Turned out to be a sensor issue, Roger is sending a new one out. Thanks everyone for the help! Here is some helpful info on other things to try/note if you are having similar trouble:
A red light means water is touching the safety sensor, the water level is too high. This could be for a lot of reasons, a siphon, water added or a rock or anything that raises water level) an angle to the sensor (cable should exit the top center). The safety sensor is the small nipple and is an emergency shut off, the main sensor that turns the pump on and off is the cone that is right in the middle of the sensor.
If you use a UV or have a growlight spectrum light near the sensor, these can cause interference and will also cause it to fill to the safety sensor causing a red too high light. A UV must be a considerable distance away with no wire/ballast contact, the ballast is emitting a magnetic field which affects the electronics on the controller. Growlights emit infrared, the optic sensor uses infrared and will be blinded by the infrared source, this also applies to any other optic sensors in the area.