668 DAYS - NO WATER CHANGES ..and going strong !

Very interesting thread and educational. I am intrigued!

I have a question, maybe two. At what bio-load and tank maturity (maybe period or some other thumb rule) this no water change equillibrium can be achieved?

please chime in...
When I started the tank about 2 yrs ago that was the 1st time and last water was added to the tank ( with the exception of top off of course)
I have about 12 fish in the tank , last I did a head count lol , I do feed heavily every day, dose phyto daily and pods once a month .
Filtration is filter floss in filters cups , replaced weekly...if I remember. Skimmer runs at night..and cheato in the refugium.
 
Here is a pretty darn good video for those that question the no WC routine (or there lack of lol ) this is The Reef Moonshiners method I follow

 
Why are you only running the skimmer at night?
You know good question lol ...I think when I first started that is what I was told and just stuck with it .... there was a time I ran it 24 hrs and it seemed to pull too much nutrients out...I run a high nutrient tank (20-50 no3) gonies and softies prefer it higher and do better .im actually dosing nitrate at the moment to keep that number in that vicinity..I had a previous tank I ran the skimmer 24/7 and ended up bottoming out nutrients and ended up with dreaded dinos and I guess I don't want to go down that road again.!
 
@cheykaser, you have some gorgeous corals and the no water change and the Moonshiners system seems to be working beautifully for you. I’ve been in the hobby for 30+ years and have never had such an easy time with my tank as I have over the past “almost” 3 years of using the Shine method. There is expense but man is it worth it. I have only done 2 small water changes since being on the shine. I enjoy the daily dosing, the ICP analysis, the incredible growth and health of the fish and corals and I especially enjoy not doing water changes!!! It’s not for everybody and their are different ways to run a reef but for me, Moonshiners has brought new joy to my reef tank experience.
IMG_1872.jpeg
IMG_1874.jpeg
IMG_1877.jpeg
IMG_1869.jpeg
IMG_1868.jpeg
 
@cheykaser, you have some gorgeous corals and the no water change and the Moonshiners system seems to be working beautifully for you. I’ve been in the hobby for 30+ years and have never had such an easy time with my tank as I have over the past “almost” 3 years of using the Shine method. There is expense but man is it worth it. I have only done 2 small water changes since being on the shine. I enjoy the daily dosing, the ICP analysis, the incredible growth and health of the fish and corals and I especially enjoy not doing water changes!!! It’s not for everybody and their are different ways to run a reef but for me, Moonshiners has brought new joy to my reef tank experience.
IMG_1872.jpeg
IMG_1874.jpeg
IMG_1877.jpeg
IMG_1869.jpeg
IMG_1868.jpeg
Thank you and you as well !!!! I am just now starting to dabble in SPS...since they are actually staying alive and actually growing and I contribute thay solely on moonshiners !!! Hopefully they will grow as big and wonderful as yours!!! I really enjoy the testing and dosing too. Makes me more in tube fo what's going on with the tank and to me it's like a science project every month lol I get excited see the month to month results
 
É uma sensação incrível, não é?
Many people here in Brazil ask me about this and say that I will have problems, let's see how old it will be until something happens, if it will happen😁
 
Many people here in Brazil ask me about this and say that I will have problems, let's see how old it will be until something happens, if it will happen😁
I get that all the time as well..."its all well and good .....until it's not" ...I feel if when/if it happens it's our own fault...we get lazy...we loose diligence...we get busy and life happens...we get comfortable and let things slide..put off basically tests ect ...for me self discipline is key
 
I'll admit I'm not an additives expert, but doing water changes replaces trace elements. Yeah, maybe not 100% at a time, but slowly. They're not consumed 100% at a time so replacing them gradually should work fine; always has for me.

Again, everyone is free to do things how they want. I have an Apex and DOS and do daily water changes. Have to mix up some saltwater in the basement every 10d or so and that's it (and I can service multiple tanks at a time from that). No measuring additives or buying additives. When I did consider the additives route they were quite expensive compared to salt, but prices on everything has gone up since then so who knows. I would think buying salt is cheaper than additives, but I don't know that for a fact. I do know it's definitely easier and gets the job done. It also helps remove things like nitrates and phosphates which depending on your bioload doing no water changes might not be an option. Certainly for a coral only or coral dominant tank it can be a great idea.

It's the standard way of doing things for a reason; it works. Doesn't mean it's the only way, probably just the best way. There are certainly situations where doing no water changes will work just fine, even great. But I would surmise that's a minority of aquariums. But I thank the OP for bringing us this interesting case study.

