@paul, I think dry rock craze and NSA thing sorta set the hobby back a few years…
(“art” vs function)
Dry Rock absolutely has its place/value, but to your point: it sells a lot of cultured pods and bottled bacteria…
secondly the rise of the “wall to wall SPS stick tank” and the “bug battle” threads got folks mortified about each and every unidentified bug that shows up…
(the shear volume of “good guy or bad guy” threads is amazing!!!
I can’t imagine the newb of today with ole skool Marshall or Tonga rock…heck they would suffer PTSD if they witnessed all the assorted “crawlies” and pods that showed up for months afterwards
IMO someone is better off buying a pound or two of real bonified Gulf rock than ordering bottle after bottle of bacterial solutions… (place new rock in a BB tanks, pull off crabs, worms, isopods, rinse/repeat for 1-2 months…)