Is this an Anemone or Duncan?

[BrokenMarrow]

I'm currently at work. I'll let y'all know in about 5 hours. Lol

 

[Miller535]

I'm currently at work. I'll let y'all know in about 5 hours. Lol

Your priorities are all out of whack! J/K. lol

 

[Cell]

It's the same fish!!! Or wait wrong thread....

But seriously, it looks sort of like a nem, but exactly like a Duncan.

 

[BrokenMarrow]

So I poked at it with a knife hard enough to draw a little blood from a person (not sure how to explain how hard I stabbed it) and it was pretty solid. Safe to say it's a Duncan? Which is good, but also a let down. I did have a Majano growing on a shell that my toadstool was attached to and I got rid of the shell. Wish I knew where the source was.

 

[Miller535]

So I poked at it with a knife hard enough to draw a little blood from a person (not sure how to explain how hard I stabbed it) and it was pretty solid. Safe to say it's a Duncan? Which is good, but also a let down. I did have a Majano growing on a shell that my toadstool was attached to and I got rid of the shell. Wish I knew where the source was.

Why also a let down?

 

[tehmadreefer]

Looks like a Duncan now that can see the structure and you said it was hard.

 

[F i s h y]

I now agree with the base that it appears to be a Duncan

 

[Cell]

In hindsight the stabby stabby probably wasnt neccessary, just a little tentacle tickle would have sufficed. Nems and Duncan's do not retract the same way.

 

[Mastiffsrule]

Definitely scrambled eggs zoas.

 

[JJ Ligs]

Ummm that doesn’t at all look Duncan to me. I would say majaon for sure. If it has a skeleton it would have to be the smallest base ever. I have encrusting and branching Duncans and not one of them look this way

 

[tehmadreefer]

Ummm that doesn’t at all look Duncan to me. I would say majaon for sure. If it has a skeleton it would have to be the smallest base ever. I have encrusting and branching Duncans and not one of them look this way

It’s small and growing, lol Duncan’s don’t come with massive skeletal structure the minute they are made. Also a majano doesn’t even have a skeletol base...

 

[BrokenMarrow]

Why also a let down?

I did have a random anemone growing and I was kinda hoping this was a source so I could hopefully end it.

 

[JJ Ligs]

It’s small and growing, lol Duncan’s don’t come with massive skeletal structure the minute they are made. Also a majano doesn’t even have a skeletol base...

They have not said it has a skeleton yet.

 

[sfin52]

They have not said it has a skeleton yet.

He did said it was very hard

 

[JJ Ligs]

I didn’t catch that but I am still on the fence