What size pvc for drain?

[AllFin-ished]

So I'm getting ready to go buy a holesaw to try and successfully cut my tank I have built into the wall and I'm thinking bean animal for drain my question is do I go with 1" or 1/4" bulkheads and pvc? The tank is 150 gallons and the drain will be on one end of the tank I was thinking 1 and 1/4 would probly be what I need any input helps

 

[William Robinson]

That is probably plenty but just incase, what flow rate are you planning on having? Also since you are drilling it, do yourself a favor and go ahead and drill for an emergency overflow drain so you can put a gate valve on safely. You need to plumb both with 1" PVC

 

[Mhart032]

Checkout the new eshopps prodigy overflow man this thing looks sweet. it comes with everything including the hole saw, i was pretty impressed with the specs.

PRODIGY L - ESHOPPS

FEATURES Worlds Slimmest Overflow box Adjustable Water Height Weir Recessed External Overflow Cover SPECIFICATIONS Item# Dimensions Internal: 12" x 5/8" x 6"External: 12" x 3" x 6" Flow Rate Up to 900 GPH Max GPH Up to...

www.eshopps.com

 

[Mr Fishface]

If it's just the one drain I would go with the larger size personally. If you had two drains, the smaller size would be fine but a bigger drain means more options in terms of flow. If you have a smaller single drain you limit the flow honestly. I'll also add I am not familiar with bean animal drains so maybe I am wrong here!

 

[William Robinson]

Checkout the new eshopps prodigy overflow man this thing looks sweet. it comes with everything including the hole saw, i was pretty impressed with the specs.

PRODIGY L - ESHOPPS

FEATURES Worlds Slimmest Overflow box Adjustable Water Height Weir Recessed External Overflow Cover SPECIFICATIONS Item# Dimensions Internal: 12" x 5/8" x 6"External: 12" x 3" x 6" Flow Rate Up to 900 GPH Max GPH Up to...

www.eshopps.com

What"s the difference between that and the Eclipse? I have the Eclipse on a couple peninsula tanks and it looks like camera magic on their webpage.

 

[AllFin-ished]

Bean animal has 2 drains and a emergency and I'm planning on the 3 holes on the bottom of the tank so maybe 1inc pvc is fine with the 2 drains?

 

[William Robinson]

Bean animal has 2 drains and a emergency and I'm planning on the 3 holes on the bottom of the tank so maybe 1inc pvc is fine with the 2 drains?

Generally I would say yes but again that depends on your flow rate. What pump are you using?

 

[AllFin-ished]

Have not bought pump yet as project will end if I smash my tank lol but 150g tank was looking for 1500gph I belive?

 

[William Robinson]

Have not bought pump yet as project will end if I smash my tank lol but 150g tank was looking for 1500gph I belive?

That is of course the upper end of the recommended but necessary if you plan on SPS style tank. You need to have two 1" primary drains and one 1" emergency. Even 1,200GPH doing down a single pipe gravity fed is going to be an issue.... You need 2.
Generally, the accepted flow rate, gravity fed through 1" PVC is 600GPH

 

[AllFin-ished]

So the bean animal having 2 drains and a emergency I should be fine at 1" then ? Or better to go with 1.25?

 

[AllFin-ished]

Two one inc drains would only be 1200gph then I would need to go with 1.25 to get the 1500+

 

[Ratherbeflyen]

I built my bean animal overflow with 1.5" drains running a 3000 gph return pump. With the head pressure and plumbing losses, it's no where near the rated 3000 gph. My gate valve on the full siphon line is more than half way closed. I can close 2 of the drains and the emergency drain easily handles the flow. If I did it again, I would used 1" drains because they take up less space and cost less.

 

[AllFin-ished]

Alright sounds like I'm buying one inc diamond bit and some bulkheads and going to cross my fingers on my 3 holes lol I've done all kinds of test to make sure it's not tempard but from what I understand u can never be 100% sure less u try and cut it I called local glass stores and that's the same awnser they have givin me so time to take the shot

 

[Pickwun]

Alright sounds like I'm buying one inc diamond bit and some bulkheads and going to cross my fingers on my 3 holes lol I've done all kinds of test to make sure it's not tempard but from what I understand u can never be 100% sure less u try and cut it I called local glass stores and that's the same awnser they have givin me so time to take the shot

You need a 1 3/4" hole saw for 1" bulkheads.

 

[mfinn]

Have not bought pump yet as project will end if I smash my tank lol but 150g tank was looking for 1500gph I belive?

1" is fine. I have a bean animal style overflow on my 240 and I use 1", and it handles all I need.
On a 150 gallon tank you really don't need anymore than 700-900 gph through the sump.

 

[AllFin-ished]

You need a 1 3/4" hole saw for 1" bulkheads.

Thanks lol I was noticing this well I'm at lowes I'm looking at it like no way 1inc holes going to be big enough

 

[AllFin-ished]

1" is fine. I have a bean animal style overflow on my 240 and I use 1", and it handles all I need.
On a 150 gallon tank you really don't need anymore than 700-900 gph through the sump.

Thanks

 

[Mhart032]

[/QUOTE]

What"s the difference between that and the Eclipse? I have the Eclipse on a couple peninsula tanks and it looks like camera magic on their webpage.

this is supposed to be tighter to the glass, but it does look very close to the same.

 

[C_mo97]

1 inch drains will just be noisier. That’s why it is suggested to do 1.5” when pushing that much flow...

 

[ca1ore]

Thanks lol I was noticing this well I'm at lowes I'm looking at it like no way 1inc holes going to be big enough

Make sure you buy a hole saw designed for glass/ceramic. Bimetal hole saws for wood/metal will work on an acrylic tank but will destroy a glass tank. If it were me, I would go 1 1/4" for the drains ….. you can always valve them back. Maybe even 1 1/2" for the emergency.