Microbe communities and shipping

keagan

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 29, 2026
Messages
473
Reaction score
638
Location
Antigonish, Canada
What state or country do you live in
Canada
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Theres a lot of interesting discussion and debate on this site. One of the most interesting debates to me is feeding and it's role in fish health.

Based on the track record of people like Paul B I wonder if many of our issues with new introductions avoiding feeding may be as follows

A hypothesis:

Prolonged fasting and transportation-associated stress in wild-caught marine ornamental fish disrupt intestinal microbial community composition and colonization resistance. Subsequent exposure to nutritionally and microbiologically dissimilar captive diets may impede restoration of the native microbial community, favor the persistence or proliferation of opportunistic taxa, and contribute to prolonged post-transport anorexia in otherwise acclimated fish.

Please give this hypothesis feedback I would like honest opinions. Do you believe the above is supported by current literature? Do you believe it incorrect? Opinion based on anecdotal evidence is still appreciated. This isn't for a research paper this is just curiosity.
 
I'm going to tag the #reefsquad crew on this one as there are some smart people in it, and could provide good feedback
 
Following due to interest, but the gut microbiome topic usually ends up in a very ugly, often unscientific discussion so for now I keep a safe distance 😅

Cat Popcorn GIF by Basecat
 
Following due to interest, but the gut microbiome topic usually ends up in a very ugly, often unscientific discussion so for now I keep a safe distance 😅

Cat Popcorn GIF by Basecat
Hopefully this will just be a few responses to the above hypothesis and doesn't turn into that 😅. I'm not emotionally invested I welcome people saying I'm wrong especially if they provide evidence of why.
 
Hopefully this will just be a few responses to the above hypothesis and doesn't turn into that 😅. I'm not emotionally invested I welcome people saying I'm wrong especially if they provide evidence of why.
I don't think you'd be the problem 🤣

I don't have much here off the top of my head, but you may be on to something, so following along.

Would you think something similar might happen even with tank raised fish since most fish are fasted before shipping?
 
This is an interesting idea, and I could see it working both ways. Here are my thoughts:

1. Indeed, many studies have demonstrated that a healthy gut microbiome can confer benefits to immunity. The gut is also a major potential entry point for pathogens. So if the handling conditions could cause stress that disrupts the microbiome, then perhaps fasting could help prevent the proliferation of harmful microbes. Feeding could do that too - I could just see potential for either scenario. Maybe pro/pre/synbiotics could help too.

2. Weaning a fish onto a new diet is ideal (instead of an abrupt change) but you're right - that's often not an option for wild-caught fish. In aquaculture typically you would start mixing in some of the new diet with the old diet gradually to wean them.

3. I personally don't think I've seen healthy fish refuse to eat solely because of transport. There has always been some sort of issue present, or at the very least they're just stuck on live feed. Refusal to eat is something you hear about a lot with wild marine fishes, but you rarely hear about it with aquacultured fishes. I've seen/heard a lot less about it with wild freshwater fishes too. Saltwater species seem to be tougher to get to eat IME. I've heard many people attribute this to collection methods but it could be something else too.

4. The main issue with shipping is the water quality. I've seen what happens when you don't let the fish purge before shipping (much more mortality). Of course this is related to fish density, water volume, shipping time, etc. The ammonia buildup and oxygen depletion are major factors, and they become much bigger issues when the fish aren't purged.

In summary, you may be right, but I think in practice it's a matter of weighing the lesser of two evils, and maintaining water quality usually prevails. We actually just finished some fish shipping experiments at work, but the data won't be published for a while.
 
I don't think you'd be the problem 🤣

I don't have much here off the top of my head, but you may be on to something, so following along.

Would you think something similar might happen even with tank raised fish since most fish are fasted before shipping?
Thanks 😂. I believe if the above hypothesis is correct that yes that would be likely. The fasting would likely cause a big enough shift in the intestinal community that it would likely affect opportunistic taxa if this above stands as correct. Although there's variables there ie tank raised fish would already be eating prepared food and may have less diversity in the microbiome, different dominant species, less opportunistic taxa, etc.

I think some of this may be easy to test at hobby level but I have never weighed a fish and that would be necessary.
 
Some questions for the community

Do fish that arrive in particularly poor condition tend to have longer-lasting feeding problems, even after their physical condition improves?

Have you ever had a fish that appeared completely settled, behaved normally, and maintained normal respiration but still refused all food?

Do you notice differences in feeding recovery between wild-caught and captive-bred specimens of the same species?

Have you noticed that some wild-caught fish refuse food for extended periods even after appearing to recover from shipping stress?

How long does it typically take newly imported wild-caught fish to begin eating consistently?

Have you noticed differences in feeding recovery between fish shipped overnight and those that spend several days in transit?
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HOW WOULD YOU FEEL ABOUT RECEIVING A FISH OR CORAL AS A HOLIDAY GIFT?

  • I’d love one, as long as it’s a species I chose

    Votes: 19 27.5%
  • I’d trust someone who knows my tank to choose

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • I’d rather get a gift card and pick it myself

    Votes: 27 39.1%
  • I’d prefer gear or supplies instead

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • Please don’t surprise me with livestock

    Votes: 19 27.5%
  • Other (Post in the comments)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Back
Top
Home
Post thread…
Market
What's new