Bad Water Change Causing Corals To Die

Here in a sec I'll post a Pic that hurts my stomach to admit lol I've neglected my tank by stress applied to a big move coming up, and a column spongoides monti, aged, formerly pristine and electric green, is now half rtn. It looks like a half beaten down chevy with broken windows and a rotting roof out in a bar ditch.

I've simply starved the whole thing a bit by putting off water changes and feeding, it's under attention stress as other life areas get the focus

Just like the adage said: mostly dead isn't dead :)


a third is still alive
And by the time it's a quarter I'll be moved.

and I'll mount the new light a bit higher for ten pct reduction

i will run three hundred dollars of roti pods and benepets powder and cyclopeeze through the system if I can find some, paired with busy water changes, until summer. I will then use the results pics for a dust up with someone regarding their use of cipro for the same matter we just fixed by tank exercise. Pills vs diet and exercise: the duel continues.

But my coral looks way worse, i wish it was as healthy as those above no joke. Mine are super old and have been through this twenty times/ confident for sure. Even my brain coral which I've had since 08 is 45% recessed, in 2012 it was 90% recessed and I bought it back to what it was last year.


We leave these tanks sitting sedentary. Most but not all reefs have periods of decline associated with a steady state that just wasn't ideal. These broad moves of + feed, + export so waste won't compound, - light power + 8 weeks is reef tank cpr. I will use it to bring my insulted reef back. You could apply this formula above to a great running reef and it would only boost coral growth during + phases



When we exercise them, they respond no joke but it's way way delayed
Must sustain all actions two months min to see edges and curls of new coral growth. * i won't frag my Monti, it'll just overgrow the stn part since it isn't some tank disease causing this.

The system is simply protein starved with no matching light reduction following: so some peeled off
Gimme till summer for updates. Plus i had to put it on petsmart water lol since I've been in Austin. Clearly she may not like that! Lubbock= has shop that sells tropic marin pre made. This time next year it'll be totally fixed.
 
Last edited:
Another impact i was causing was waiting too long to top back up. Salinity shocks are flat out skin-peeling things to do. I regret being this harsh but it'll pull for sure.

20250219_214948.jpg
 
Last edited:
Were the torches aquacultured? I’ve hear many people claim wild torches are very finicky and seem to die for no apparent reason. Same thing happened to me with a wild torch just last week. Hope this puts your mind at ease
 
Well said. Nice clue catch.
 
Here in a sec I'll post a Pic that hurts my stomach to admit lol I've neglected my tank by stress applied to a big move coming up, and a column spongoides monti, aged, formerly pristine and electric green, is now half rtn. It looks like a half beaten down chevy with broken windows and a rotting roof out in a bar ditch.

I've simply starved the whole thing a bit by putting off water changes and feeding, it's under attention stress as other life areas get the focus

Just like the adage said: mostly dead isn't dead :)


a third is still alive
And by the time it's a quarter I'll be moved.

and I'll mount the new light a bit higher for ten pct reduction

i will run three hundred dollars of roti pods and benepets powder and cyclopeeze through the system if I can find some, paired with busy water changes, until summer. I will then use the results pics for a dust up with someone regarding their use of cipro for the same matter we just fixed by tank exercise. Pills vs diet and exercise: the duel continues.

But my coral looks way worse, i wish it was as healthy as those above no joke. Mine are super old and have been through this twenty times/ confident for sure. Even my brain coral which I've had since 08 is 45% recessed, in 2012 it was 90% recessed and I bought it back to what it was last year.


We leave these tanks sitting sedentary. Most but not all reefs have periods of decline associated with a steady state that just wasn't ideal. These broad moves of + feed, + export so waste won't compound, - light power + 8 weeks is reef tank cpr. I will use it to bring my insulted reef back. You could apply this formula above to a great running reef and it would only boost coral growth during + phases



When we exercise them, they respond no joke but it's way way delayed
Must sustain all actions two months min to see edges and curls of new coral growth. * i won't frag my Monti, it'll just overgrow the stn part since it isn't some tank disease causing this.

The system is simply protein starved with no matching light reduction following: so some peeled off
Gimme till summer for updates. Plus i had to put it on petsmart water lol since I've been in Austin. Clearly she may not like that! Lubbock= has shop that sells tropic marin pre made. This time next year it'll be totally fixed.
Seems like I just gotta keep on going and roll with the punches.
 
Were the torches aquacultured? I’ve hear many people claim wild torches are very finicky and seem to die for no apparent reason. Same thing happened to me with a wild torch just last week. Hope this puts your mind at ease
I think 1 was wild, but the other 2 were aquacultured.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHICH SUPPOSEDLY EASY CORAL HAS GIVEN YOU THE MOST TROUBLE?

  • Zoanthids or palythoas

    Votes: 19 19.6%
  • Mushrooms or Ricordea

    Votes: 20 20.6%
  • Green star polyps

    Votes: 12 12.4%
  • Xenia

    Votes: 10 10.3%
  • Leather corals

    Votes: 9 9.3%
  • Duncan or candy cane corals

    Votes: 22 22.7%
  • Birdsnest or Montipora digitata

    Votes: 26 26.8%
  • None—mine have lived up to the reputation

    Votes: 5 5.2%
  • Other (tell us which one)

    Votes: 3 3.1%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new