I am lucky enough to have 5 locally-owned brick-and-mortar stores and 4 Petco's doing saltwater within a 40-mile radius. The Petco's are Petco's and everything in there looks unhappy all the time, I try to rescue nems if I can when I can... but let's focus on the local businesses for a moment.
1) The closest, has the best prices for fish but want to charge $50/polyp on some bland Zoa's. They also have a steady supply of used tanks and sometimes equipment. Besides used tanks, they sell almost no dry goods beyond some additives, they don't even sell salt. But, I refuse to go there because it's extremely rundown inside, and every time they get in a new Chromis shipment, they unleash them into the tanks even though it's clear they have Uronema.
2) The next closest store, has decent prices on coral, and ok prices on fish, and a store full of dry goods, some of their display tanks could use some TLC, but overall the store itself isn't bad. However, whenever I go in there, it takes them 30 minutes for them to acknowledge my existence, and they don't even ask if I want any help. I've waited around for over an hour just walking the store with my daughter, waiting for someone to "unbusy" themselves just to help. As a result, I only buy corals from them at their facebook auction prices, even though I would gladly buy fish and other things. People have left facebook reviews about this same thing, and the store owner just backtalks and makes excuses, so their customer service practices will never change.
3) the 3rd closest store to me, smells to high heaven when you walk in, like you've stepped into a skimmer cup, and you can't see inside any of the tanks to know what they have. Walked in, stayed 5 minutes to walk through the store, walked out, never looked back.
4) The fourth store closest to me is about a 30 minute drive, the others are all 15-20 tops, so it's about twice the distance maybe a bit less. They have higher prices for fish than the others by a fair bit, coral prices are reasonable, but the store looks wonderful, the tanks are clear, the fish look healthy, they have a decent amount of dry goods available, and they even take requests like "Any chance you guys can get some macro algae in?". It's excellent. I guess their success may be aided by the fact that it's more than just a saltwater fish, or fish store, it caters to other pets too. But as a result of this combination, I go to this store.
5) Haven't been, may go soon as I hear good things, but store 3 has some of the best reviews around, and I'd rather spend the night in a heroin den than go back.
I've actually been considering trying to open my own store as I feel I could run things so much better, there's obviously a demand for it, and being 40 minutes away from the currently best store in town has got to be a bummer for most people. So, who knows, maybe I'll pull the trigger and try to fill the void in the
market. Local business is a bit scary though.