I don’t agree, and I think your conclusion is not justified by your experience. You say it works, but a great reef tank doing water changes does not show the water changes usefully supplement trace elements. You are ignoring foods, which may be what “works” in your case. :)


Some elements deplete fast enough that unless you change large amounts daily, the tank cannot hope to keep close to the new salt water. Mathematically it just does not work.
 
I don’t agree, and I think your conclusion is not justified by your experience. You say it works, but a great reef tank doing water changes does not show the water changes usefully supplement trace elements. You are ignoring foods, which may be what “works” in your case. :)


Some elements deplete fast enough that unless you change large amounts daily, the tank cannot hope to keep close to the new salt water. Mathematically it just does not work.
OK. Weird that it works for so many people.
 
OK. Weird that it works for so many people.

Is there a single reefer anywhere who does water changes but never feeds the tank? No. So no reefer anywhere can rightfully claim based on their tank results that water changes are what “works”. Together, all the things you and others do “works”.

Don’t get me wrong, I like water changes and have changed 1% daily for years. But I also do not think they are adequately supplying rapidly depleting trace elements such as iron, manganese, and perhaps iodine.
 
So not sustainable? I suppose that requires context. My reef has existed for over 2 decades. Will it come crashing down due to lack of water changes? Maybe! But its lifespan has exceeded the tenure of most people’s participation in this hobby, @PaulB excluded.
hello bean. 😎 i actually feel that too many water changes is detrimental.

if new water was so great, why do new tanks all look lousy and have all the disease problems?

i think we should change some water, but not too much as water gets better as it ages, up to a point.
(guido huckstead)

i change some water about 4 times a year. i dont know if thats good or bad but i still probably have some water in my tank from the east river next to manhattan from 1971 😬
 
When i started this hobby in 2014 (thanks to my hubby for getting us into the hobby) I was always preached to by LFS, water change water change water change...well thats not always the case...im going on nearly 2 years now with my Waterbox 155.5 Infinia frag with not a single water change !!! With the diligence of keeping parameters in check ... and in all honestly im reall not that strickt in myself....monthly (or every other month or so) ICP tests and the discipline i have found for myself in Reef Moonshiner's this has been an amazing journey....tank is thriving...I am keeping almost every type of coral...SPS...LPS...softies, gargonians....everything from leathers, acropora, zoas to gonis .
This tank is run on the basics of equipment... filter floss filtration ( pillow stuffing from Walmart) , cheato and miracle mud in the refugium, skimmer and uv , running at night.
Auto dosing calcium, alkalinity, iron and manganese.

20250913_101430~2.jpg 20250911_121913~3.jpg 20250810_120511~2.jpg 20250405_112229~2.jpg 20250812_185540~2.jpg
how do you keep your nitrate under controle it drives me nuts my nitrate levels
 
how do you keep your nitrate under controle it drives me nuts my nitrate levels
I use zeolite in a sock cup-- I have two of them in the sump. I also have around 10 PolypLab Genesis rock in the sump.

Never had issues with high nitrates since. I also need to dose nitrates at this point and sometimes ammonia. I guess I needed a lot more nitrifying bacteria in the tank somehow and live rocks aren't enough. All I know is that the moment I remove zeolite or a genesis rock, my nitrates will go up.

For Phosphate, GFO in a reactor works along with half-dosing LC (around 2.5ml) as needed. Keeps my PO4 under .2
 
I use zeolite in a sock cup-- I have two of them in the sump. I also have around 10 PolypLab Genesis rock in the sump.

Never had issues with high nitrates since. I also need to dose nitrates at this point and sometimes ammonia. I guess I needed a lot more nitrifying bacteria in the tank somehow and live rocks aren't enough. All I know is that the moment I remove zeolite or a genesis rock, my nitrates will go up.

For Phosphate, GFO in a reactor works along with half-dosing LC (around 2.5ml) as needed. Keeps my PO4 under .2

i use gfo in a reactor too. let me ask, how do you run yours? i run it 45 min a day and it keeps mine steady around 0.5. how about you? i heard some people run it 24/7 but with a small gph.
 
i use gfo in a reactor too. let me ask, how do you run yours? i run it 45 min a day and it keeps mine steady around 0.5. how about you? i heard some people run it 24/7 but with a small gph.
I run as needed. I run it all day 24/7 until I reach my target range and then run it for 4-6 hours depending on feeding after.

If .5 is your target, then just leave it as it is. But if you want to go lower, I use Lanthanum Chloride at half dose through a sock to reduce it further at a daily basis until gfo can handle the phosphates on its own.
 
i use gfo in a reactor too. let me ask, how do you run yours? i run it 45 min a day and it keeps mine steady around 0.5. how about you? i heard some people run it 24/7 but with a small gph.
That's pretty high. Do you mean 0.05?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 23 24.0%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 8 8.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 39 40.6%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.1%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 24 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new