Dino outbreak

  • Thread starter Thread starter jdpeters
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None
For the OP as you can tell opinions and advice in treating dinos and the basis for that advice vary widely. Dinos aren't just one thing, they are a class of organisms. Some have free swimming phase that allows UV to be effective, some don't.

Having gone through dinos a couple years ago they can be one of the most frustrating things a reefer faces. Partly because there's really no one thing you can do. Best advice I can offer is to do research and start with the easiest recommendations and proceed down the line.

Another piece of advice that isn't popular that I'd wished I had followed. A tank reset. Everyone will say that's not fixing the problem. But I lost all but one soft coral and all but one fish and then because everything was so out of balance had a GHA issue that took out the last corals. Could a reset have been worse?

Do the first level of things you'll find. Should include blackouts, sand bed vacuuming, nutrient control etc. But once you get to the point of adding poisons think carefully.

Good luck. It's frustrating as all heck but many of us have been there.
 
For the OP as you can tell opinions and advice in treating dinos and the basis for that advice vary widely. Dinos aren't just one thing, they are a class of organisms. Some have free swimming phase that allows UV to be effective, some don't.

Having gone through dinos a couple years ago they can be one of the most frustrating things a reefer faces. Partly because there's really no one thing you can do. Best advice I can offer is to do research and start with the easiest recommendations and proceed down the line.

Another piece of advice that isn't popular that I'd wished I had followed. A tank reset. Everyone will say that's not fixing the problem. But I lost all but one soft coral and all but one fish and then because everything was so out of balance had a GHA issue that took out the last corals. Could a reset have been worse?

Do the first level of things you'll find. Should include blackouts, sand bed vacuuming, nutrient control etc. But once you get to the point of adding poisons think carefully.

Good luck. It's frustrating as all heck but many of us have been there.
I appreciate everyone who has feedback but bums me out when it gets a little nasty.
I didn’t think I would have this problem but unfortunately my dry rock and bare bottom, it’s new and unbalanced. It’s also interesting that it happened all at once it feels like. I had nitrates, polyp extension and the few corals I had were growing. I bring home some new fish, they die 2 weeks later and the 2 original inhabitants also peace out.

I think currently I’m going to try to get my nitrates and phosphates up and go from there. Unfortunately I have candy canes that have damaged tissue and my leptoseris that was doing great is losing color.

If all my corals kick the bucket is it possible just killing the lights and getting some testable nitrates a possible improvement?

To your point I’m not totally interested in a restart but between already owning 28 tanks, 4 kids and being gone 3 days a week I’m thinking that having a high rev tank isn’t the best option for me at this point in my life. I’m seriously considering changing spectrum, adding live sand and rock from tampa bay aquatics. Then persuing a flowly softy tank.

Additionally, I’m not going to ever add new fish again to a sensitive new reef tank. I have the room for quarantine in my fish room.
 
I blew off the rocks yesterday and now I’m two neonitro doses in. There is significant reduction in bubbles from Dino’s but obviously it could be unrelated.

Thanks for the feedback. It’s funny cause the last time I set a reef up, over 5 years ago obviously Dino’s were a thing but it seems to be even more prevalent. I thought I wouldn’t have an issue with jt. But here I am and now I’m at risk of losing all my livestock
 
Could a possible approach be do a large water change, scrub all the rocks. Siphon out as much of it as possible and change the socks

I blew off the rocks yesterday
I highlighted your two quotes because that is the solution. Daily blowing the rocks and cleaning the socks, cleaning the pumps often so flow is strong, and weekly WC to remove detritus on the bottom. It will take a while but it will work….i would add a few soft corals and inverts while you’re fallow. My tank is just a year old and I used dry rock also; vigorous and consistent maintenance got me through the ugly phase, no dosing needed. You can lightly feed the corals and inverts which will provide all the nutrients you need.

2 pictures a year apart of my reef, so you understand my advice doesn’t come without success…

Edit: didn’t realize you are bare bottom so I replaced sand with bottom, so during WC remove all the crud..

IMG_3574.jpeg
IMG_0807.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I highlighted your two quotes because that is the solution. Daily blowing the rocks and cleaning the socks, cleaning the pumps often so flow is strong, and weekly WC to remove detritus on the bottom. It will take a while but it will work….i would add a few soft corals and inverts while you’re fallow. My tank is just a year old and I used dry rock also; vigorous and consistent maintenance got me through the ugly phase, no dosing needed. You can lightly feed the corals and inverts which will provide all the nutrients you need.

2 pictures a year apart of my reef, so you understand my advice doesn’t come without success…

Edit: didn’t realize you are bare bottom so I replaced sand with bottom, so during WC remove all the crud..

IMG_3574.jpeg
IMG_0807.jpeg
That’s quite the transformation. It’s a bummer losing livestock but I’ve learned a tremendous amount. The tank is a bit smelly, I’d like to fix that other than that I’m happy to have some algae and snails for the being. I have so much going on I can’t give anything 100% my attention.
I’m seriously considering ordering sand from Tampa bay aquatics once I get past the Dino’s and ditching barebottom. Ryan batchelor has been praising systems that include it for so long, there has to be something to it
 
Running a good amount of carbon should help with the smell as well as removing toxins from the Dino’s. I’ve heard great reviews with Tampa bay sand. Considering seeding my new tank with it this time around
 
Running a good amount of carbon should help with the smell as well as removing toxins from the Dino’s. I’ve heard great reviews with Tampa bay sand. Considering seeding my new tank with it this time around
Have you ever heard of Dino’s killing fish? I’m starting to suspect that it’s what took my fish out but honestly I didn’t think I had that much in my tank at the time
 
Yes depending on species. Some emit toxins. Dinoflagellates are responsible for "red tides" along the coasts. Was at the beach once in Florida during an episode. Horrendous smell from the algae and the dead fish. Never forget it.

And if not directly toxic they can indirectly by creating anoxic conditions.

And then if you treat the tank with something toxic to kill the dino and your fish are already weak from the dinos and treatments that can do it as well.
 
Yes depending on species. Some emit toxins. Dinoflagellates are responsible for "red tides" along the coasts. Was at the beach once in Florida during an episode. Horrendous smell from the algae and the dead fish. Never forget it.

And if not directly toxic they can indirectly by creating anoxic conditions.

And then if you treat the tank with something toxic to kill the dino and your fish are already weak from the dinos and treatments that can do it as well.
I’m starting to suspect it killed my fish and corals. I think the system is starting to recover after scrubbing, blowing it off the rocks, cleaning the socks and dosing phosphate and nitrate. It’s starting to not smell bad anymore and smell’s more like a gentle reef smell.

Dosing phosphate and nitrates seems a little counter intuitive and I’m basically testing daily. I’m thinking I might go a different direction with this tank. Ordering sand from Tampa Bay Saltwater and ditching barebottom might be my next step. Increasing my CuC with the addition of a urchin and dedicating the tank to softies
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new