Dino outbreak

  • Thread starter Thread starter jdpeters
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

jdpeters

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 20, 2015
Messages
933
Reaction score
477
Location
eatonville washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I’m next to certain I have Dino’s. It’s a series of bubbles, some of it stringy and snotty. Additionally my reef tank doesn’t smell good and it’s making my living room not smell fresh.

Newer system, less than 5 months. I had hair algae and possibly a bit of diatoms. I then had a parasite take out my 4 fish. My nitrates were always low, less than 5ppm and phosphate between .01 to .03. Once I lost my fish everything was immediately out of control. Sps started to look ticked and retracting polyps and lost color.

Could a possible approach be do a large water change, scrub all the rocks. Siphon out as much of it as possible and change the socks. In addition to start dosing N and P? I only have a few corals left and I’m afraid my whole system is heading for disaster. I don’t want to add any fish to the system for 90+ days and obviously buying corals right now would be at a lost
IMG_0491.jpeg
IMG_0490.jpeg
 
Borrow a microscope from your LFS and post the pic of the slide. Find out what you have, then plan the treatment.
You can also go to Macks FB page. All they do is help folks deal with Dinos.
 
Looks like It but the only way to really make sure is to get it under a microscope and identify which Dino’s you have. A UV would work wonders unless you have Large or Small Cell then it’s useless.
 
Borrow a microscope from your LFS and post the pic of the slide. Find out what you have, then plan the treatment.
You can also go to Macks FB page. All they do is help folks deal with Dinos.
Is there any Amazon equivalents for a micro scope? I know that identifying which specific type is important but short term is raising my nutrients and trying to filter it out a good plan?
Looks like It but the only way to really make sure is to get it under a microscope and identify which Dino’s you have. A UV would work wonders unless you have Large or Small Cell then it’s useless.
I don’t have a good UV currently but have a manifold set up for it. I have a small green killing machine UV
 
Borrow a microscope from your LFS and post the pic of the slide. Find out what you have, then plan the treatment.
You can also go to Macks FB page. All they do is help folks deal with Dinos.
Is there any Amazon equivalents for a micro scope? I know that identifying which specific type is important but short term is raising my nutrients and trying to filter it out a good plan?
Looks like It but the only way to really make sure is to get it under a microscope and identify which Dino’s you have. A UV would work wonders unless you have Large or Small Cell then it’s useless.
I don’t have a good UV currently but have a manifold set up for it.
 
Yes raising your nutrients is the first step. No water changes for the time being and use activated carbon
This is the 4th reef I’ve set up, I’ve never dealt with Dino’s before. It’s so frustrating I’m on the verge of losing everything. It’s nearly like having a total restart. I have sps losing flesh now too. It seems odd dosing a system with only like 3 corals remaining that are doing well
 
You don’t need anything but your eyes to identify filth. Clean the algae with turkey basting, toothbrush brushing and WC. 5 ppm no3 is not low, stop dosing it’s algae fuel….
 
Tell me about it I’ve been fighting the small cell kind that can’t be killed with UV. It’s the hardest longest battle I’ve ever had to deal with in this hobby. I’ve been silicate dosing bacteria dosing for over a month now it’s 70% better at this point. Half my corals are doing bad loosing tissue. I just bought a new tank and I’m 100% certain I’m going fowlr for years this time around or until I feel I have a good bio diversity and even then I’m only doing soft/lps. I’m thinking starting off with dry rock and low nutrients caused my situation
 
Chsub is right no more dosing no more water changes. Nutrients should be on the high side as well phos .05-1 nitrates 5-10
 
Silicate feed diatoms, diatoms are food for dinoflagellate…try sound reef management and not potions.
Diatoms vastly outcompete Dino’s for space. It’s one of the few strategies that actually work fighting large and small cell Amphidinium
 
Chsub is right no more dosing no more water changes. Nutrients should be on the high side as well phos .05-1 nitrates 5-10
WC is fine imo, with detritus removal. Every specs removed is sequestered nitrogen and algae fuel. Algae can grow regardless of hobby test kit readings. Better to maintain a clean aquarium with manual removal.
 
Diatoms vastly outcompete Dino’s for space. It’s one of the few strategies that actually work fighting large and small cell Amphidinium
No…dinoflagellate eat diatoms. They are both contributing to the food web. You are relying on “hobby observations”. In anything but a very mature aquarium space is not limiting algae growth…
 
No…dinoflagellate eat diatoms. They are both contributing to the food web. You are relying on “hobby observations”. In anything but a very mature aquarium space is not limiting algae growth…
I’m all ears if you have a better way to go about outcompeting small cell Amphidinium
 
I’m all ears if you have a better way to go about outcompeting small cell Amphidinium
Imo and Ime, any algae can be controlled with manual removal, CUC, low nutrients(less important for experienced reefers)…it’s really that simple. WC with detritus removal, cleaning mechanical filters often, feed fish only what is consumed in seconds is all part of keeping nutrients low. Corals will tell you if they need more food, algae tells you to feed less…
 
Silicate feed diatoms, diatoms are food for dinoflagellate…try sound reef management and not potions.
Factually untrue. The Dinos we see in our hobby are not consuming diatoms causing a worsening Dino outbreak. If this was true, we wouldn’t see early slides dominated by dinos, and after a month of using diatoms to outcompete, slides full of diatoms and few to none dinos. We would continue to see slides full of dinos.
 
Last edited:

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW DO YOU HANDLE HOLIDAY DECORATING AROUND YOUR REEF?

  • I decorate the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I decorate AROUND the tank or stand

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • I add one small seasonal touch but keep it very basic

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I take a holiday photo, but don’t decorate the space

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I leave the reef area as it is

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • We don’t decorate for the holidays

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new