Credible Online Fish Stores - Who's best??

Sdoutreefer

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
1,173
Reaction score
453
Location
Idaho
What state or country do you live in
Idaho
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've been cruising the interwebs for a credible, dependent online store for some invertebrates (tuxedo urchins, mainly). Are there certain companies to stay away from?
 
Check out Reefcleaners.org. Doesn't look like they have any in stock currently but you can set up an alert.
Great livestock and have never had any issues with them.
 
This place has a cult like love of reefcleaners.org so either they must be really really good or it is an elaborate prank to get me to buy from them.
 
I’ve gotten some really good and healthy inverts from Top Shelf Auqatics last week ( Iv e ordered there before), stomatella snails, nassarius snails, collonista snails, dwarf red and blue leg hermits and trochus snails with no losses.
 
Ive had a VERY long history buying from Fosters and Smith/Live Aquaria..
My take: I give them a C+ /B- …
Too many skinny anthias, chromis and or borderline fish..
I wouldnt buy any “expert only” from them, all that means is dead in a week

Saltwaterfish.com I give a B- good fish in general, my experience with bordeline species like sensitive anthias, regal angels, et …I would pass

Very Decent luck with KP over the “other Florida vendor” …you will probably need to quarantine the fish, pass on their creole wrasse

For delicate pricey fish I would stick with the two or three “Premium Vendors” that quarantine (Dr Reef et) …
 
Check out Reefcleaners.org. Doesn't look like they have any in stock currently but you can set up an alert.
Great livestock and have never had any issues with them.

The only issue I have with them is they list crabs as available for non-overnight shipping. I always have 2-3 dead on every shipment.
 
Check out Reefcleaners.org. Doesn't look like they have any in stock currently but you can set up an alert.
Great livestock and have never had any issues with them.
Thank you!

Anyone else...? Surely there's quite a few of you out there who buy online :cool:
 
Thank you!

Anyone else...? Surely there's quite a few of you out there who buy online :cool:

Reefcleaners for inverts. There are other options, but reefcleaners has been around for a long time. They keep a fishless system so you don't have to worry about ich transmission. Their prices are fair. I have NEVER had an issue in terms of DOA or anything else they didn't make right. Other places are also okay, but they are the gold standard to me.

For fish...I avoid most like the plague. I either order from somewhere that dropships from ORA/BIOTA (captive bred, low disease/health issue risk) or order from Dr. Reefs/Ocean Devotion/TSM Aquatics/Marine Collectors (Pre-QT). To me, buying fish from your average online retailer is worse than buying from your LFS. At least at the LFS you can see the condition of the fish. Pre-QT places increase your chance of success, but $$$. I've come to learn its worth it, unless you want to become a DIY marine vet.
 
I've been browsing there stuff. Pretty good, eh?
They are really reliable. They have a massive coral grow warehouse across the street that they grow all of their corals! They dip and qt all of their fish and treat them all with great care. Great selection too!
 
Reefcleaners for inverts. There are other options, but reefcleaners has been around for a long time. They keep a fishless system so you don't have to worry about ich transmission. Their prices are fair. I have NEVER had an issue in terms of DOA or anything else they didn't make right. Other places are also okay, but they are the gold standard to me.

For fish...I avoid most like the plague. I either order from somewhere that dropships from ORA/BIOTA (captive bred, low disease/health issue risk) or order from Dr. Reefs/Ocean Devotion/TSM Aquatics/Marine Collectors (Pre-QT). To me, buying fish from your average online retailer is worse than buying from your LFS. At least at the LFS you can see the condition of the fish. Pre-QT places increase your chance of success, but $$$. I've come to learn its worth it, unless you want to become a DIY marine vet.
By pre-QT you mean they do the QT right? I could also read that as from them before they QT them so just checking.
 
Reefcleaners for inverts. There are other options, but reefcleaners has been around for a long time. They keep a fishless system so you don't have to worry about ich transmission. Their prices are fair. I have NEVER had an issue in terms of DOA or anything else they didn't make right. Other places are also okay, but they are the gold standard to me.

For fish...I avoid most like the plague. I either order from somewhere that dropships from ORA/BIOTA (captive bred, low disease/health issue risk) or order from Dr. Reefs/Ocean Devotion/TSM Aquatics/Marine Collectors (Pre-QT). To me, buying fish from your average online retailer is worse than buying from your LFS. At least at the LFS you can see the condition of the fish. Pre-QT places increase your chance of success, but $$$. I've come to learn its worth it, unless you want to become a DIY marine vet.
Ok I’ll check all them out! I’m more so curious on inverts as well as coral. My LFS quarantines all fish stock that enters his store, and he won’t sell any fish, until he goes 2 weeks without a death… that two weeks is AFTER his 30 day quarantine. It’s really awesome; takes so much pride in his work.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHAT DO YOU ALWAYS RUN OUT OF AT THE WORST TIME?

  • Salt mix

    Votes: 17 18.9%
  • Fish or coral food

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • Test kits or reagents

    Votes: 9 10.0%
  • Filter media or replacement fleece

    Votes: 5 5.6%
  • RO/DI filters or supplies

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • Fragging and repair supplies, like glue or epoxy

    Votes: 10 11.1%
  • I keep a backup of everything

    Votes: 23 25.6%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 7 7.8%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new