” or frags that just sit on the rack for too long. It’s one of two scenarios

1). It’s an “invasive” level montipora of sorts that starts to get uncomfortably too far past my imaginary border I’ve set. It is either beginning to encrust over or kill a more desirable piece. Or the plates stretch too far and start shading more desirable pieces. Those are normally cut intentionally and dried out if nobody local wants them (they never do). If someone wanted to PM me I would be happy to make them up a pack of various montipora I throw away if you pay full shipping and packaging costs (usually will be around $50 for label and box shipped anywhere to the lower 48, sometimes less depending on how close)

2) an emergency. An acro will get large and heavy enough it will snap at the base and fall face down onto the rocks and sand. It’s too heavy to glue back down and I don’t have room to cram a colony somewhere else without affecting other things, so if it’s not a highly valuable piece, I will normally cut a few large chunky frags quickly and just dry out the rest of it. I can’t let a colony just sit there stinging everything else it touches, which will eventually lead to the whole thing dying anyway, and likely taking others with it. It’s hard to get rid of a 12+” stag on literally a moments notice.
 
Last edited:
I'm not a fan of selling stuff cheap or giving it away for free and then watch that person you gave it to turn around and resell it for a profit. I believe it is insulting. I see my husband go through this stuff with car parts. He gives stuff away on his off-roading forum or on craigslist because the hobby can be expensive and if he doesn't need it, he figures some other rock crawler should have it. Then he sees it immediately for sale online. He feels disappointed. However, if it is the choice between having a person resell it or you throw it away, I'd prefer the resell it method -- as shameful as it is. Because eventually, someone would use it vs. it rotting in the garbage.

I’ve seen that happen to me. I’ve sold very large frag packs and given good deals on them based on volume, and then 2 weeks later I see half my frags posted by the same buyer, but HEAVILY photoshopped and at a 3-4x price point what I charged. It’s irritating. I suppose all is fair in a free market, but still. Kinda irks me
 
I've had a bit of a clear out of my softies in my home tank lately, ended up posting most of it all over the UK for the cost of postage, packing and a heat pack. Was mostly some Star Polyps, Xenia and Zoas. Luckily could fit all in an envelope to keep costs super low. Would drive me mad putting them in the Bin, my LFS wont accept them at all, not even as donations
 
I have purple and green slimer available. $5 per pound, pick up only.

To the point now where I am pretty much removing all my no-name SPS, monti cap, and monti digi. A couple LFS nearby take my stuff on consignment/store credit which is fine. Probably sell enough to cover my salt and two-part bill.

It is funny, they are happier taking in decent cuts of soft stuff. It moves and sells faster.
 
weird I didn’t see why u don’t throw it in bucket they sell skeleton peace s to put in calcium reactors an u are just throwing it it in the trash
 
My social connections are restricted such that I know nobody who wants them ha I need a Facebook.
I brought my lfs a wad of rare freshwater moss they'd never seen since day of open. They have myriad planted tanks with moss...shrimps etc. moss came from aquashella Dallas shrimp area from a man from France who told me it was rare for him. No joke, a wad I'd produced of it. They said na not interested lol they wouldn't even take free red monti I'm sure of it. How value ranges person to person = fascinating.

One year ago someone could have sold me the grip of moss for a hundred dollars. I paid fifteen for a postage stamp portion at aquashella he was a legit guy fun to visit with I didn't get name of his company. At work I'll get some out of tank and post pic someone can id
 
Last edited:
I really don't care if people turn around to sell a coral for more than they paid. I sell frags cheap to get them out of my tank asap. It works. I sell them fast and most people buy 4 or 5 different frags because of the price. So I end up making a decent amount of money anyway... and faster than if I sold them at twice the price (which would still be cheap).
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.2%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new