How do you run a tank without GFO/Phosphate Reactor?

Dripping lanthanum chloride into a filter sock via dosing pump. Gives you much more precise control of how much phosphate you are removing and you can fine tune so much easier than a reactor. More consistent too.
 
I don’t run any mechanical filtration. Plus I read that it can harm clams which I have.
Going to stick with NO3:PO4, if that can help me transition off GFO but thanks.
 
I have no problem with phosphate reactor. It is just to have enough low flow to work optimally.
I recommend my customers to begin with a tank volume passing it in a day. This will half the value in one day but at the end the value will stabilize at the amount You add every day. I recommend to fill the reactor halfway up and turn it upside down every week to mix the media. Otherwise its a risk that there will be channels in the media where the water flows and that most media will not be used.
Measure the phosphate value leaving the reactor and You will know when the media is out.
A tank volume a day will be something around 100 gallons a day or 4 gallons per hour or a cup per minute.
You will need a valve at the output of the reactor.
After a month or so it will be time to fine adjust the flow to get the value You want.

NoPox and vodka methods needs both nitrate and phosphate to work. It is usual that one of them goes to zero if You dont measure both. That can crash the tank. They work for small reductions but can not replace water changes.
 
I cannot stand running GFO reactors. The maintenance on them is a deal breaker for me. I drip Lanthanum Chloride into my skimmer neck every couple days to keep PO4 down
 
Even if i run my GFO at the lowest setting, over time it reaches 0.0

I need to turn it off and start dosing carbon i think. Problem is, my nitrate is like 0.5 ppm too.

Not sure about Lanthanum Chloride.
 
The lowest setting on a phosphate reactor is normally many times the correct flow.
A cup in a minute is about the limit between flowing and dripping.
So get a valve and check the flow with a plastic bag on the output from the reactor. If it is hard to adjust the valve get a reduction of the tube down to air line tubing. Often the airline tube will have a flow suitable for a 200 to 300 gallon tank so You will need a plastic air line valve. Tune it in to a cup of waterin a minute for 100 gallons of water and You will have a very different tank.
 
The lowest setting on a phosphate reactor is normally many times the correct flow.
A cup in a minute is about the limit between flowing and dripping.
So get a valve and check the flow with a plastic bag on the output from the reactor. If it is hard to adjust the valve get a reduction of the tube down to air line tubing. Often the airline tube will have a flow suitable for a 200 to 300 gallon tank so You will need a plastic air line valve. Tune it in to a cup of waterin a minute for 100 gallons of water and You will have a very different tank.
Just to clarify, I have a 150 g system using Rowaphos in a reactor are you saying to tune the output to a flow of a cupful of water a minute ?? once the PO4 is where I want it 0.03 ?
 
How low the end value will be is impossible to say. It depends of how much You feed and how much Phosphate it is in the food.
What I know is that with such a low flow You will have a continius lowering of the phosphate value in the tank.
Teoretically it will half the value every day but in practice it will go slower. A lot of phosphate is bound in the stones and will by and by be released as the value sinks.
And I know from a lot of customers that the corals will not be harmed of fast sinking phosphate level.
It will take a month or 2 to reach Your end level. Nothing good happens fast in Reef Aquaria.
 
I recently removed my GFO reactor after running it for years.....my phosphate numbers have barely increased. You just have to adjust feedings, types of food, water changes, etc. to keep your numbers where you want them.
 
I don’t test my water, but I’ve never run any phosphate removers or dosed anything..... You don’t need a reactor for stability
 
I don't run reactor or a fuge and still have low phosphate. I have run both before in the past. reactor kept the levels to low, fuge just didn't seem to benefit for me, it usually collected crap at the bottom of it I missed making the issues worse. I just run a skimmer now in the sump and 1 of the waterchanges a month I use a shop vac to clean the bottom of the sump out.
 
When you add a GFO reactor you also have to check ALK.

Otherwise when you first set it up, ALK can really drop and kill corals.

Also you always want to start real slow with GFO. Even when you replace the media, you are only supposed to replace half. Always go on the low side and check phosphates alot.

I think alot of people make a mistake on how much to put in over time. It's hard to gauge because your first batch of GFO will be used very quickly. After that, the curve settles out and not as much GFO is needed.

I have a bunch of GFO reactors on hand, but am not using any now. I would rather have stabilized ALK for sps. If you can make a tank run without a GFO reactor and use chaeto/macroalgae that is always the better solution. You also aren't constantly dealing with ferric oxide and can save money. It's just more difficult to deal with things like GHA without a GFO reactor.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 13 34.2%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 14 36.8%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 11 28.9%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new