VanDalsenReef
Valuable Member
Does anyone know if these are same gfo high capacity
Brs gfo vs kolar gfo
- Thread starter VanDalsenReef
- Start date
- Tagged users None
There are only a few places in the world that make GFO. I have no idea what Kolar is, but usually the regular stuff is all the same and the high capacity stuff is all the same. It is mostly just rebranded with different names with different prices.
OP
OP
VanDalsenReef
Valuable Member
They like the biggest company for gfo I believe. So exactly what you were saying. Thank you for the help. Saving like 12 bucks this way.
Willhersh34
Community Member
I’m using Kolar for the very reason you seem to be. The manufacturers are using identical stuff then rebranding it. The Kolar is readily available and cheaper from Amazon. And since I’m a prime member (who isn’t these days) free 2 day shipping. I love BRS but I also like saving a buck or 2. Go figure.
I am saying that it is very likely that BRS just resells the same stuff at a mark up. I have some GFO. I bought a 5 gallon bucket of it unbranded from eBay or Amazon (I forgot, it has been so long) and it works just like Rowa or any other GFO out there. I have never seen anything compelling to spend more on GFO.
Gfo is gfo. I just buy the least expensive I can find.
I also just use regular not HC.
I also just use regular not HC.
Dang! GFO has gone up. The last 5g bucket that I bought was like $149 and now it is $285 for generic, $300 at saltwater aquarium and $320 for BRS. Wow! Glad that I don't need much of this.
FWIW - I would buy the generic stuff if I was buying.
FWIW - I would buy the generic stuff if I was buying.
Willhersh34
Community Member
Same with everything these days. I’m sure some law of supply and demand crap from Econ 101 applies here but it boils down to how much is tied up in shipping delays right now. World gone mad. Lol. I think I last got a few oz. on Amazon for like $20 which I’m sure is upper marked up but it is what it is.
PeterC99
Solarbenchmark.com
Excellence Award
Reef Tank 365
NJRC Member
Hudson Valley Reef Keepers
Hospitality Award
My Tank Thread
My Aquarium Showcase
Curious - why do you say use regular GFO and not the high capacity stuff?
It is less expensive if you buy like 10lbs. That said I run a fuge in my frag system and a remote fuge on my 80. I dont use any po4 reducing media anymore.
I don't think that the average person will get the most out of the high capacity with either too long of run times or using it passively. Even if it is used correctly, you need to use less to not pull too much out of the water. In the end, it always seemed like a push to me if you used it right and a waste if you did not.
Reefin' Alaska
Active Member
They could be the same, I have no idea. All I know is I have some Kolar HC that I ordered off Amazon to try, because it costs so much to ship stuff here and it was free to Alaska. A couple days of it in my reactor and it was in my filter roll and all over media bags. I've used the BRS stuff for years and never had an issue with that. Perhaps an error on my part, I didn't do anything differently, but I've used GFO for a long time and never had that happen before.
Similar threads
