Macroalgea in a display tank which ones to avoid...

DM address I’ll send and if good refund shipping. Good trial for me 🤣. I don’t want money from selling so just shipping. If it die's in shipping no need to pay.
Thank you so much I sent you the DM
 
Hi R2R peeps. I am thinking about adding some macroalgea to my 125 gallon display tank and would like to see pictures if your tanks have it, or any tips you guys and gals can give me. Any kinds I should avoid? Best ones to try? I do have a chocolate tang and a foxface so it needs to be able to hold up to them.

My cleanup crew will eat most any macro, and the crew include a one spot foxface and a yellow tang, as well as various snails and crabs.

Highly calcified macros are most resistant, such as halimeda, but those may be harder to grow.
 
NO SEA LETTUCE! Stuff started growing on everything, rock, glass, silicone, acrylic. . . .

I assume you mean ulva? I move it up to my display from my refugium and my fish and crabs and snails eat it.
 
Even when nutrients don’t bottom out. Caulerpa is a daily task!
What's so high maintenance with caulerpa?
I have it in my tank and all I need to do is trim it every once in a while (and pull it out when it's about to go sexual, but that hasn't happened to me yet).
 
What's so high maintenance with caulerpa?
I have it in my tank and all I need to do is trim it every once in a while (and pull it out when it's about to go sexual, but that hasn't happened to me yet).
Same mine will go white tipped to full white. Just worried about it going sexual though I just got back from 9 day vacation with several white/dead and no issues. I have Caulerpa ashmeadii not sure if more forgiving or if I’m just paranoid. But I clip daily! Grows fast and follows flow.
 
Try the shaving bush or flat cap algae, snails and tangs won’t eat it. Also something like the atomic broccoli (Augophyllum wysorii) isn’t palatable to snails. My yellow and white tail tang don’t really eat it too
 
Red macros are usually less desirable to herbivores so they may be your best bet. Caulpera may be one you want to avoid as it can grow really fast and won't be touched by most herbivores since it is toxic when eaten.
That stuff is a Nightmare if you let it get out of control and manual removal is a major pain. It just breaks when you pull on it and then pieces migrate around the tank and resettle in new hidden homes. Terrible.
 
Forgot to mention if you have urchins they will eat everything, so I wouldnt house them together.
Also, I think @Nate Chalk has more experience with macro, he might be able to help more.
I have tangs , fox face and urchin.

When I harvest a softball size of chalerupa , it's gone in the hour.

I highly doubt your algae will make it in a main display with plant eaters.
 
That stuff is a Nightmare if you let it get out of control and manual removal is a major pain. It just breaks when you pull on it and then pieces migrate around the tank and resettle in new hidden homes. Terrible.
I feed my tangs and fox face chalerupa? None have died . Eating it gladly
 
Honestly I would say pom pom is nice but I LOVE my halymenia stipitata ( sometimes called orange galaxy or atomic broccoli). Just posted about it but it is a stunning addition to the DT, and you can throw some in the fuge as well to grow fast. This stuff grows so quickly by the time the urchin gets it you have plenty more.. its a built in harvesting mechanism! unless you have a tuxedo like mine and it prefers to take its snack with it as a disguise... and forgets to eat it so it grows like a 70's fro!

1755444041957.png
this was one month ago.....

1755444067762.png
this is this morning. I fight nutrients bottoming out in my nano specifically because of this, but its pretty enough that I just don't care... and this is what it looks like in my 90g. The tangs mostly leave it alone... from time to time my pincushion might dislodge it when it finds a clump, or on even rarer occasion a mexican turbo finds it and starts munching, but mostly everything leaves it alone and it just grows and soaks up nutrients like it's its job...

1755444172282.png
 
I have tangs , fox face and urchin.

When I harvest a softball size of chalerupa , it's gone in the hour.

I highly doubt your algae will make it in a main display with plant eaters.
Thank you i think I will just grow it in a refugium in the sump and feed the extra growth to the tank.
 
Thank you i think I will just grow it in a refugium in the sump and feed the extra growth to the tank.
I have a second tank connected to the same sump that i use a display refugium, I put extra scraps in the sump similarly. :)
 
Honestly I would say pom pom is nice but I LOVE my halymenia stipitata ( sometimes called orange galaxy or atomic broccoli). Just posted about it but it is a stunning addition to the DT, and you can throw some in the fuge as well to grow fast. This stuff grows so quickly by the time the urchin gets it you have plenty more.. its a built in harvesting mechanism! unless you have a tuxedo like mine and it prefers to take its snack with it as a disguise... and forgets to eat it so it grows like a 70's fro!

1755444041957.png
this was one month ago.....

1755444067762.png
this is this morning. I fight nutrients bottoming out in my nano specifically because of this, but its pretty enough that I just don't care... and this is what it looks like in my 90g. The tangs mostly leave it alone... from time to time my pincushion might dislodge it when it finds a clump, or on even rarer occasion a mexican turbo finds it and starts munching, but mostly everything leaves it alone and it just grows and soaks up nutrients like it's its job...

1755444172282.png
Wish I had that growth! Mine is slow to grow. Really not much growth at all. My Pom Pom, Gracillaria, and caulerpa grow daily though. It’s by far the prettiest macro I have though! Would love to have a fuge full.
 
Hi R2R peeps. I am thinking about adding some macroalgea to my 125 gallon display tank and would like to see pictures if your tanks have it, or any tips you guys and gals can give me. Any kinds I should avoid? Best ones to try? I do have a chocolate tang and a foxface so it needs to be able to hold up to them.
I had a bunch of ulva, Pom Pom and caulerpa in my display. My tang ate the ulva and caulerpa and my snails ate most of the Pom Pom. Good luck.
 
As requested in the title I'd avoid caulerpa. It is invasive and will make a mess of your tank.

https://seagrant.oregonstate.edu/sites/seagrant.oregonstate.edu/files/ca-species-guide.pdf
Not with a tang. My caulerpa was growing nicely until my purple tang was added. No more caulerpa
As requested in the title I'd avoid caulerpa. It is invasive and will make a mess of your tank.

https://seagrant.oregonstate.edu/sites/seagrant.oregonstate.edu/files/ca-species-guide.pdf
the tang will eat the caulerpa faster than it grows. Ask me how I know. 🙄🤣
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 20 25.3%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 7 8.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 30 38.0%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.5%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 20 25.3%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new