Your sump isn’t that cool!

  • Thread starter Thread starter rtparty
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

rtparty

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 19, 2010
Messages
8,817
Reaction score
15,162
Location
Utah
What state or country do you live in
Utah
Rating - 100%
4   0   0
Alright, nice click-bait title and you’re here!

I’m no longer convinced sumps make life any easier in this hobby for the majority of tanks. Especially softie or LPS systems. Sumps are usually stuffed under a cramped stand and are extremely annoying to work on or in. Sumps tend to load up with equipment that needs cleaning and maintenance to be efficient and effective. There is a lot of pointless equipment in the hobby these days cramping sumps.

Let’s look at a couple claims more in depth:

“You need a sump for a good skimmer.”
— This is mostly true. Small skimmers and HOB are easily out performed by larger in sump skimmers. The real question needs to be - is a skimmer required? Yes, they provide oxygen and remove stuff. What they remove is still debated let alone if what they remove is a benefit or a detriment.

“Carbon and GFO reactors”
— There are plenty of ways to run carbon, GFO, and other media without specialized reactors. In tank reactors are plentiful these days.

“Sumps hide equipment”
— Again, true but an AIO with good rear chambers will hide a heater, probes, return pump, even in tank UV sterilizers.

“Rear chambers are hard to clean”
— Be honest, 99% of us aren’t cleaning our sumps anyway. How many people really need to clean rear chambers in an AIO? A wet dry vac does wonders if needed. You can easily run floss in an AIO if one wants mechanical filtration.


There are some serious pros to AIO systems no matter the size. They are far simpler to run for most, they can be dead silent, and they can be much cheaper to setup. I’m not sure we’ve seen enough large AIOs to say they are “worse” than sump systems. The few threads I’ve found of those going with large AIOs seem to love them. Even those that swapped their large sump system to an AIO

I would love to see someone take a stab at a large AIO and keep tabs on it. 🤔 maybe the frog tank needs to be converted 😂
 
This should be an interesting thread!

But this is pretty dang cool! HAHA!

@Broadfield
1771267703999.png
 
Now, my hexagon is definitely an edge case here, but it was designed from the ground up to run a sump!

six viewing panes, no exposed wiring or equipment, island overflow, designed to sit in the center of a room… (there’s even a dedicated 3/4” bulkhead and associated dry conduit for lighting wires to pass through the tank’s overflow box without being seen…)

These (or similar) design constraints necessitated a place to put all the ugly equipment out of sight, and out of mind!
 
4’x8’ peninsular all in one would be sweet. I’ve seen them in some coral growout videos and I think the zeovit headquarters and reef builders studio used to have some coral growouts setup like this.
 
Guess it depends how much stuff you want to run.

If you are one of those who want a big skimmer and a GFO reactor and a calcium reactor and a UV sterilizer and a filter roller and a refugium or an algae scrubber.... a sump just gives you so many more options.

Arguments can and have been made that not all of these things are needed, and if so an AIO is much more appealing.

Just depends what all you want to do with it.
 
Nope. A sump is the way to go once you get towards higher scale volume. I would do it pure pure aesthetics alone: a sump is a great place to hide equipment and it also increases water volume which helps with stability.
 
Alright, nice click-bait title and you’re here!

I’m no longer convinced sumps make life any easier in this hobby for the majority of tanks. Especially softie or LPS systems. Sumps are usually stuffed under a cramped stand and are extremely annoying to work on or in. Sumps tend to load up with equipment that needs cleaning and maintenance to be efficient and effective. There is a lot of pointless equipment in the hobby these days cramping sumps.

Let’s look at a couple claims more in depth:

“You need a sump for a good skimmer.”
— This is mostly true. Small skimmers and HOB are easily out performed by larger in sump skimmers. The real question needs to be - is a skimmer required? Yes, they provide oxygen and remove stuff. What they remove is still debated let alone if what they remove is a benefit or a detriment.

“Carbon and GFO reactors”
— There are plenty of ways to run carbon, GFO, and other media without specialized reactors. In tank reactors are plentiful these days.

