What a great discussion. A couple of things came to mind while reading this. 1. I can't help but wonder if there is a level of "snobby-ness" in the hobby with regards to soft/hard coral. If it is easy (soft) then it is ugly. When I first entered the hobby I didn't get the wow factor when people were saying how cool various hard coral looked. Then over the years I got it, but it was an acquired taste. I always liked the movement of the soft corals. To the beginner I feel this is commonly the case. 2. I have this big 5 inch leather, that is mostly brown with a little bit of green, in my 20 that was a freebee and I was ready to get rid of. My daughter asks when I am going to move it to my 75 that I am building out. I said I wasn't because I thought it was ugly. She freeked and said she loved it. As you might guess . . . . I will be moving it. :-)