I've been slowly getting my tank back to the state where I can keep acros, and I thought I had made it. However, over the past couple of days I've noticed one of them seems to be either bleaching or losing tissue on the tips of a few branches. Rather than simply waiting for it to die, I thought I'd ask for help and hopefully prove to myself that I can keep acros again.
First, because pictures are worth a thousand words and I'm already too verbose:
Here's the acro in question, shortly after I picked it up:
It's pale golden with red polyps, but it doesn't photograph terribly well. Also, because of its coloration, it's a little difficult to see tissue loss under the full lights.
Here it was on Monday:
I thought I saw some recession there, so last night I snapped a picture with lights off:
Without the lights, it was much easier to see what was going on, and definitely some recession on the tips.
I don't think there's anything in the tank that would be eating it - I do have a robust population of asterina stars, but I don't think they're of the coral-eating variety. I've seen them all over the place wherever there's algae, but I've never seen them on a live coral. None of my fish are known coral eaters, and most of the rest of the corals in the tank are looking fine.
I think the problem is chemistry, but I'm not 100% certain. Here are my current parameters:
PH: Currently averaging 7.95, with a daytime value of about 8.1 and a nighttime value of about 7.9.
Alk: Currently 10.35 dKH, and where I think the problem is. When I got the acro it was down around 8.5. Without dosing, that value was steadily falling, so I started a very mild dose of 3ml/day, later dropped to 2 ml/day when it kept rising. I discontinued dosing a few days ago after I crossed the 10 dKH threshold, but it's still been going up without dosing.
CA: Fluctuating between 415 and 430 ppm, I'm currently dosing about 25 ml/day.
MG: Currently holding steady at about 1350 with a dosage of about 5-10 ml/day.
I didn't have time to run a nitrate/phosphate test last night; last I checked they were about 1.4 ppm for Nitrate and 0.06 ppm for phosphate, but that was before I did a round of Chemiclean. I'll run one tonight.
Could the rising alkalinity be the cause of this, or some other cause?
First, because pictures are worth a thousand words and I'm already too verbose:
Here's the acro in question, shortly after I picked it up:
It's pale golden with red polyps, but it doesn't photograph terribly well. Also, because of its coloration, it's a little difficult to see tissue loss under the full lights.
Here it was on Monday:
I thought I saw some recession there, so last night I snapped a picture with lights off:
Without the lights, it was much easier to see what was going on, and definitely some recession on the tips.
I don't think there's anything in the tank that would be eating it - I do have a robust population of asterina stars, but I don't think they're of the coral-eating variety. I've seen them all over the place wherever there's algae, but I've never seen them on a live coral. None of my fish are known coral eaters, and most of the rest of the corals in the tank are looking fine.
I think the problem is chemistry, but I'm not 100% certain. Here are my current parameters:
PH: Currently averaging 7.95, with a daytime value of about 8.1 and a nighttime value of about 7.9.
Alk: Currently 10.35 dKH, and where I think the problem is. When I got the acro it was down around 8.5. Without dosing, that value was steadily falling, so I started a very mild dose of 3ml/day, later dropped to 2 ml/day when it kept rising. I discontinued dosing a few days ago after I crossed the 10 dKH threshold, but it's still been going up without dosing.
CA: Fluctuating between 415 and 430 ppm, I'm currently dosing about 25 ml/day.
MG: Currently holding steady at about 1350 with a dosage of about 5-10 ml/day.
I didn't have time to run a nitrate/phosphate test last night; last I checked they were about 1.4 ppm for Nitrate and 0.06 ppm for phosphate, but that was before I did a round of Chemiclean. I'll run one tonight.
Could the rising alkalinity be the cause of this, or some other cause?