Im glad to know you guys were measuring nutrients pre and post rip clean, good to know they're that effective for the tanks we do want to undo/nutrient sink eject etc.
One thing Im finding as a pattern in the sand rinse thread where we just 100% blast rinse all of them, no matter the presentation, is that though we hammer nutrients in this way via physical export of nutrient stores/particulate organic matter/ its not causing tradeoff invasion like will occur if we leave waste in place then strip nitrate or phosphate with targeting media.
that form of nutrient control is fraught with bleaching, dinos, tradeoff invasions and we specifically do not have that data in the sr thread/handy compare
I can fully understand how someone would want to keep N and P flux in control/modulate the depth and frequency of physical cleaning vs just drop it as low as possible in one swoop. people gravitate towards stability vs suppressing competition microbes/starving them of N and P.
We're still forced to totally clean sand though in home transfer jobs/too many recycle risks for leaving any of the waste. To offset that insult, we ramp up lighting in the new tank/no full production after organics robbing. if someone does want to deep clean or replace sand, just be thorough and dont leave any waste and the whole thing will mix and match with a current reef setup just perfectly.