Is ChatGPT right?

[scaredmantisshrimp]

I recently got a 75 gallon tank and was wondering what to put in it. I talked with ChatGPT for the past three days and this is the list that I ended with. Is it right or is it completely wrong?

• Royal Gramma
• Firefish Goby
• Orange Stripe Cardinal
• Ocellaris Clownfish (x2)
• Blue Green Chromis (x4)
• Starry Blenny
• Ruby Finned Fairy Wrasse (male)
• Purple queen Anthias (1 male, 3 females)
• Cleaner Shrimp
• Scarlet Hermit Crabs (x3)
• Pom-Pom Crab
• Nassarius Snails (x6)
• Feather Duster
• Toadstool Leather Coral
• Kenya Tree Coral
• Green Star Polyps
• Zoanthids
  • HML Red and Green Bouquet Zoanthids
  • HML Bloodshot Zoanthids
• Mushroom Corals
  • HML Black Plague 226 Mushroom
  • HML Toxic Green Rhodactis
• Hammer Coral
  • HML Oddball Splatter Double Hammer
• Clove Polyps
  • Clove Daisy Polyp

 

[DrkNMighty]

List looks fine. I'm not 100% sure on the number of chromis, but I think it is okay. I would also maybe add 1 or 2 more cardinals. You will also want a larger cleanup crew than just 3 hermits and 6 snails.

Purple queen Anthias (1 male, 3 females)

I would select different anthias. I have heard that these are quite finicky and not as hardy as some of the other anthias. I guess this would depend on your experience level.

• Pom-Pom Crab

I would hold until the tank is a little more mature. Their pompoms are anemones which can be sensitive to parameter swings.

Once parameters begin to stabilize I would start with the soft corals and then work your way up to the hard corals. Note that kenya trees, green star polyps, and cloves can easily take over your entire tank unless isolated and watched.

 

[scaredmantisshrimp]

Thank you, in which order should I add the fish and how far in between if you don’t mind

 

[scaredmantisshrimp]

I was also thinking of lyretail anthias but I’m not sure my family won’t let me put the tank in the living room unless the fish look nice

 

[JumboShrimp]

"If" your Chromis survive Uronema, they will probably pick each other off one by one. If it was me, I'd skip them altogether. ;)

 

[scaredmantisshrimp]

Ok

 

[scaredmantisshrimp]

Is this feeding plan good?

Mon	Light feed or skip	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Tue	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + mysis	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Wed	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + algae wafer	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, MagnesiumPM: Amino acids (weekly)
Thu	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + mysis + vitamins	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Fri	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + crushed pellets	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Sat	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Mysis + Nori

 

[BeanAnimal]

AI just repeats what it is read and fills in blanks that match what it has already read (for lack of more detailed explanation. It does not use logic or reasoning in the way that you assume it might

Examine both of those AI responses closely. Why do they differ? Which one is correct?

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

AI just repeats what it is read and fills in blanks that match what it has already read (for lack of more detailed explanation. It does not use logic or reasoning in the way that you assume it might

Examine both of those AI responses closely. Why do they differ? Which one is correct?

You should post something outlandish and see if newly trained AI’s will state it. lol

 

[rhitee93]

The gsp, kenya trees, and clove polyps are known to be pretty invasive. I would urge you to reconsider including those. I had pretty good luck confinging gsp to a rock for a year or so, but I'm glad I have removed it from my system.

 

[Airedale Reef]

Thank you, in which order should I add the fish and how far in between if you don’t mind

I typically like to place 1 fish at a time (unless a pair), and monitor my bio load before adding an additional fish. If you're adding fish to the system for the first time, I think you are fine. I would probably hold off on the clowns or at least put them in last as they can be a bit bullish.

 

[BryanM]

Is this feeding plan good?

Mon	Light feed or skip	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Tue	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + mysis	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Wed	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + algae wafer	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, MagnesiumPM: Amino acids (weekly)
Thu	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + mysis + vitamins	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Fri	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Brine shrimp + crushed pellets	AM: Dose Calcium, Alkalinity, Magnesium
Sat	AM: Flakes/pelletsPM: Mysis + Nori

I am not going to comment on what your feeding, but it absolutely boggles my mind that you might skip or do light feeding on any given day.

Fish need food every day, multiple times per day is almost mandatory in most cases.

This also appears to be in the planning stages, so I think you can safely ignore any calc, alk, mag dosing, you need to get things up and running and see what your consumption is first... Certainly okay to plan, and with data from your tank then you can figure out what to dose.

You would also do well to research all of the items in that list, as others have stated some of these items can be invasive, and indeed hard to rid yourself of after the fact. AI is a great tool, but you need to "own" the information.

 

[BeanAnimal]

You should post something outlandish and see if newly trained AI’s will state it. lol

I was told recently that I lot of whatI post is outlandish :face-with-spiral-eyes:

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley]

I was told recently that I lot of whatI post is outlandish :face-with-spiral-eyes:

Maybe ask it which person types more about bacon than any other. lol

 

[JumboShrimp]

(Maybe we should flood the internet with the sentence, "Most fish don't need water to swim in", and see how long before AI starts including that statement in its 'answers'.) Lol. ;)

 

[fandaga]

TBH, ChatGPT was probably trained on the posts of R2R to come up with these answers…

 

[areefer01]

TBH, ChatGPT was probably trained on the posts of R2R to come up with these answers…

Trained? There is no training.

 

[Besieged]

"If" your Chromis survive Uronema, they will probably pick each other off one by one. If it was me, I'd skip them altogether. ;)

Agreed.

I had (and think still have) the same fish on my livestock plan, but the more and more I read about them, the less and less I think I want them.

The goal was one set of schooling fish with those gorgeous colors, and I was going to do 3 - 4 in my 50 AIO display tank, but between uronema and the fact they seem to like to kill each other off, that's too much stress and money down the drain for my liking - their projected mortality rates are just too dang high.

 

[Goaway]

Purple queen Anthias (1 male, 3 females)

Just find me 2 people, who have kept them alive over 1 year.

Why in the (beep) would that fish be recommended? OH I forgot. It's a bot program!

No queen anthias until you are ready to make a system for that fish.

 

[Featherweight]

I recently got a 75 gallon tank and was wondering what to put in it. I talked with ChatGPT for the past three days and this is the list that I ended with. Is it right or is it completely wrong?

• Royal Gramma
• Firefish Goby
• Orange Stripe Cardinal
• Ocellaris Clownfish (x2)
• Blue Green Chromis (x4)
• Starry Blenny
• Ruby Finned Fairy Wrasse (male)
• Purple queen Anthias (1 male, 3 females)
• Cleaner Shrimp
• Scarlet Hermit Crabs (x3)
• Pom-Pom Crab
• Nassarius Snails (x6)
• Feather Duster
• Toadstool Leather Coral
• Kenya Tree Coral
• Green Star Polyps
• Zoanthids
  • HML Red and Green Bouquet Zoanthids
  • HML Bloodshot Zoanthids
• Mushroom Corals
  • HML Black Plague 226 Mushroom
  • HML Toxic Green Rhodactis
• Hammer Coral
  • HML Oddball Splatter Double Hammer
• Clove Polyps
  • Clove Daisy Polyp

Swap chromis w those rad blue damsels and yeah, pretty much