Best Skimmer for around $1,000

sturgisjasonc

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 4, 2021
Messages
46
Reaction score
8
Location
Grand Rapids, MI
What state or country do you live in
Michigan
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
180gallon DT but total water column is 260-275 with a very heavy bioload. Looking for the best skimmer, low maintenance for $1,000 +\- .

I want my skimmer to be forward compatible when I step up to a 400-500 tank too. Not married to that idea, but it’s what I’m thinking right now.
 
180gallon DT but total water column is 260-275 with a very heavy bioload. Looking for the best skimmer, low maintenance for $1,000 +\- .

I want my skimmer to be forward compatible when I step up to a 400-500 tank too. Not married to that idea, but it’s what I’m thinking right now.
Based on your need for both current and future compatibility, Reef Octopus Regal 200INT or ATI PowerCone 250i would be great choices. They both are highly efficient, have DC pumps for adjustable settings, and are built for larger tanks, which makes them solid options as you scale up to a 400-500 gallon tank. The Bubble Magus Curve 7 could be a good budget choice but may be limiting for your future plans.
 
"Best" is saved for sports. Here (figure of speech) you will get opinions based on experience which sometimes leaves the bias hat on.

One suggestion I'd offer you is to ignore total water volume. I mean yes, take stock of it because that is what you have but don't let that be the deciding factor. More important is consider something that goes beyond that requirement to accommodate future upgrade(s) or changes.

You allocated a decent size budget for a skimmer so you have some options. Whatever you end up with should outlast your time in the hobby. I did similar and am using the same skimmer I purchased in 2000. So far it turned out to be the best money I've spent in this hobby to date.

Good luck.
 
I run a Reef Octopus Regal 300-INT, on a heavily stocked 350gallon total water volume system. I love it. Had a 200-INT before this one, was too small.
 
Adaptive Reef 300

Use the smaller neck insert for now and then if you upgrade, go to the larger neck
 
Reef octopus 250. Very quiet, pulls all the junk in the water, and very easy to clean.
 
180gallon DT but total water column is 260-275 with a very heavy bioload. Looking for the best skimmer, low maintenance for $1,000 +\- .

I want my skimmer to be forward compatible when I step up to a 400-500 tank too. Not married to that idea, but it’s what I’m thinking right now.
Try venturi skimmer, best of ever than any high end needle wheel skimmer.
 
"Best" is saved for sports. Here (figure of speech) you will get opinions based on experience which sometimes leaves the bias hat on.

One suggestion I'd offer you is to ignore total water volume. I mean yes, take stock of it because that is what you have but don't let that be the deciding factor. More important is consider something that goes beyond that requirement to accommodate future upgrade(s) or changes.

You allocated a decent size budget for a skimmer so you have some options. Whatever you end up with should outlast your time in the hobby. I did similar and am using the same skimmer I purchased in 2000. So far it turned out to be the best money I've spent in this hobby to date.

Good luck.
What skimmer do you run?
 
Bashsea 8-24 or 8-30 if enough height in the stand. Rated at 400g on 8-24. Venturi/beckett style skimmer typically they do need a pretty powerful pump to feed them. I am using a sicce 7 on mine. I used one years ago and loved it so got another, they just work no adjusting no tinkering.

Edit. just noticed location, Bashsea is Michigan made too!
 
Last edited:
What skimmer do you run?

Me? I run a Lifereef SVS2-24 in sump with a Cor 20 return pump. In 2000 when I purchased the pump selection Jeff offered was either a Mag 1200 or a Japanese Iwaki. I went with the Iwaki. I use the Neptune Cor now because I also use them for my returns. Since they all use the same fittings I can easily swap them should an emergency arise (I can do without a skimmer for a couple of days). It also helps for maintenance, cleaning.

Prior to purchasing the Lifereef I used a ETSS skimmer. It was good but very finicky with water sump water level and back pressure. Most hobbyist at the time who used ETSS modified them either by removing the bio balls or beckets. I got a bit frustrated with it then moved to the Lifereef after talking to Jeff.

Only other skimmer I have today is a CPR Bak Pak which is used for a 40 breeder that I keep for emergencies. Isolation, grow out, live rock, things like that. It is built well, small, and works. Not viable for your use case.

