Thanks very much for your further thoughts. I have left on sandbed like you have suggested. There is some suggestion now from the seller that a maybe Phoenix. I’m seeing him tomorrow so I will see what he says.Well if it was a trusted seller then it’s a beach bum in poor conditions, if you aren’t 100% positive with lineage, then just let it sit on the sand bed and wait for it to color. Might be better than a beach bum, or just a single color montipora, which are nice..but not that sought after.