“Sumps hide equipment”
— Again, true but an AIO with good rear chambers will hide a heater, probes, return pump, even in tank UV sterilizers.

“Rear chambers are hard to clean”
— Be honest, 99% of us aren’t cleaning our sumps anyway. How many people really need to clean rear chambers in an AIO? A wet dry vac does wonders if needed. You can easily run floss in an AIO if one wants mechanical filtration.


There are some serious pros to AIO systems no matter the size. They are far simpler to run for most, they can be dead silent, and they can be much cheaper to setup. I’m not sure we’ve seen enough large AIOs to say they are “worse” than sump systems. The few threads I’ve found of those going with large AIOs seem to love them. Even those that swapped their large sump system to an AIO

I would love to see someone take a stab at a large AIO and keep tabs on it. 🤔 maybe the frog tank needs to be converted 😂
hahah yeah ive had 3 AIO tanks, and over the last 3 or 4 years ive maybe cleaned the chambers like 2 time LOL. sponges like to inhabit the chambers because theyre low light and i feel bad wiping out that whole environment because those chambers are like their own ecosystem. as long as you arent havnt any high nutrient problems or flow problems just dont clean them imo hahah
 
Alright, nice click-bait title and you’re here!

I’m no longer convinced sumps make life any easier in this hobby for the majority of tanks. Especially softie or LPS systems. Sumps are usually stuffed under a cramped stand and are extremely annoying to work on or in. Sumps tend to load up with equipment that needs cleaning and maintenance to be efficient and effective. There is a lot of pointless equipment in the hobby these days cramping sumps.

Let’s look at a couple claims more in depth:

“You need a sump for a good skimmer.”
— This is mostly true. Small skimmers and HOB are easily out performed by larger in sump skimmers. The real question needs to be - is a skimmer required? Yes, they provide oxygen and remove stuff. What they remove is still debated let alone if what they remove is a benefit or a detriment.

“Carbon and GFO reactors”
— There are plenty of ways to run carbon, GFO, and other media without specialized reactors. In tank reactors are plentiful these days.

“Sumps hide equipment”
— Again, true but an AIO with good rear chambers will hide a heater, probes, return pump, even in tank UV sterilizers.

“Rear chambers are hard to clean”
— Be honest, 99% of us aren’t cleaning our sumps anyway. How many people really need to clean rear chambers in an AIO? A wet dry vac does wonders if needed. You can easily run floss in an AIO if one wants mechanical filtration.


There are some serious pros to AIO systems no matter the size. They are far simpler to run for most, they can be dead silent, and they can be much cheaper to setup. I’m not sure we’ve seen enough large AIOs to say they are “worse” than sump systems. The few threads I’ve found of those going with large AIOs seem to love them. Even those that swapped their large sump system to an AIO

I would love to see someone take a stab at a large AIO and keep tabs on it. 🤔 maybe the frog tank needs to be converted 😂

I will debate this.

1). Sumps hide equipment, which you did state is true, but with the equipment and size tank I am running there isn't an AIO option. I have a 40w pentair UV, and a rain8 ATS for my waterbox 230.6.

2). I think for small to medium size tanks AIO's are probably great.

Granted my view is based on my equipment choices obviously.
 
Nope. A sump is the way to go once you get towards higher scale volume. I would do it pure pure aesthetics alone: a sump is a great place to hide equipment and it also increases water volume which helps with stability.

Is there really a substantial difference between 250g of water compared to 290g of water for stability?

Imagine you’re only running a heater, maybe a bag of carbon and some pumps for flow. What does the sump hide that isn’t easily hidden in an AIO?
 
Is there really a substantial difference between 250g of water compared to 290g of water for stability?
Yes, a 16% difference, in fact!

And, this would be a sump barely 33% of tank size, running at 50% full!
 
I like the clean look of a rimless tank with just a light overhead, with everything hidden below. Even with an All in One, there is still some kinds of equipment that stick out.
 
Is there really a substantial difference between 250g of water compared to 290g of water for stability?

