Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Yes and it has been successful in alot of cases but not all. I use the brightwell aquatics coral dip. I figure it cant hurt if stn starts to affect a piece of coral.Anyone ever done iodine dip for STN?
If it is that prevalent then it would come right back with new corals along with the nitrifying bacteria and everything else. I'm an SPS novice but it seems to be something that is benign until the coral is stressed. The relationship between bacteria and other living things is very complex. We have plenty of bacteria on our skin that could cause problem in an open wound, or gut bacteria that could cause problem if you ate it. STN/RTN must be caused by the coral losing some protective mechanism that allows this bacteria to grow out of control. (again, just an slightly educated guess)Its a specific strain of the bacteria in the vibrio family. Ironically, this turns out to be the most prevalent bacteria family in the oceans and our aquariums. Im curious if its pheasable to completely remove this strain from a system when we have things going in all the time such as fish, corals, invertibrates, etc.
thank youSTN and RTN are two things that we still do not know much about in this hobby. STN/RTN is not a disease but a bacterial strain in our water and in the ocean, one of the most present bacteria in fact. When a factor occurs that stresses or weakens the coral(s) it gives the bacteria a window to jump in causing STN or RTN. Your best bet it to frag the corals but success has also been seen with temp and salinity changes. The bacteria does not like temps below 78 or salinity above 36. When kept under those two ranges many people have been able to recover large colonies.
I am quite sure that STN is not a bacterial disease but an imbalance of deficiency. It is quite typical that it occurs when phosphate concentration is sinking rapidly. Not rising phosphate concentrations are damaging corals but rapidly sinking phosphate concentrations. You can easily tell it when you get corals from a high phosphate system (with coral rubble reactor or phosphate dosing) and put it into a low phosphate system. Corals stop growing and get STN from the base. High alkalinity enhances or causes STN when phosphate concentrations are low.
Do the corals eventually get used to the low phosphate system and then start to grow if you can save them from stn?I am quite sure that STN is not a bacterial disease but an imbalance of deficiency. It is quite typical that it occurs when phosphate concentration is sinking rapidly. Not rising phosphate concentrations are damaging corals but rapidly sinking phosphate concentrations. You can easily tell it when you get corals from a high phosphate system (with coral rubble reactor or phosphate dosing) and put it into a low phosphate system. Corals stop growing and get STN from the base. High alkalinity enhances or causes STN when phosphate concentrations are low.
This is an old topic and your conclusion seems to be right but when we look at new investigation http://cris.leibniz-zmt.de/id/eprint/4590/1/Zhao 2021.pdf than is dosing nitrate a very bad idea?I am quite sure that STN is not a bacterial disease but an imbalance of deficiency. It is quite typical that it occurs when phosphate concentration is sinking rapidly. Not rising phosphate concentrations are damaging corals but rapidly sinking phosphate concentrations. You can easily tell it when you get corals from a high phosphate system (with coral rubble reactor or phosphate dosing) and put it into a low phosphate system. Corals stop growing and get STN from the base. High alkalinity enhances or causes STN when phosphate concentrations are low.
It's a disease caused by many potential factors. STN and RTN are usually caused by bacterial infection. RTN happens to everyone's tank. Healthy corals don't usually get them. Stressed ones are susceptible to bacterial infection. If your corals are still dying slowly you can dip them in antibiotics every day. Because you don't know what bacteria is/are causing the issue you can dip them in sea water mixed with a little bit of wide-range antibiotics like erythromycin and Furan-2. If you are carbon-dosing or dosing any amino acids, vodka, vinegar, etc that needs to stop too.
Yes, but very slowly and I don't know how to improve adaptation. Once they are adapted they grow more slowly but normal. The key is to get new skeletal growth at all. Iodine may help, keeping the iodine concentration rather on the high side at 60 to 100 ppb but on the low side. But this is a bit speculative from my side, some observations but not well tested yet.Do the corals eventually get used to the low phosphate system and then start to grow if you can save them from stn?
Yes, but in the oceans it is a much bigger problem. The problem in the oceans is that nitrate has two effects: 1) It supports algal growth which competes with coral growth for space and nutrients, especially phosphate and 2) it causes direct damage to the corals, especially when they are in short supply of ammonium and phosphate, which is caused by 1)!This is an old topic and your conclusion seems to be right but when we look at new investigation http://cris.leibniz-zmt.de/id/eprint/4590/1/Zhao 2021.pdf than is dosing nitrate a very bad idea?
Yes, for sure! The bad thing is that amino acids also feed opportunistic bacteria, rotting bacteria, which may attack also living tissue when they get abundant. So rather be careful with amino acids.Does the aminos feed the bacteria?
At what point do phosphates start to kill SPS?Yes, but very slowly and I don't know how to improve adaptation. Once they are adapted they grow more slowly but normal. The key is to get new skeletal growth at all. Iodine may help, keeping the iodine concentration rather on the high side at 60 to 100 ppb but on the low side. But this is a bit speculative from my side, some observations but not well tested yet.
For the old part of the skeleton the prognosis is quite bad. I call it the "memory effect of the coral skeleton". Maybe it is the organic matrix, maybe it is the mineral structure of the old skeleton, but something seems to inhibit new growth on the old skeleton when phosphat concentrations drop. The best chance for new skeletal growth is on the growth tips and the growth zones. From there the corals may initiate new growth adapted to low phosphate concentrations.
Yes, but in the oceans it is a much bigger problem. The problem in the oceans is that nitrate has two effects: 1) It supports algal growth which competes with coral growth for space and nutrients, especially phosphate and 2) it causes direct damage to the corals, especially when they are in short supply of ammonium and phosphate, which is caused by 1)!
In tanks in the best case it works as an oxidant like hydrogen peroxide killing cyanobacteria. In many tanks it is just chasing numbers without any effect. The nutrient load in the water is high and, if at all, coral growth is limited and reduced by trace elements. No macro nutrients limiting coral growth, corals hardly make use of nitrate as a nutrient. No nitrate effects to the corals.
Yes, for sure! The bad thing is that amino acids also feed opportunistic bacteria, rotting bacteria, which may attack also living tissue when they get abundant. So rather be careful with amino acids.
I am not sure whether 0.6 ppm of phosphate was really the cause. I have 0.3 ppm in one system without any problems and my colleague had 1 or 1.5 ppm phosphate in a nano, largely without major problems.At what point do phosphates start to kill SPS?
I have two tanks, in one the phosphate got to 0.6 and a lot of my sps started to get STN from the core or base and die.
It may have been above 0.6 that is just the reading i got at one point. But I have AEFW also in the tank and what was happening was they would cause damage and the high phosphate would cause the acro's to get algae growing on the damaged parts of the coral. Some kind of infection would then set in and start to stn. It was only Acropora that were dying due to the super high phosphate levels, other sps were perfectly fine. Not all acro's only some.I am not sure whether 0.6 ppm of phosphate was really the cause. I have 0.3 ppm in one system without any problems and my colleague had 1 or 1.5 ppm phosphate in a nano, largely without major problems.
The problems after moving the corals to a tank with low phosphate is what I would have expected.
Iodine and its ratio to phosphate maybe could be a factor. If iodine is low, increasing the iodine concentrations to normal (60 ppb) to slightly high levels may help.