As I mentioned earlier you set aside a very reasonable budget in my opinion for a skimmer. I personally believe that is great. You should be able to find something that will last your time in the hobby to include upgrades should you do so. I mean that sincerely.

The reason being is that skimmer technology isn't something that is going to change. Find the type you like and if it is over sized run the pump lower or alternate days it runs. Your skimmer need will change as your display matures. By mature I mean number of fish, size of fish, age of fish, feeding habits, and so forth.

TL; DR that is all I was trying to say. Nice budget, find a couple of options, read a bit, read a bit more, then make a decision. Above all remember sunscreen and upgrades. Ok, not the sunscreen (unless it is sunny today) but do factor in upgrade of display. It may save you a couple bucks down the road.

Hope your day is well.
 
Bashsea 8-24 or 8-30 if enough height in the stand. Rated at 400g on 8-24. Venturi/beckett style skimmer typically they do need a pretty powerful pump to feed them. I am using a sicce 7 on mine. I used one years ago and loved it so got another, they just work no adjusting no tinkering.

Edit. just noticed location, Bashsea is Michigan made too!
I’m not hearing great things about the Bashsea skimmers, but I also gather that people don’t know a lot about them. Paralysis by analysis at this point!
 
If $1000 was the strict line, I’d go with the RO Elite 200SSS. Amazing top notch skimmer that saves space in your sump and has 5yr warranty
 
I’m not hearing great things about the Bashsea skimmers, but I also gather that people don’t know a lot about them. Paralysis by analysis at this point!
Yeah its weird you also don't see bad reviews. Bashsea has a much larger internet presence now than in the past but still little good or bad reviews. When I got back in a little over 2 years ago I couldnt believe fish tanks direct carried it, amazon, saltwater fish, but really no reviews. I found someone not happy about the glue job on a sump but didnt want to take the time to bring it to Bashseas attention just bash it on a forum. Well I was happy with my previous 8-30 and I am happy with my current 8-24. Hook them up turn the pump on and they work. Maybe people dont like them because there are no adjustments. "If I am paying $1000 for that I better be able to play with it!" These used to have a little bit of adjustment but people were using it incorrectly to how it was designed and actually hurting performance so Steve removed the "adjustability".
 
Another vote for Reef Octopus Elite here. I'd go with the 200 if you have strong mechanical filtration or the 220 if not. A properly sized skimmer for this tank will be overloaded with double the volume and bioload.
 
Another vote for Reef Octopus Elite here. I'd go with the 200 if you have strong mechanical filtration or the 220 if not. A properly sized skimmer for this tank will be overloaded with double the volume and bioload.
I ended up going with the SRO 6000
 
Another vote for Reef Octopus Elite here. I'd go with the 200 if you have strong mechanical filtration or the 220 if not. A properly sized skimmer for this tank will be overloaded with double the volume and bioload.
I ended up going with the SRO 6000
 
Yeah its weird you also don't see bad reviews. Bashsea has a much larger internet presence now than in the past but still little good or bad reviews. When I got back in a little over 2 years ago I couldnt believe fish tanks direct carried it, amazon, saltwater fish, but really no reviews. I found someone not happy about the glue job on a sump but didnt want to take the time to bring it to Bashseas attention just bash it on a forum. Well I was happy with my previous 8-30 and I am happy with my current 8-24. Hook them up turn the pump on and they work. Maybe people dont like them because there are no adjustments. "If I am paying $1000 for that I better be able to play with it!" These used to have a little bit of adjustment but people were using it incorrectly to how it was designed and actually hurting performance so Steve removed the "adjustability".
I ended up going with the SRO 6000
 
Based on your need for both current and future compatibility, Reef Octopus Regal 200INT or ATI PowerCone 250i would be great choices. They both are highly efficient, have DC pumps for adjustable settings, and are built for larger tanks, which makes them solid options as you scale up to a 400-500 gallon tank. The Bubble Magus Curve 7 could be a good budget choice but may be limiting for your future plans.
Extremely undersized given the OPs constraints. I run a RO 200 EXT on a 100 gallon system and wouldn’t dream of anything smaller being enough.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 15 17.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 6.0%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 8 9.5%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 6.0%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 13 15.5%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.9%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 21 25.0%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 8.3%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new