Barely keeping up w/ Alk in New Tank

MySoCalReef

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 19, 2024
Messages
44
Reaction score
16
Location
Temecula, California
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Like the title says, I can barely keep up with the falling Alkalinity in my tank. The tank will be 5 weeks old tomorrow. The alkalinity dropped all the way to 5.6dKH during the cycle.

I have a ~120 gallon tank w/ ~30 sump. I am adding about 50ml of AquaVitro Eight.Four every day just to maintain alkalinity. It tests about 8.2dKH in the morning. I add 50ml of eight.four which raises it to about 9.2dKH. By the next day, it drops back to 8.2dKH. I'm testing Alkalinity, Nitrates, and Phosphates using Hanna Colorimeters. There isn't anything in the tank except 3 fish, a tuxedo urchin, 10 snails, and copepods. I add about a tsp of phyto everyday. I have diatoms, but they're dying off (my reefmat is full of it) and they are being replaced by neon green diatoms.

Salinity - 35ppt
Alkalinity - 8.2dKH
pH - 8.1
Ammonia - 0ppm
Nitrites - 0ppm
Nitrates - 0ppm
Phosphates 0.07ppm

Possibly related, or maybe it warrants a separate post, but my nitrates are a bit crazy. Throughout the cycle they went up to about 15ppm. My LFS suggested Red Sea NoPox to lower my phosphates (from 0.25ppm). I added 15 ml (the recommended dosage) NoPox on 1/16/25, and 5 ml on 1/17/25 (and no more since then). My tank got cloudy and on 1/18/25 my nitrates went to zero. They gradually recovered and peaked at 5.1ppm on 1/22/25. On 1/24/25 they tested 0.1ppm and tested 0.0ppm today.

Are these issues related? What should I do, if anything?

P.S. I just posted my tank, so that posting should be approved soon, if it hasn't been already. There are photos there. Thank you guys in advance for the help.
 
First, a little upset with your LFS for having you use NoPox in a brand new tank. Sounds like this led to an imbalance.

Second diatoms and dinos can lower alkalinity but that’s typically when you have tons of them. Definitely an interesting phenomenon. Bacterial blooms can also cause alkalinity drops.

I might consider not dosing at all and just doing small water changes to get everything to settle. You shouldn’t need to dose in a tank this young if you don’t have coral.
 
15 is not necessarily bad for nitrates. 0 is bad.

If you tank is growing coraline algea this would be at least some consumption of alk. What are you using to test alk?
 
First, a little upset with your LFS for having you use NoPox in a brand new tank. Sounds like this led to an imbalance.

Second diatoms and dinos can lower alkalinity but that’s typically when you have tons of them. Definitely an interesting phenomenon. Bacterial blooms can also cause alkalinity drops.

I might consider not dosing at all and just doing small water changes to get everything to settle. You shouldn’t need to dose in a tank this young if you don’t have coral.
Thanks for the response.

Yeah, I'm unimpressed by the LFS. I asked them about the Alk dropping and the said to use Brightwell Aquatics Alkalin8.3 instead of Aquavitro eight.four. Looking into it, they're the same thing lol...

By not dosing at all, do you mean NoPox (I'm already not dosing that) or anything at all (including Alk)? The Alk dropped all the way to 5.6dKH before I had dosed NoPox, so the NoPox didn't cause the issue. I added a couple bottles of coralline algae a couple weeks ago, so I would like to maintain the alkalinity. If it drops back down into the 5dKH range would it hurt anything? Fish or Urchin?
 
15 is not necessarily bad for nitrates. 0 is bad.

If you tank is growing coraline algea this would be at least some consumption of alk. What are you using to test alk?
The LFS suggested the NoPox for the Phosphates, but it dropped the Nitrates (as it is supposed to). I now know it was a terrible idea, but trusted the LFS (I don't anymore lol).

Hannah Colorimeters for Alk and Nitrates.

I added ARC Coralline Algae a couple weeks ago, but it hasn't shown up yet, and probably won't for at least a couple months. I know it's there, but I wouldn't think it's there in significant enough quantities to 0 my nitrates.
 
Thanks for the response.

Yeah, I'm unimpressed by the LFS. I asked them about the Alk dropping and the said to use Brightwell Aquatics Alkalin8.3 instead of Aquavitro eight.four. Looking into it, they're the same thing lol...

