Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Now we are getting closer to some real research on this. Thank you. One of my questions still is ”what is high flow?” Dana gives the value of 3.9 in/sec as high flow rate. I am just wondering what 3.9 in/sec looks like in a tank, since I don’t have a Flo-meter.
Looks like you are going to have to buy a flow meter to validate that the flow in your tank is truly "low" vs "high".Now we are getting closer to some real research on this. Thank you. One of my questions still is ”what is high flow?” Dana gives the value of 3.9 in/sec as high flow rate. I am just wondering what 3.9 in/sec looks like in a tank, since I don’t have a Flo-meter.
Left the flow on when feeding 1 time. Watched a food particle and did the 1 Mississippi thing. More than 3, less than 5 inches/sec, in the middle of a 20g. MP10 at 40%.Now we are getting closer to some real research on this. Thank you. One of my questions still is ”what is high flow?” Dana gives the value of 3.9 in/sec as high flow rate. I am just wondering what 3.9 in/sec looks like in a tank, since I don’t have a Flo-meter.
I don’t know what you want. Do you want research papers that show how water flows over natural reefs? Here you go:Max, I’m not going to get in a ticking match with you, since you obviously can’t or won‘t back it up with an actual research paper, but if you read the article I sent you, they account flow with bringing in cooler water to the reefs, and nowhere does it say directly what you summarized as the previous quote. Here is the actual previous quote you reference directly before the quote I referenced
“High temperature is very stressful to corals,” Rogers said. “If there’s not enough exchange of water from the open ocean, those areas do not do well.”
Not surprisingly, in reef zones around the atoll that had less moving water, coral cover was much sparser, since there was little cool inflow to offset rising water temperatures.
I’m done discussing this with you unless you can provide some actual research links.
So now it’s your turn to show us some evidence supporting your claim. Convince us to turn the pumps off.
From your sourcesI don’t know what you want. Do you want research papers that show how water flows over natural reefs? Here you go:
https://journals.ametsoc.org/downloadpdf/journals/phoc/43/7/jpo-d-12-0164.1.pdf
https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/phoc/39/4/2008jpo3958.1.xml
Do you want studies about how flow affects morphology? Here you go:
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0225676
Here is a series of articles that goes fairly in-depth about why adequate flow is important (it’s not a peer-reviewed study, but it’s in-depth and you’d be hard pressed to find a better series that covers the topic as it relates to reef aquaria).
https://reefs.com/magazine/water-fl...an-light-part-1-introduction-to-gas-exchange/
https://reefs.com/magazine/water-fl...part-ii-the-science-of-corals-and-water-flow/
https://reefs.com/magazine/water-fl...ls-than-light-part-4-basics-of-hydrodynamics/
https://reefs.com/magazine/water-flow-is-more-important-for-corals-than-light-part-v/
Heres the deal though, you’re the one making an assertion. You’re the one claiming that decades of thought and experimentation on water flow as it relates to reef aquaria is wrong. So, the burden of proof is on you. As far as I’m concerned, and I’m sure most experts in the hobby agree, that adequate flow is very important, and that fact is as close to ‘settled science’ as anything can be in this hobby. We know, objectively, that corals receive orders of magnitude more ‘flow’ in the wild than they do in our tanks, that is indisputable.
So now it’s your turn to show us some evidence supporting your claim. Convince us to turn the pumps off.