Nori alternatives?

[Mongo1.0]

Love my new tangs, but my wife and I have noticed the smell. The tangs, especially the sailfin, love it, eat and shred it up quickly. We have noticed the smell of the decaying nori and the water is no longer clear as normal.

Is there any recommended alternatives for nori that doesn't cloud up the water or smell as bad?

Thanks for any advice.

 

[Jay Hemdal Verified Community Expert]

Love my new tangs, but my wife and I have noticed the smell. The tangs, especially the sailfin, love it, eat and shred it up quickly. We have noticed the smell of the decaying nori and the water is no longer clear as normal.

Is there any recommended alternatives for nori that doesn't cloud up the water or smell as bad?

Thanks for any advice.

I've never had an issue with the smell - can you change it out more often, and net out any pieces before they can start to decay?

Some of Julian Spring's Sea Veggies have more body to them, so won't break down as easily.

 

[Mongo1.0]

Love my new tangs, but my wife and I have noticed the smell. The tangs, especially the sailfin, love it, eat and shred it up quickly. We have noticed the smell of the decaying nori and the water is no longer clear as normal.

Is there any recommended alternatives for nori that doesn't cloud up the water or smell as bad?

Thanks for any advice.

I've never had an issue with the smell - can you change it out more often, and net out any pieces before they can start to decay?

Some of Julian Spring's Sea Veggies have more body to them, so won't break down as easily.

There isn't really much left after they eat it. Can see fine fibers swirling around in the water. It was recommended to do a half a sheet a day. Maybe go to a quarter of a sheet a day might help some.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

My herbivores eat dulse. Available at Whole Foods and online. Natural, dried leaves of seaweed.

 

[keagan]

I second dulse it won't shred into fine pieces and foul your water and it takes a long time to rot in saltwater. It's also a lot cheaper.

Edit to add: sea lettuce would likely shred a bit but it has no discernable smell. It's also sold for human consumption for cheap

 

[JGT]

My tangs prefer Romaine over Nori. Big advantage is that it doesn’t fall apart and go all over the tank like Nori does. They have to take a bite to eat it.

 

[JGT]

My herbivores eat dulse. Available at Whole Foods and online. Natural, dried leaves of seaweed.

This is a new one for me. Is dulse just a different type of seaweed vs Nori? I see they sell whole leaves or even flakes which might be a cool option.

 

[keagan]

This is a new one for me. Is dulse just a different type of seaweed vs Nori? I see they sell whole leaves or even flakes which might be a cool option.

Dulse is a seaweed that grows here in Canada, the U.S.A, also Japan and europe it's high in iodine, potassium and protein. We grow a lot of it to sell to Japan where I live.

 

[Randy Holmes-Farley Verified Community Expert]

I believe Dulse is also sold by many hobby companies, such as Sprung Sea Veggies (with a markup).

 

[helmsreef]

I would adjust your feeding amount and or fold the nori tightly. Nori or dulse is always going to more nutritionally complete for herbivores.

 

[DmitryB]

BRS has their branded dulse.

 

[Mongo1.0]

My herbivores eat dulse. Available at Whole Foods and online. Natural, dried leaves of seaweed.

Haven't heard of that one. Will look it up. Thank you!

 

[tzabor10]

My herbivores eat dulse. Available at Whole Foods and online. Natural, dried leaves of seaweed.

Just ordered some. Thanks for the recommendation

 

[kratosxxl]

I believe Dulse is also sold by many hobby companies, such as Sprung Sea Veggies (with a markup).

Do you get sheets ? any concerns with using this one ?

 

[keagan]

Do you get sheets ? any concerns with using this one ?

I know you tagged Randy but IMO that's way overpriced. Check the international section at the grocery store or a Chinese grocery store.

 

[kratosxxl]

I know you tagged Randy but IMO that's way overpriced. Check the international section at the grocery store or a Chinese grocery store.

what should i watch out for ? no added what ?

 

[tzabor10]

Do you get sheets ? any concerns with using this one ?

My fish don’t favor that one as much. TLF green and purple are the favorites

 

[keagan]

what should i watch out for ? no added what ?

If it says organic you're good. Most of the products won't have additives. It's already shelf stable after drying so there's no point in adding preservatives. But just in case it's not a bad idea to get organic. Dulse like Randy was talking about is mainly wild harvested and would be even less likely to have additives.

 

[CrewePD210]

This thing right here is money. What gets stuck behind the grid can get scraped off and used on the next round. My foxface and tomini get almost 100% of it though after having it for a few months. Hardly any left, and I put one and a half of the full size sushi nori in it. Last about 3 days.

 

[kratosxxl]

If it says organic you're good. Most of the products won't have additives. It's already shelf stable after drying so there's no point in adding preservatives. But just in case it's not a bad idea to get organic. Dulse like Randy was talking about is mainly wild harvested and would be even less likely to have additives.

is this the one ? If yes how do you feed it ? like magnet holder or something ?