- Joined
- Jan 19, 2010
- Messages
- 8,817
- Reaction score
- 15,162
- Location
- Utah
- What state or country do you live in
- Utah
Alright, nice click-bait title and you’re here!
I’m no longer convinced sumps make life any easier in this hobby for the majority of tanks. Especially softie or LPS systems. Sumps are usually stuffed under a cramped stand and are extremely annoying to work on or in. Sumps tend to load up with equipment that needs cleaning and maintenance to be efficient and effective. There is a lot of pointless equipment in the hobby these days cramping sumps.
Let’s look at a couple claims more in depth:
“You need a sump for a good skimmer.”
— This is mostly true. Small skimmers and HOB are easily out performed by larger in sump skimmers. The real question needs to be - is a skimmer required? Yes, they provide oxygen and remove stuff. What they remove is still debated let alone if what they remove is a benefit or a detriment.
“Carbon and GFO reactors”
— There are plenty of ways to run carbon, GFO, and other media without specialized reactors. In tank reactors are plentiful these days.
“Sumps hide equipment”
— Again, true but an AIO with good rear chambers will hide a heater, probes, return pump, even in tank UV sterilizers.
“Rear chambers are hard to clean”
— Be honest, 99% of us aren’t cleaning our sumps anyway. How many people really need to clean rear chambers in an AIO? A wet dry vac does wonders if needed. You can easily run floss in an AIO if one wants mechanical filtration.
There are some serious pros to AIO systems no matter the size. They are far simpler to run for most, they can be dead silent, and they can be much cheaper to setup. I’m not sure we’ve seen enough large AIOs to say they are “worse” than sump systems. The few threads I’ve found of those going with large AIOs seem to love them. Even those that swapped their large sump system to an AIO
I would love to see someone take a stab at a large AIO and keep tabs on it.
maybe the frog tank needs to be converted 
I’m no longer convinced sumps make life any easier in this hobby for the majority of tanks. Especially softie or LPS systems. Sumps are usually stuffed under a cramped stand and are extremely annoying to work on or in. Sumps tend to load up with equipment that needs cleaning and maintenance to be efficient and effective. There is a lot of pointless equipment in the hobby these days cramping sumps.
Let’s look at a couple claims more in depth:
“You need a sump for a good skimmer.”
— This is mostly true. Small skimmers and HOB are easily out performed by larger in sump skimmers. The real question needs to be - is a skimmer required? Yes, they provide oxygen and remove stuff. What they remove is still debated let alone if what they remove is a benefit or a detriment.
“Carbon and GFO reactors”
— There are plenty of ways to run carbon, GFO, and other media without specialized reactors. In tank reactors are plentiful these days.
“Sumps hide equipment”
— Again, true but an AIO with good rear chambers will hide a heater, probes, return pump, even in tank UV sterilizers.
“Rear chambers are hard to clean”
— Be honest, 99% of us aren’t cleaning our sumps anyway. How many people really need to clean rear chambers in an AIO? A wet dry vac does wonders if needed. You can easily run floss in an AIO if one wants mechanical filtration.
There are some serious pros to AIO systems no matter the size. They are far simpler to run for most, they can be dead silent, and they can be much cheaper to setup. I’m not sure we’ve seen enough large AIOs to say they are “worse” than sump systems. The few threads I’ve found of those going with large AIOs seem to love them. Even those that swapped their large sump system to an AIO
I would love to see someone take a stab at a large AIO and keep tabs on it.
maybe the frog tank needs to be converted 
