They are very consistent. Alkalinity has always been a little higher on Hanna than Salifert for me. Not a lot though. Hanna phosphate has been spot on with all the ICP tests that I've done.
I've had my units so long that they are the ppm version for alkalinity and ppm phosphorous one for phosphate. I've used them so long I wouldn't even bother with the conversions if my Apex didn't convert them when I log results. I'm really looking at stability/change even more than the absolute number. Hanna has been very consistent for me, especially the alkalinity one. I can do two tests in a few minutes and will get the same ppm or no more than 1ppm different.