Imagine you’re only running a heater, maybe a bag of carbon and some pumps for flow. What does the sump hide that isn’t easily hidden in an AIO?
I don’t have a tank that large but my RedSea 525 is a 112g display paired with a 31g sump. That increases water volume by 27.6% which is indeed significant. More importantly, the sump is large enough to fit in the largest model of Reefmat and a sizable skimmer. None of those could fit in an HOB chamber. Some people also use the sump to store more frags so it can be used as more free real estate.

Assuming you have a display tank sitting on some sort of stand, there is always going to a large amount of real estate below the tank. A sump is a great was to use that space.
 
Of course you post this when I'm in the process of looking for a tank to replace my Reefer 300. Now I have to do some more research lol. The only thing in the 300 sump is a reefmat and skimmer and heater but the skimmer is only for aeration and never cleaned or emptied. I wonder if there are any nice 4ft AIO tanks 🤔

PS an AIO with the back section taller than the display to help hide equipment would be pretty sweet
 
Yes, a 16% difference, in fact!

And, this would be a sump barely 33% of tank size, running at 50% full!

But a noticeable difference in water stability? Very unlikely.

I’ve seen no difference trying to keep 50g or 250g stable
 
I recently upgraded from a FC 38 AIO to which I eventually added an overflow and sump. Now I went with a NYOS 440 120 volume system. I also wanted a pair of Mandarins and eventually a butterfly and multi bar.

1. I wanted a system that was as natural and low maintenance as possible AND maintain the above fish happily. That required a refugium IMO the only option... I could add a refugium in the AIO chamber. Did so without the 38 and it was a PITA and too small.
2. I don’t run a skimmer or mechanical filtration. Only macro for export. Some chemipure but very little.
3. I do minimal water changes and basic supplements keeping hardy corals and nems. I guess I’m somewhere between a FOWLR and reef.
4. Since I got the new tank with OEM sump everything looks better and so easy. Just add supplements! Few wires showing. I don’t clean the sump. I welcome detritus. With the AIO I was constantly scrubbing the baffles to make sure water was flowing. With the fuge pieces would get trapped all the time. Drove me nuts.

Now I have rubble, removable DSB, ATO and macro growing where I can access everything comfortably.

I honestly cannot imagine a situation where an AIO is better. Bigger footprint with less display area and everything squeezed into tiny chambers. Not for me!
 
Of course you post this when I'm in the process of looking for a tank to replace my Reefer 300. Now I have to do some more research lol. The only thing in the 300 sump is a reefmat and skimmer and heater but the skimmer is only for aeration and never cleaned or emptied. I wonder if there are any nice 4ft AIO tanks 🤔

I’m usually good for throwing a stick between the spokes 😂

Innovative Marine has the SR80 and 120 AIO setups but I don’t like the AIO on the back wall taking up so much depth.

My ideal AIO is a peninsula turned sideways. I have two tanks in mind currently for this idea. My old 250 (72*36*22) or have a new eurobraced 72*24*24 built by @Joe Glass Cages with a divider wall on one side that will become the AIO chambers

From a simplicity stand point, the AIO is much simpler. Of course it has limits, limits that no longer bother me after 21 years of doing this
 
Honestly I may make my next large volume tank an AIO.
I think it depends on your goal :) and how you approach things.
I LOVE the simplicity of my 15 gallon AIO. Three chambers, running Filter floss, a heater, and return pump. If I need to add some carbon etc easily done, even a small UV will fit. All I run are some small cables to the cabinet as well as the ATO tube.
I admit getting to that level of stability took a while, I used to stuff Biomedia etc in the back.
My 50 gallon with sump is almost too complex sometimes... trying to get everything tuned in properly... the AIO I can set it and go.
Cost alone is something to think about too... now that it's on my mind, looking at WB it's like a grand for a 65 gallon AIO.

*I have tiny arms
 
But a noticeable difference in water stability? Very unlikely.

I’ve seen no difference trying to keep 50g or 250g stable
Stable in what sense?

For example, temperature stability is vastly different between the two volumes, as is PH buffering capacity, resilience to salinity swings, etc…

A larger volume of water inherently takes more input (or output) to appreciably change in chemistry!
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 17 29.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 3.4%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 22 37.9%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 17 29.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new