By not dosing at all, do you mean NoPox (I'm already not dosing that) or anything at all (including Alk)? The Alk dropped all the way to 5.6dKH before I had dosed NoPox, so the NoPox didn't cause the issue. I added a couple bottles of coralline algae a couple weeks ago, so I would like to maintain the alkalinity. If it drops back down into the 5dKH range would it hurt anything? Fish or Urchin?
The alkalinity drop should not cause huge issues. Aqua vitro 8.4 also messes with pH which may be leading to your issues with alkalinity. It’ll raise alkalinity but then can cause other chemistry issues leading to precipitation and declines in alkalinity as it raises calcium. Water changes are your best friend at this point. Don’t try to chase pH it won’t work and it’ll lead to all sorts of problems.
 
The alkalinity drop should not cause huge issues. Aqua vitro 8.4 also messes with pH which may be leading to your issues with alkalinity. It’ll raise alkalinity but then can cause other chemistry issues leading to precipitation and declines in alkalinity as it raises calcium. Water changes are your best friend at this point. Don’t try to chase pH it won’t work and it’ll lead to all sorts of problems.
My pH is actually pretty stable. It stays right around 8.0. I’m hesitant to let the alkalinity plummet. I’m mixing up water for a water change right now.
 
You’ve gotten good advice in this thread. All you need to do at this point are water changes. I wouldn’t dose anything.

Leave things alone and water changes will take care of your chemistry.
 
My pH is actually pretty stable. It stays right around 8.0. I’m hesitant to let the alkalinity plummet. I’m mixing up water for a water change right now.
Sucking up Alkalinity is common in a new tank; Ive set up 7 or 8 over the past 30 years. My new tank is doing the same thing and I'm dosing 20 ml of soda ash solution daily to keep it above 8 dKh. See Randy's 2- part recipe.

Don't bother with the water change, that's not going to help you maintain alkalinity. And I'd stop listening to your LFS, nitrates at 15 in a new tank is great. Mine are staying at 29ppm for a few weeks now; I'm happy with that, I know they will go down as the tank matures. Also, you likely wasted your money on the Coraline solution; 5 week old tanks don't grow Coraline, especially with low and unstable alkalinity levels. Im in San Diego, where are you?
 
Sucking up Alkalinity is common in a new tank; Ive set up 7 or 8 over the past 30 years. My new tank is doing the same thing and I'm dosing 20 ml of soda ash solution daily to keep it above 8 dKh. See Randy's 2- part recipe.

Don't bother with the water change, that's not going to help you maintain alkalinity. And I'd stop listening to your LFS, nitrates at 15 in a new tank is great. Mine are staying at 29ppm for a few weeks now; I'm happy with that, I know they will go down as the tank matures. Also, you likely wasted your money on the Coraline solution; 5 week old tanks don't grow Coraline, especially with low and unstable alkalinity levels. Im in San Diego, where are you?
Hmm, so you think I should keep dosing alkalinity so it doesn’t drop too low?

I’m already mixing up 15 gallons of water. Maybe it’s a waste, but it can’t hurt. ‍:thinking-face:

The coralline spores should survive until it is able to grow (I know it’s true because that’s what the people who sold it to me said :face-savoring-food:).

Wow, I’m really close to you, in Temecula.
 
Last edited:
I have a similar size tank and went through a similar depletion of Alk (I think it was my Marco rocks, sand, bio blocks, etc all equaling out.) Alk started to normalize around the ~ 4 month mark-ish.

If your tank is 5 weeks, I would highly suggest dosing NOTHING for a few months+ aside taking care of the livestock and let the biome develop BUT you might be staring down the barrel of a super not fun shotgun with fully depleted nutrients. Rolling in to an ugly phase that will also have Dinos due to zilch nutrients on top of everything else is just a kick in the…knee. Phyto consumes nutrients as well, but probably negligible w/ how much your dosing.

A reef mat + a skimmer (presume you’re running a skimmer) on a new tank keeps it waaaay to clean for a robust cycle and bound past the uglies in my opinion. I’d consider pulling your reef mat off line and running socks for a while. You’ll know when it’s time to put the roller back online.
 
Hmm, so you think I should keep dosing alkalinity so it doesn’t drop too low?

I’m already mixing up 15 gallons of water. Maybe it’s a waste, but it can’t hurt. ‍:thinking-face:

The coralline spores should survive until it is able to grow (I know it’s true because that’s what the people who sold it to me said :face-savoring-food:).

