It is amusing to me how some things seem to take a sharp left turn at Albuquerque and end up somewhere completely opposite of intended.
My ONLY stand on this topic is that "I am against harvesting live rock from the ocean.". That is all.. nothing more, nothing less.
All of my tanks were started using established dry rock from a running system. I fully agree that by doing this approach, the cycling and setup of ALL of my tanks has been far easier than if I had simply opened up a box of dry rock, poured in salt water and hoped for the best.
First of all, the sale of ocean harvested live rock is illegal here in California, so that option is off the table for us no matter what we want or think.
I have a couple boxes of new dry rock that I could add a couple pieces to my tank at any time to seed them and gift them out to any newbie who wants or needs them. This is my personal approach to sustainability. This also allows anyone who asks, to take advantage of the "easy" way to set up a tank that you are promoting.
As I stated last night, I am in agreement with you that running a tank does not need to be difficult. A little bit of applied knowledge and a few drops of experience can make a reef tank almost effortless. It is the gaining of that knowledge and experience that is the challenging part for new aquarists.
I have over 35 years of experience with aquariums. Most of that time was with FW, but the knowledge and experience I gained from that, allowed me to seamlessly move into the reefing side of the hobby. Consider the newcomer who doesn't have that background. They watch the
BRS videos and believe that they need a tank full of the latest and greatest equipment, empty their bank accounts and max out their CCs to get it and have no idea why their tank is not running like this months "reef of the month".
Further, as has been stated in previous posts, the stock you intend directly influences how difficult your reef is to maintain. You have a beautiful tank full of softies. I applaud your success. Very well done! However, not everyone is going to be happy with the setup you run. As an example, I started my tank with the idea that I would go with something very similar to what you have. Simple softies, some fish and just watch it grow... As I got more involved with the hobby, my interests shifted and I wished to challenge myself, push my boundaries. I now have a tank with quite a few SPS as well as softies and fish. Personally, I do not find this any more or less difficult than it was before, but the addition of new pieces does change the dynamic of what I need to be aware of in order to sustain a healthy system.
So, MY tanks are all running on the mindset that "simple is easier and better" approach. I have no fancy hi-tech gear, no apex or whatever controllers, no UV this and gfo that.. I have simple canister filters, skimmers and not much else. The only indulgence I have allowed myself as far as equipment goes is my Kessil lights. Are they strictly "needed"? Possibly not, but since installing them in December, I have seen an explosion of growth that I have never experienced using bargain lights. I also am now able to keep SPS corals not only alive, but thriving.
To wrap up, I fully agree with you that live rock, or established dry rock from a running system, absolutely makes startup of a new tank easier and allows for more simplified integration of new livestock. On that point we are in full agreement. Does using live rock make reefing "easier"? Yes and no. It all depends on the individual hobbyist. Their personal level of experience and their specific goals for the system they intend to run.