Toadstool ticked Off - Help w Nitrate & Phosphate Ratio

SoggyCarbs

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
10
Reaction score
8
What state or country do you live in
Texas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Nitrate: 1.2
PO4: .19
Ca: 820
PH: 8.0
Alk: 10
SG: 1.025

Refugium w Chaeto on at night for 8 hrs.

Feeding mysis, brine shrimp, and bloodworms 2-3x day, frozen cubes.

My nitrates have bottomed out since adding the refugium though phosphates have fluctuated from .09-.19. I started feeding more.

Should I dose nitrates too?

Just added Phosguard today upon measuring 0.19 phosphate

This toadstool has been in my tank for two years. For the last four weeks it's been closed up and unhappy. I have changed the flow a few times.
Should I try moving it somewhere else? If so, how do I get it off the rock?
I'm worried it's dying though other corals seem OK.

Help! :)
1000011191.jpg
PXL_20250831_163733344.jpg
 
Maybe lessen the time the refugium lights are on and gradually increase time. Changes have to be slow. The coral is responding to a fast change.
 
Looks like something is collecting on it so I would blow it of. I have a large toadstool that has been in the tank for years. I've noticed that the bigger it gets the more often it sheds and the longer the sheds take to finish and it's always larger afterwards. The last shed took over a month and I thought for sure it was dying. I like to help my leathers along by blowing them off daily and make sure nothing collects on them.
I've since moved mine so they are getting blasted with flow to the point they are lifting. The one on the left has positioned itself vertical and has an MP40 blowing right on it. Mine love light and flow.
They also like N and P My last test was NO3 35 and PO4 0.6 . PO4 has been over 0.9 where my tester maxes out and coral have no complaints at all. I would try to raise nitrate and not do anything to reduce PO4. I had these corals in a tank for 6 years that ran nitrates 25+
and phosphate 0.5+ the entire time.

PXL_20250831_170305366.jpg
 
Looks like something is collecting on it so I would blow it of. I have a large toadstool that has been in the tank for years. I've noticed that the bigger it gets the more often it sheds and the longer the sheds take to finish and it's always larger afterwards. The last shed took over a month and I thought for sure it was dying. I like to help my leathers along by blowing them off daily and make sure nothing collects on them.
I've since moved mine so they are getting blasted with flow to the point they are lifting. The one on the left has positioned itself vertical and has an MP40 blowing right on it. Mine love light and flow.
They also like N and P My last test was NO3 35 and PO4 0.6 . PO4 has been over 0.9 where my tester maxes out and coral have no complaints at all. I would try to raise nitrate and not do anything to reduce PO4. I had these corals in a tank for 6 years that ran nitrates 25+
and phosphate 0.5+ the entire time.

PXL_20250831_170305366.jpg
THANK YOU! Gosh those look amazing 😍
 
Looks like something is collecting on it so I would blow it of. I have a large toadstool that has been in the tank for years. I've noticed that the bigger it gets the more often it sheds and the longer the sheds take to finish and it's always larger afterwards. The last shed took over a month and I thought for sure it was dying. I like to help my leathers along by blowing them off daily and make sure nothing collects on them.
I've since moved mine so they are getting blasted with flow to the point they are lifting. The one on the left has positioned itself vertical and has an MP40 blowing right on it. Mine love light and flow.
They also like N and P My last test was NO3 35 and PO4 0.6 . PO4 has been over 0.9 where my tester maxes out and coral have no complaints at all. I would try to raise nitrate and not do anything to reduce PO4. I had these corals in a tank for 6 years that ran nitrates 25+
and phosphate 0.5+ the entire time.

PXL_20250831_170305366.jpg
Another win for higher nutrient systems!
 
Looks like something is collecting on it so I would blow it of. I have a large toadstool that has been in the tank for years. I've noticed that the bigger it gets the more often it sheds and the longer the sheds take to finish and it's always larger afterwards. The last shed took over a month and I thought for sure it was dying. I like to help my leathers along by blowing them off daily and make sure nothing collects on them.
I've since moved mine so they are getting blasted with flow to the point they are lifting. The one on the left has positioned itself vertical and has an MP40 blowing right on it. Mine love light and flow.
They also like N and P My last test was NO3 35 and PO4 0.6 . PO4 has been over 0.9 where my tester maxes out and coral have no complaints at all. I would try to raise nitrate and not do anything to reduce PO4. I had these corals in a tank for 6 years that ran nitrates 25+
and phosphate 0.5+ the entire time.

PXL_20250831_170305366.jpg
^^^
 
Just adding a video of the one above getting flow. Its doing what it wants I suppose. It could lay down flat to reduce the flow. It's tearing at places but not fragging itself. I find it interesting.

PXL_20250831_170305366.jpg




That doesn't seem like too much flow to me. The leather in my tank is almost the size of a dinner plate with the trunk soda can size and I blast it alot more than that. It seems to like it.
 

IF YOU HAD TO OPERATE EVERYTHING ELSE MANUALLY, WHICH AUTOMATED SYSTEM WOULD YOU KEEP?

  • Auto top-off

    Votes: 60 57.7%
  • Automated dosing

    Votes: 6 5.8%
  • Mechanical filtration / roller filter

    Votes: 4 3.8%
  • Automated water testing

    Votes: 3 2.9%
  • Automatic feeding

    Votes: 1 1.0%
  • Lighting schedule

    Votes: 20 19.2%
  • Controller and remote monitoring

    Votes: 4 3.8%
  • Leak detection and emergency shutoff

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Automatic water changes

    Votes: 3 2.9%
  • None. I prefer to operate everything manually

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Something else (explain in the comments)

    Votes: 1 1.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new