Wow, I’m really close to you, in Temecula.
That's what I would do, it's just too easy not to and you can control it. As opposed to your small water change. Do this: measure the alkalinity of that saltwater you mixed up, I'd bet it's not over 8.5 and it could be 7 depending on the salt. And what percentage is 15 out of the approx 130 net gallons of water you have with an 8.2 dKh? It's not going to change much at all.

A water change is also going to slightly lower your Nitrates and Phosphates, you don't need that either. In fact you need to shoot for Nitrates about 10 +/-5, Phosphates about .1+/-.05.

Tank start up can vary wildly. I'm at 2.5 months in and have 4 fish, nothing else. Just burning lights very at very low levels enough to see the fish. No algae at all, the rocks are still white, nitates at 29 for the last 3 weeks, Phosphates about .3 on average.
 
I cannot see a reason to not maintain at least 7 dKH by dosing. Water changes are a very expensive way to maintain alk, and many creatures use alk, even snails.
 
Glad to see I'm not alone. I have a brand new tank that continues to drop alkalinity daily. I continue to replace the losses daily with baking soda to try and maintain my alk between 8 and 9 dkh. Sure hope it stabilizes at some point since I haven't even added corals yet. I can't imagine how much alk the tank would burn through at that point.
 
I have a similar size tank and went through a similar depletion of Alk (I think it was my Marco rocks, sand, bio blocks, etc all equaling out.) Alk started to normalize around the ~ 4 month mark-ish.

If your tank is 5 weeks, I would highly suggest dosing NOTHING for a few months+ aside taking care of the livestock and let the biome develop BUT you might be staring down the barrel of a super not fun shotgun with fully depleted nutrients. Rolling in to an ugly phase that will also have Dinos due to zilch nutrients on top of everything else is just a kick in the…knee. Phyto consumes nutrients as well, but probably negligible w/ how much your dosing.

A reef mat + a skimmer (presume you’re running a skimmer) on a new tank keeps it waaaay to clean for a robust cycle and bound past the uglies in my opinion. I’d consider pulling your reef mat off line and running socks for a while. You’ll know when it’s time to put the roller back online.
That’s interesting I haven’t heard this before, what are your thoughts on increasing the biome ?
 
That’s interesting I haven’t heard this before, what are your thoughts on increasing the biome ?
Just letting the habitat/ecosphere meld, strengthen and balance with living creatures, their bi product, nutrients for other bacteria and algae, the light energy and transformations, etc.
 
Hmm, so you think I should keep dosing alkalinity so it doesn’t drop too low?

I’m already mixing up 15 gallons of water. Maybe it’s a waste, but it can’t hurt. ‍:thinking-face:

The coralline spores should survive until it is able to grow (I know it’s true because that’s what the people who sold it to me said :face-savoring-food:).

Wow, I’m really close to you, in Temecula.
I am going to agree with the vast majority of people - stop dosing alkalinity - and double check your test kits - most of the time - it's not necessary to dose with such a new tank.
 
I am going to agree with the vast majority of people - stop dosing alkalinity - and double check your test kits - most of the time - it's not necessary to dose with such a new tank.
The test kits are Hanna Colorimeters. I can check before and after dosing and tell exactly how much I dosed. For example if I’m at 8.0dKH and add 7 tsp of Aquavitro eight.four, if I retest right away, it goes up to 8.7dKH (as expected for my water volume). This demonstrates that the tests are working correctly.
 
I have a similar size tank and went through a similar depletion of Alk (I think it was my Marco rocks, sand, bio blocks, etc all equaling out.) Alk started to normalize around the ~ 4 month mark-ish.

If your tank is 5 weeks, I would highly suggest dosing NOTHING for a few months+ aside taking care of the livestock and let the biome develop BUT you might be staring down the barrel of a super not fun shotgun with fully depleted nutrients. Rolling in to an ugly phase that will also have Dinos due to zilch nutrients on top of everything else is just a kick in the…knee. Phyto consumes nutrients as well, but probably negligible w/ how much your dosing.

A reef mat + a skimmer (presume you’re running a skimmer) on a new tank keeps it waaaay to clean for a robust cycle and bound past the uglies in my opinion. I’d consider pulling your reef mat off line and running socks for a while. You’ll know when it’s time to put the roller back online.
I used Marco rocks and (dry) Caribsea araganite sand. No live rock. And yes, I am running a reefmat and a skimmer. If I turn off the skimmer, it gets cloudy (bacteria bloom?) within a day.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 26 24.1%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 9 8.3%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 44 40.7%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 1.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 27 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new